What happens when a muslim prays in a public area in US

[Hindustani78]

I am asking whether this can happen in any Islamist countries? You know that respect is a two way street..

If American Muslim, American Hindu, American Jew is praying in America than what this has to do with any Islamic country ?

 

[Dubious]

If you do not understand what I am trying to say then why bother quoting me?

Sorry did you not manage to read what I quoted you to read:

American Muslim is praying in America . What this has to do with Saudi Arabia, India or any other country ?

 

[Waqar Rashid]

We had some hindus and sikhs living in my village with us. We hadn't any problem with their prayers.

 

[Iggy]

If American Muslim, American Hindu, American Jew is praying in America than what this has to do with any Islamic country ?

So you think only American muslims or an American Hindu can pray in America? I am talking about religious freedom.. Can we expect that in any of the Islamist country?

 

[Kloitra]

The point is that nobody has the right to block a public right of way for others due to their own private ritual. It is inconsiderate at best, illegal at worst, and totally unnecessary given that other alternatives are easily available.

I have seen Muslim praying in public places, even at my work place. It is hardly conceivable that they block the way of others. Generally the person devout enough to pray in public is concious enough to not interfere with others. A little consideration towards them isn't a big deal.

Again what this has to do with other countries ?

The video is about how people treating when a Muslim in praying in public.. Can you imagine anything like this happening in Saudi Arabia or any other Sharia implemented countries?

That is a wrong question. The problem is between people, and not something legal.

Muslims are not so considerate towards other religions. As an example, Muslim majority countries mostly mix religion with state, restricting other religions. Besides, they have achieved a lot of negative publicity. Is it so wrong that other religions or even atheists too develop a negative feeling for Muslims?

 

[Iggy]

Sorry did you not manage to read what I quoted you to read:

Great for me you quoted Hindustani78 comments!!

 

[Hindustani78]

So you think only American muslims or an American Hindu can pray in America? I am talking about religious freedom.. Can we expect that in any of the Islamist country?

The thread is about American praying in public area and here you want to talk about religious freedom of some other country.

 

[VCheng]

I have seen Muslim praying in public places, even at my work place. It is hardly conceivable that they block the way of others. Generally the person devout enough to pray in public is concious enough to not interfere with others doing so. A little consideration towards them isn't a big deal.

Consideration is fine, and only to be expected in a civilized society. But it still does not give anyone the right to block public rights of way, like I said before.

 

[Hindustani78]

Muslims are not so considerate towards other religions. As an example, Muslim majority countries mostly mix religion with state, restricting other religions. Besides, they have achieved a lot of negative publicity. Is it so wrong that other religions or even atheists too develop a negative feeling for Muslims?

This is according to you which up to some extend unfair from your part.

 

[Iggy]

The thread is about American praying in public area and here you want to talk about religious freedom of some other country.

It was not about American praying in public.. If this is what you think it is, then whats the point of opening a thread for it.. The thread is about religious freedom Muslims enjoy in a western country.. The same religious freedom is denied to other religious people in most of the Islamic countries.

 

[Dubious]

Great for me you quoted Hindustani78 comments!!

Why retype something already available and said to you before?

It was not about American praying in public.. If this is what you think it is, then whats the point of opening a thread for it.. The thread is about religious freedom Muslims enjoy in a western country.. The same religious freedom is denied to other religious people in most of the Islamic countries.

1st Tell me how does a Christian/ Hindu pray in "Public"

 

[Hindustani78]

It was not about American praying in public.. If this is what you think it is, then whats the point of opening a thread for it.. The thread is about religious freedom Muslims enjoy in a western country.. The same religious freedom is denied to other religious people in most of the Islamic countries.

Thread title. What happens when a muslim prays in a public area in US

Second thing , that Muslim is a western national and here first thing you are denying the right of that person and making him seperate from the rest.

 

[Iggy]

1st Tell me how does a Christian/ Hindu pray in "Public"

Why cant a Hindu or Christian pray in public?? Dont you see some one read a bible in public?? What kind of questions are you asking?

 

[Hindustani78]

1st Tell me how does a Christian/ Hindu pray in "Public"

It can be in the form of preaching and doing yoga etc in public gardens .

 

[livingdead]

We had some hindus and sikhs living in my village with us. We hadn't any problem with their prayers.

if they were using public place meant for other purpose, its wrong. besides village is a different place from cities. Cities have very high footfall in public place.
If I park a car on side of a road in village, no problem, In a city, that can cause big problem.