What's new

What is the biggest difference between 2 great guerilla forces (Vietcong vs Taliban)

The talibs are a fringe movement and not the original Mujahideen force that defeated the Soviets. The Vietcong compared to the talibs were a much larger and organized force that had popular backing from large nations and huge support from all over the area. They can be better compared to the Mujahideen pre-Afghan civil war.

For the first time, I have seen someone differentiating between the Mujaheedin and the Taliban - which is a FACT. Kudos for bringing that out, my Jedi roasting friend. You indeed surprise me.

Even many western media sometimes wrongly report that Mujaheedin = Taliban! They are NOT!
 
.
Well , they Both belong to diffrent schools .. TALIBAN are pro Islamist And are Backed by ksa, Uae & pakistan , while Vietcong are belong To Pro Nationlist..
They fought just for vietnam..and Taliban are willing to Fight with whold world.

They are spot on Islam , They were Backed by USA itself .
 
. .
What comparison?

One was fighting for their country.
Later is fighting with every country for nothing.
 
.
The Taliban is seriously overrated. They revel on the fact that they 'defeated' soviets and now its Americas turn. The Soviets would have shot these guys skyhigh if it was not for the American backing. When it comes to America, they are very sensitive about their world image. Otherwise a couple of B-52 raids like what they did to the Ho Chi Minh Trail is enough to convince the Taliban who is the boss. Betterstill nuke the whole country and call it "Mission Accomplished".
 
. . .
I guess the matter here is not TTP but Afghan Taliban.
I see no difference between them-Both are scums.The only difference is one is targeting Pakistan and other is Afghanistan.So if you're supporting one branch then you should support other branch too unless you explicitly support terrorism in afghanistan.
 
. .
Talibans are sick people.I am glad i don't live in a Taliban Governed Country.Black Blood if it was not for USA support to Groups during Soviet War these sick people would have been blown to bits by Soviet Union.VietCong was a professional militia.Don't compare it with Taliban.If they inflict damage any where near to VietCong levels to American Forces All AMerica has to do is carpet bomb everything.They're taking advantage of American's kindness nothing else.



[/COLOR]

No Pakistan Government does not support Taliiban and rightfully so.GOP will kick Taliban arse as it did in Swat, SW and soon NW and please don't malign Islam by saying Tailban are islamic.They follow backward tribal laws.

sir Taliban were carpet bombard by Usa and Allies , since 2001 or so bt it didn't put Affect on their health,
and plz dnt get mixed Pakistani Bad *** Taliban with afghan once. Even Supreme commander of Afghan talib denid their link with Bait ullah Mehsud & co.
Afghan talib's are freedom fighters they are fighting for freedom of their country while Pakistani So-called Talibs are Rebel's..
 
.
They are spot on Islam , They were Backed by USA itself .

no Man talibs were just by pakistan Army and were heavily funded By Ksa And Uae Sheikh's and Govts..
Question: How can A Talib from Madrassa drive A Tank And Fly A Jet?
 
.
sir Taliban were carpet bombard by Usa and Allies , since 2001 or so bt it didn't put Affect on their health,
and plz dnt get mixed Pakistani Bad *** Taliban with afghan once. Even Supreme commander of Afghan talib denid their link with Bait ullah Mehsud & co.
Afghan talib's are freedom fighters they are fighting for freedom of their country while Pakistani So-called Talibs are Rebel's..

Yes, yes.
Thank you.
And THAT attitude is precisely why Pakistan is in the mess it is in.:agree:
 
.
Militarily speaking Taliban will never be able to inflict the amount of damage Vietcong did to American forces.

Otherwise we would be seeing daily carpet-bombings and even the use of chemical weapons something which was normal in Vietnam.
 
.
Also on the same note, tactically speaking the taliban are forced to operate under daunting conditions. Overhead hundreds of drones are operating, some armed with hellfire missiles and they can call in Spooky air raids and helicopters filled with special forces within minutes. Vietcong had access to Soviet AA guns and sometimes inflicted damage on the USAF, routinely forcing them to transport troops under heavy escort as the helicopters were being brought down in the hundreds. Taliban can't do this, by the time American forces land on the ground to face any kind of numerous opposition, the area has been leveled by above and artillery. The taliban can only dream of bringing down airplanes or helicopters these days, especially since countermeasures are very effective against rpg's. So the best they can do is lure in the ground forces. Here they have had one regrettable success...they adopted many tactics from Iraq such as the IED. Still casualties have been remarkably low for ISAF and heavy for taliban. New recruits are lured in by talks of Islam and dollar and kalashnikov, there aren't people like me there to tell them that these guys are a death cult and the reason why Allah's wrath is on them.
 
.
The talibs are a fringe movement and not the original Mujahideen force that defeated the Soviets. The Vietcong compared to the talibs were a much larger and organized force that had popular backing from large nations and huge support from all over the area. They can be better compared to the Mujahideen pre-Afghan civil war.

Mujahideen also has support from Saudi Arabia and rest of GCC, USA, Europe, Pakistan and China. The actual mujahideen retired after war and went to serve in army of their respective countries. Saudi Arabia imported large number of Afghan pukhtoon and nationalise them to server in their armed forces as doctors, pilots, instructors and trainers. The current day talibans are those walking in the shoes of popular culture. They in essense are no different than those in the west wearing Che t-shirts and smoking pot not exactly knowing why.

and this picture is just epic

hh43fewilliamarobinsons.jpg
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom