What Ganesha means to a Muslim like me

[SarthakGanguly]

War .. No war our love gor beef . i mean cow is unconditional ..

Okay. Anything else? On topic?

 

[Irfan Baloch]

There you have it.

How is it different then to the dargahs of Shias and Sufis.

Or the rock at Kaba?

I really don't get this "idol worship" frothing frenzy.

I agree with your point. not for being politically correct or being "pro Indians" as some jackasses here think I am. but lets agree we will avoid this discussion.


it is the discussion like this which I respectfully ask all members here to avoid
look at my signature too
prevention is much better than cure even though some very valid and logical debate is sometimes prevented here due to the fact that people abuse the freedom and use the opportunity to show their hatred from within them.

 

[Echo_419]

Though the picture is a beautiful display of religious harmony I would like to say that lets not to to link Hindu Gods and figures with Islam. It is most of all annoying rather than a clear threat to Muslims though it is a threat at times when Islamic version of events are removed in favor of Indian version. However this policy has constantly been used by India to direct Muslim thought and boast the superiority of Hindu religion. There is no mention of Ganesha in Quran or Hadith and these are defined as idols-seriously no offence intended at all as I respect Hindu brothers.

Linking islamic concepts, ideals and figures to Hinduism seems aggressive to us muslims. It seems that India is trying to take over our rich distinct history.

You are insecure

 

[Bang Galore]

i have answers but i will not go to your level

I understand. That would involve a lot of climbing.

 

[Maarkhoor]

So far....no one in this thread has abused Islam or called names.....
On the other hand you guys called me idiot,illiterate,dot head what not
I.dont give a damn

I am not the one who called you.

 

[vsdoc]

I agree with your point. not for being politically correct or being "pro Indians" as some jackasses here think I am. but lets agree we will avoid this discussion.


it is the discussion like this which I respectfully ask all members here to avoid
look at my signature too
prevention is much better than cure even though some very valid and logical debate is sometimes prevented here due to the fact that people abuse the freedom and use the opportunity to show their hatred from within them.

Irfan believe me getting into religion is the last thing I want to do this time.

But what is the point of bashing Hindus and their customs man?

Why can't faith be kept to a personal thing between a man and his God?

My intention is not to offend in any way. But to poke holes into shallow bigotry. Be it of any hue. Saffron, white or green.

 

[45'22']

I am not the one who called you.

You said we stooped low
The fact is no one did


Anyways...i am off
Happy Ganpati to all ( to all hindus and non hindus)
may the lord bring happiness to your life

 

[Irfan Baloch]

Irfan believe me getting into religion is the last thing I want to do this time.

But what is the point of bashing Hindus and their customs man?
.

the word jackass was used for those who mock other faiths and then demand the respect for the same faith as mine and report the posts of those who are not Indians.

for me Mocking any faith including Hindu faith is exactly the same as mocking my own Muslim faith.
its a basic teaching of Islam that anyone mocking other's faith earns two sins... one for mocking the belief of other person and then another one when the other person mocks Islam as a response.

such habit is most retarded and brain dead when a person is so defensive about his own faith that he doesnt even want others to even talk about it as a matter of fact but in the same breath wont spare a moment to mock the practices of others.

I sound like a broken record but if it was up to me I will punish any Muslim mocking other faiths as if he has Mocked Muhammad PBUH or Quran.

please accept my apologies that someone has been born in a Muslim faith and therefore sees it a birth right to mock your faith.

Note: a Jackass here will say that well does it not apply to Hindus too? why do they mock Islam. my response is... Jackass listen i am not Hindu.. I wont speak for them.
I will only talk from my side and talk about the pilocks who actually invite hatred and mockery to my faith through their jackass attitude.

this is the most off putting tendency I see among people (all sides, corners) here and really kills the whole motivation to log into the forum

 

[Spring Onion]

Well Ganesha means nothing for a Muslim but Ganesh Chaturthi, the festival may means a lot to all mahrashtrans including Muslims.

anyway being Indians irrespective of faith the Muslims may respect the sacredness of the deity

 

[Irfan Baloch]

Well Ganesha means nothing for a Muslim but Ganesh Chaturthi, the festival may means a lot to all mahrashtrans including Muslims.

anyway being Indians irrespective of faith the Muslims may respect the sacredness of the deity

Muslims are advised to do so as per Islamic teaching . its only polite and a civil thing to do in a multi faith society

 

[unbiasedopinion]

What about that. A one pic a one article..explain below

As usual trick by some trolls to spoil a beautiful thread with their utter nonsense.

 

[Irfan Baloch]

So far....no one in this thread has abused Islam or called names.....
On the other hand you guys called me idiot,illiterate,dot head what not
I.dont give a damn

wrong attitude
you should give a damn (not being abusive)
but by feeling sorry for such people and praying/ wishing that such offenders gain some basic social skills to interact in a civilised manner.

Muslims give way to hindus to peacefully take the ganesh idol whereas hindus silently walk down the road not distrubing the namaz... this is real incredible India

people who are part of TTP now are those who used to throw boiling water, stones, spit and even shoot at shia processions during their their days of mourning.

a mutual respect or tolerance at the least just shows your own good heart.

 

[Maarkhoor]

I am not talking about what you think happened with Allah
You are not geeting my point....
It is not mandatory.to slaughter a cow.....here people have.slaughtered other animals during festives.....
If it can happen then i feel it should be enforced because it goes with both religion....

Gov isnt banning slaughter of animals....its banning only slaughtering of .cows.....

@Irfan Baloch
This person asking me a reference where Allah order to slaughter a cow i post reference and see the response.

There is no Allah....
Let the people live they want to live it....

I dont have a problem if a hindu eats beef simillarly you shouldnt have problem if a muslim wants to follow hinduism...
You have no right.to.judge

@Irfan Baloch

 

[vsdoc]

please accept my apologies that someone has been born in a Muslim faith and therefore sees it a birth right to mock your faith.

Your post is like a breath of fresh air my friend.

And believe me, you should be the last person to apologize on anyone's behalf.

I've been on this forum long enough to know each and every guy (or girl) here and understand well where they are coming from.

Yes the so called newbies as well who believe they are unknown entities to me. Because reading some posts of some "new" IDs, it feels a lot like PDF has really not gotten any new membership since 2012. Old wine in new bottles.

Bigotry is ugly. And it is poorly disguised at the best of times.

My message is simple. Please speak to people here as you would if you were face to face with them.

If you still feel that what you are saying would not embarrass your socks off in a real life situation, well then please go right ahead.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Maarkhoor]

Declare WAR on the cows...

@Irfan Baloch

Do you.eat all halal.meet....
Say dog,rats,cockroaches....i.dont know which is halal sorry.....

The point is you dont

@Irfan Baloch

There you have it.

How is it different then to the dargahs of Shias and Sufis.

Or the rock at Kaba?

I really don't get this "idol worship" frothing frenzy.

@Irfan Baloch