I voted for Conditional offer.
Condition being a plebesite in whole of Kashmir, as nothing else is required of them. Cannot think of anything else that we want them to do. But this will never happen as the current government is too right wing or any future government for that matter, will not accept this condition either I believe.
The risk for India is too if a referedum was to happen, as they know that Kashmir would demand succession. On the other hand, running a newly independent country would mean starting from scratch. All banks and financial centres that Jammu and Kashmir are connected with, are based in Delhi/Bangalore. So only option would be to join Pakistan if the results shows that majority wants to separate. For this reason India wouldn't want to go in a situation where they might end up losing JnK.
I will say what Hamza said in his interview with the Indian channel, see this as a human issue and not as a race for land or battle of nationalisms. We as Pakistanis support Kashmir's succession but we also understand that no country wants to lose its territory and would do anything to keep it intact. India is big enough but they wouldn't support a referendum in one state as it can have a domino effect in rest of India, as separatist parties will get leverage and momentum to galvanise their movements for independence. This is what I studied in my last year of IR studies in Indentity and Territory module. So I am aware that Indian dynamics when it comes to JK are a lot more complicated then what meets the eye.
But again, Kashmiris are as human as the rest of your people and I do get a sense from Indians (I have met them in real life) that they see their region as troublesome and have turned a blind eye because the Army is involved in this and they dont want to criticise their actions as its a respected body and symbol of nations pride.
We are just onlookers whatever happens with humans anywhere in the world cannot be changed by our protests or debates unless the nation itself gets up to rebel against the regime.