What is possibility of Modi triggering 3rd war with Pakistan?

[Dillinger]

I will give it between 5 to 10 years. So you should make it and back before that

Boori nazar wale tera mooh kala.

 

[MST]

Boori nazar wale tera mooh kala.

Sach bolne wale pe duniya julm hi karti hai

 

[RazPaK]

LoL. Indians know nothing will happen to Pakistan, but we can't stop you from dreaming. Make sure Kashmir doesn't fall out of your hands while you are seeing these fantasies Indians.

 

[Sugarcane]

I will give it between 5 to 10 years. So you should make it and back before that

That's enough time for formation of Greater Punjab, making India & Pakistan it's provinces and enforcing marshal law forever - no more politicians, no more screw ups.

 

[Jackdaws]

This is not just a question but an concern. Modi is leading a hate centric campaign in India and likes to receive those applauds when he exhales enmity towards Pakistan. His past record showed how chaotic he can when he enjoys power and control.

How likely do you see Modi getting into power and if he does (which seems possible) how likely do you find India initiating another war with Pakistan specially when power-balance has leaned more towards India over the past decade. With Modi getting into power, I have several reasons to think that India will itch for another war with Pakistan.

Zero. Mostly because it is safe to assume that he can't time travel. The third war between India-Pakistan was in 1971 preceded by wars in 1965 and 1948.

 

[Water Car Engineer]

Modi has no balls to attack other Muslim country rather attack unarmed muslim civilian in his own country.

He has bad dreams about him being enslaved by Muslim for 1000 years...

I swear those, invaders brain f**ked you guys good, it's so hilarious. 1000 years later the children of the enslaved are praising their oppressors.

 

[SBD-3]

Modi is a fanatic but not a dork. Its a logical conclusion that any war with Pakistan will take more toll on India than Pakistan since India has accumulated hostilities all around her. And Indian policymakers certainly know it (though die-hard Indians here don't). That's precisely why Indians kept quiet as the Chinese intruded 10KM? into disputed territory.

One take away from this is that Indians have permanently institutionalized their extremism through BJP.

 

[janon]

Zero. Mostly because it is safe to assume that he can't time travel. The third war between India-Pakistan was in 1971 preceded by wars in 1965 and 1948.

They tend to ignore that particular war and pretend that it never happened, and also pretend they won all the other wars. Their narrative goes like this:

1948: Pakistan conquered half of Kashmir from India. (Reality being that India stepped in AFTER Pakistani tribesmen and lashkars occupied and pillaged a third of Kashmir, and then India prevented the rest from being occupied by pak.)

1965 : One muslim equals ten hindus, so the tiny Pakistan won against the much bigger India. (Reality being that THEY started a war to capture Kashmir, and ended up desperately defending Lahore instead.)

1971: Huh? What? I don't remember anything happening. (When pressed further, they will mumble something about a war somewhere far away. The reality being that their eastern half was clipped away, and East pakistan surrendered lock, stock and barrel because the west was also in mortal peril of being overrun.)

1998: Nothing happened, we didn't fight. Oh well, maybe somebody fought, we think it was non state actors. Oh wait, some of our soldiers may have fought as well, so we'll give them a few bravery awards. Oh, you know what, we took point 5353 and won the war, poor India just hasn't realized it yet.

Present condition: We have more insurgents and terrorists than we can control, we cannot keep up with the latest tally of attacks, so let's request all of them to organize themselves and build offices for themselves and take over our country, while we fantasize about a grand "third" war with India, a ghazwa-e-hind where India splits into several pieces and Kashmir eagerly joins us.

That's the Pakistani version of Indo-pak history, so you have to excuse them for not remembering the third war where they got split into two, never to recover.

Anyway, on topic, Modi (or anybody else) cannot start a war even if he wanted to. The Indian government doesn't work that way, it is not a presidential system, no single person can take such momentous decisions as going to war. The prime minister, the cabinet of ministers and a large section of the parliamentarians have to agree on it. Whether Modi is PM or Sushma or Vajpayee will make no difference, at the end of the day, a lot of people will collectively make that decision. It is a real democracy, where the armed forced indirectly obey the will of the people, through the elected representatives. No single human being has the power or authority to order the armed forces to go to war. Not the PM, not the president, not the service chiefs. If India goes to war, it will be a collective decision, not the whim of the person who happens to be in power.

Now coming to Modi himself - it is a misconception of Pakistanis that he is some devil incarnate with a deep hatred for Pakistan. Pakistan has never been a political or electoral issue in India for any major party, and nobody has ever come to power by promising to go to war with Pakistan or badmouthing pakistan. Despite what they may have been led to believe Modi is a very able administrator, and a shrewd politician. Going to war will not be on his priority list. It is my guess that he would try his best not to let things go to the point of war - which is what all previous Indian governments have done as well.

And despite the belligerence seen on this forum from some Indian members, the fact is that India as a whole does not have any warmongering or pugnacious tendencies. As a nation, India is much more content to enjoy the glories of peace than the spoils of war. There has never been a "let's go to war" mood in India, and going to war is not seen as the ultimate nobility for the country. Pakistanis are projecting their own nation's psyche and mentality on to India, when they think that a "strong leader" (which is what many people expect Modi to be) necessarily means a warmaker.

 

[Guynextdoor2]

Modi is a fanatic but not a dork. Its a logical conclusion that any war with Pakistan will take more toll on India than Pakistan since India has accumulated hostilities all around her. And Indian policymakers certainly know it (though die-hard Indians here don't). That's precisely why Indians kept quiet as the Chinese intruded 10KM? into disputed territory.

One take away from this is that Indians have permanently institutionalized their extremism through BJP.

That will not be his conclusion

Chances are zero. He's playing politics to attract hindutvadasi votes. He'd be getting cold chills when he finds out about Pakistani strategic force posture, in his declassified security breifing after becoming the PM.

Buddy...one thing about modi- he won't be scared about your strategic posturing, he will be well prepared, he will win the war.... And in the end that won't solve any problems for anyone either.

 

[Alfa-Fighter]

LoL. Indians know nothing will happen to Pakistan, but we can't stop you from dreaming. Make sure Kashmir doesn't fall out of your hands while you are seeing these fantasies Indians.

Lol this is what you dreaming in since 1947, but forget kashmir you lost Bangladesh, now what you wanna loose? balochistan ? Ground realities and history tell that its pakistani who dreams most.

Modi is a fanatic but not a dork. Its a logical conclusion that any war with Pakistan will take more toll on India than Pakistan since India has accumulated hostilities all around her. And Indian policymakers certainly know it (though die-hard Indians here don't). That's precisely why Indians kept quiet as the Chinese intruded 10KM? into disputed territory.

One take away from this is that Indians have permanently institutionalized their extremism through BJP.

thanks why India now raised one attacking Corp for china , to give them taste of their own medicine. time shifts and things change.

 

[rockstarIN]

Post reported

No use, he is the next candidate as MOD.

 

[Kompromat]

Buddy...one thing about modi- he won't be scared about your strategic posturing, he will be well prepared, he will win the war.... And in the end that won't solve any problems for anyone either.

If he won't be scared than its bad luck for Indians. If he attacks Pakistan, we will unleash hell. We have always been crystal clear about our intentions.

 

[doppelganger]

If he won't be scared than its bad luck for Indians. If he attacks Pakistan, we will unleash hell. We have always been crystal clear about our intentions.

I think you do not give us enough credit. We will make Modi ji see reason. There are proven better ways of engaging with Pakistan.

 

[footmarks]

If he won't be scared than its bad luck for Indians. If he attacks Pakistan, we will unleash hell. We have always been crystal clear about our intentions.

Good luck to you "hellites"

 

[onionkiller]

oh my god i thought pakistani dont care about modi ji but on pdf they always talks about him. to my pakistani friends modi ji is good for both of country. there wil be peace on border, bcoz tight security on indian borders. and modi ji is bussiness minded leader. so more business among both of country. friends india can progress at very high rate in bjp's govt. you dnt know about this. under vajpayee's govt we have seen super fast develpment. why you my pakistani friends afraid of modi ji ? imo you should think how both country make better econmy in modi ji's govt. @Aeronaut. sir we should give peace a chance. war is last thing .you are very senior member, u should promote peace.