What's new

what is solution for political crisis between administration and judiciary

what is solution for current political crisis..( assuming that people will vote for PML N again)

  • 1. Make nawaz sharif the "sharif/king" thus above law , or make him chief excuetive

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • 2. fire the judiciary

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 3. give party president immunity against all crimes (like president of pakistan)

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • 4. give all parliamentarian and lower house members immunity

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 5. restrict power of judiciary so it cannot do self references/notices(PMLN 2018 manifesto)

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • 6. completely abolish NAB and any accountability organisation

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 7. pray that punab doesnt vote for PMLN again

    Votes: 9 45.0%
  • 8. other

    Votes: 6 30.0%

  • Total voters
    20
people of Pakistan will vote for PMLN and they would make a law allowing criminals to walk free to help nawaz sharif than also cutting judicry right to do self notice or here any case against law makers..judiciary will not accept a law which defies common sense..PMLN will refuse to obey......choas will ensure..

Well, that will require 2/3rd majority in both the house.. which PMLN will not be able to get ever..

Actually, after 2020, PMLN will be there as a party (or one of the 2-3 factions of the party), but Nawaz and Maryam will be either in UK or in Pakistani jail..
 
.
The best solution is to burry the doctrine of necessity (nazariya -e - zaroorat) and keep judiciary away from whats app calls , keep agencies away from court rooms , keep the fan families of judges away from court rooms. "Justice must not only be done but seems to be done" a famous quote is the right thing to follow. Courts must give decisions based on solid grounds and past legal practices. For a case of political person court must not introduce any new examples , actions etc like whats app call, JIT formation, monitoring judge of SC , six months trial period, preliminary references, supplementary references, God father novels, disqalification of all Pmln senate candidates, first time in legal history even after apology Nihal sentence etc .Decisions must be to a highest quality that at least the legal fraternity at least is satisfied with the verdicts. For example a PM is disqualified on the basis of black law dictionary which on consulting even does not consider the un withdrawn salary as an asset , countries law does not consider it as an asset and courts indulge in forming new examples. In this scenario , courts will lose its credibility and the historian had always been very cruel as no contempt proceeding is applicable on him .
All conpiracy theories with no proof all we need to is punish those who do corruption by the billions and treat politicians from all provinces in the same fashion no more ladla beuaviour for punjab why is law different for Nawaz Sharif and Sharjeel Memon?
 
.
so far it seems "if" such an establishment exist it wants justice..the best PMLN supporter can argue is why is the justice selective to PMLN but one cannot argue its not justice

Actually, this is the first time Shareefs are facing real cases.. and not being allowed to runaway on technical grounds.. so naturally it will look like selective justice to them..
 
.
All conpiracy theories with no proof all we need to is punish those who do corruption by the billions and treat politicians from all provinces in the same fashion no more ladla beuaviour for punjab why is law different for Nawaz Sharif and Sharjeel Memon?
yes but unfortunately you cannot , whole pakistan state has bowed down in front of Rao Anwaar so it is impossible to punish all corruption cases.
 
.
All conpiracy theories with no proof all we need to is punish those who do corruption by the billions and treat politicians from all provinces in the same fashion no more ladla beuaviour for punjab why is law different for Nawaz Sharif and Sharjeel Memon?

These conspiracy theories will have to die down if Pakistan has to move forward.. and they will die... :D
 
.
so far it seems "if" such an establishment exist it wants justice..the best PMLN supporter can argue is why is the justice selective to PMLN but one cannot argue its not justice

Absolutely Not; Justice could be done to PMLN Exclusively..No issue.
In Politics, Its a two edge sword anyway and cut both ways simultaneously, we know how to get benefit of it.
IMHO, PMLN comes out more strong from this selective justice...in the longer run.
 
.
i dont support any party..this thread is not about politics but about how to finish current stand off between PMLN and judiciary

first this isnt going anywhere, we are kind a stuck here..per Gallop polls, by polls, even though PTI is all time high its still not famous enough to get votes in sindh or punjab....PMLN will still win in Punjab and form govt again..

how long can this crisis continue between judiciary and parliament..?

every Pakistani knows that if we do very tight (imran khan style) accountability than obliviously every one will end up in jail, this cannot be done as people dont want this level of accountability..?

so whats the solution...?

PMLN thinks the solution is in legislation to limit judiciary power(Talal chaudary)..but what if judiciary throw out such rules, bureaucracy has refused orders, what if police refuse orders..what will happen..so who is going to implement orders..will we become a bigger laughing stock in country like Afghanistan where governor refuses to go down?

will army be asked? but what if army say this is not our job(which is right), people are going to support their leaders, so will judiciary be forcefully taken down by police on orders of parliament?

will nehal hashmi warning make judicary back off ? afterall they should be worried about their salary as well..

or will the rare event happen and people of Pakistan/civil society support judiciary?

There is no crises law implementation and criminals / crooks needs to be made example of
 
Last edited:
.
yes but unfortunately you cannot , whole pakistan state has bowed down in front of Rao Anwaar so it is impossible to punish all corruption cases.
Rao Anwar will face a similar fate as that of Abid Boxer lets hope his facilitators will face a similar fate
 
.
can you explain, who the establishment is..in medicine i call this "displacement disorder" blaming everyone else...
you think that a hidden hand is forcing judiciary to lie about PMLN, isnt this exactly what PML N is saying

i would have understood your point if Mr Nawaz sharif and maryam nawaz were clearly people of middle class but having properties of billion of dollars it doesnt make sense to me, i mean my father is grade 22 officer, he cannot afford a corrola how come maryam nawaz afford a BMW that is registered as a honda


Its actually registered as a Honda CD70 motorcycle

Also what PMLN supporters would never acknowledge is that their leaders have not provided any documentation to prove that all their wealth is Halal. All they have to show is a letter from a Qatari Prince who himself is accused of money laundering and was also listed in the Panama Papers.

And the reason they have come up with this imaginary hand of the establishment trying to exert some kind of revenge is because they have no other way out of this mess.
 
.
yes but unfortunately you cannot , whole pakistan state has bowed down in front of Rao Anwaar so it is impossible to punish all corruption cases.
not the state the admin has...state is trying to punish roa anwar the admin(likes of PML and PPPP) is protecting him..same is abid boxer

Its actually registered as a Honda CD70 motorcycle

Also what PMLN supporters would never acknowledge is that their leaders have not provided any documentation to prove that all their wealth is Halal. All they have to show is a letter from a Qatari Prince who himself is accused of money laundering and was also listed in the Panama Papers.

And the reason they have come up with this imaginary hand of the establishment trying to exert some kind of revenge is because they have no other way out of this mess.
is any other society the qatari letter would be used agianst them as a bribe ...exception is our society


so main theme shows PMLN will either cut NAB or judiciary..this should "solve" current crisis and ensure smooth 2018-2023 tenure
 
.
Again, you are turning towards optics; Corruption, which by yourself admits does by everyone from a street cobbler to a security colonel. This is not the issue for ordinary public which are more wise and see things beyond mirrors. Establishment with IK&Co drumming it past 8 years from all rooftops and see where they ending up finally....Lodhran.

The Issue, my dear Zia here is "Authority". PMLN asking of it to exercise independently what its given in the Pakistani Constitution and denied by the ME continously for past 70 years to civilians. This cannot be more simple from that.
Lets take ur suggestion seriously for once and analyze it. So lets say ME is defeated and nawaz sharif emerges as victorious. What will be Pakistan of tomorrow?
- PmLN winning 2018 election
- Nawaz as 4rth time prime minister
- shahbaz as CM punjab
- sharif family cleared of all allegations
- PTI down and dead
- PP already dead
- ME defeated
- Parliment will makes law to makes changes to appoint judiciary and army designations from birgadier level
- SHARIFS BECOME UNTOUCHABLES

Do you see whats going to happen?

- End of democracy in Pakistan
- End of Judicial system in pakistan. May be Danish Courts outside CM punjab house will be new justice system
- Start of civil Marshal Law in Pakistan. This time may be for infinite because ME will be down and dead. No one to challenge it
- End of any chance of any accountability against most powerful
- ME role as balancer finished
- One party, One leader, No opposition

It will be Zia Era again, With people behind a truck light!!

Its a fashion in Pakistan to oppose ME to save democracy. But unfortunately currently ME is trying to save democracy and biggest democratic Party of Pakistan PMLN is showing exactly anti democratic behavior by conspiring against state institutions and decisions
 
. . . . .

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom