What Bangladeshi People Think About India & Pakistan | Dhaka University

[newb3e]

Bhai aap sahi ho me ghalat hon.

sahi galat toh pata nai but chashma bhool gaye kia ajj?

 

[El Sidd]

sahi galat toh pata nai but chashma bhool gaye kia ajj?

Aap roz subah uth kar dhaka ki taraf dekh kar maafi Manga karo

 

[newb3e]

Aap roz subah uth kar dhaka ki taraf dekh kar maafi Manga karo

lols why? my family lost everything in 1961 wesay but still for me Pakistan is naymat of Allah!

 

[El Sidd]

lols why? my family lost everything in 1961 wesay but still for me Pakistan is naymat of Allah!

Allah deta hai leleta hai.

Uski marzi

 

[Bilal9]

No you didn't get it.

Are Chinese and Senegalese the same people?

Only you think it is about racial superiority because you are projecting your own racism on to others.

We are merely stating a historical fact that Pakistanis and Bangladeshis are different people which is why you separated from us because of your racist and ethnocentric mindset of Bangali Nationalism.

Now stop begging us to accept you because it looks pathetic and desperate. Bangladesh has nothing of significance to offer Pakistan, we do not need to seek your assistance for any reason. You went your way and that's that!

Again - appreciate the amusement.

You notice I'm the only one that cares enough to reply? Out of all the Pakistanis I have ever known, a section of the PDF lot is the strangest. Way out of ordinary. No prizes for guessing who they are.

I don't get where you are finding these supposed 'differences' between Bangladeshis and Pakistanis and 'ethnocentric mindset of Bangali Nationalism'. Have you ever even known educated Bangladeshis personally? I doubt it. A little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

Some guy will now stoop to posting cherry-picked pictures of ugly people from Bangladesh, as if they don't exist anywhere else. You guys take the cake.....

People in Bangladesh could care less.....there are over twenty some odd thousand textile experts from Pakistan working in Dhaka and remitting income to Pakistan. If we were that ethnocentric, how could they live and work there?

And we won't solve our differences of mindset over here. this has gone on long enough - let's just agree to disagree, shall we?

 

[knight errant]

Your fellow countryman kept on insisting that Bangladeshi people are one and same as Pakistanis, same heritage I just refuted that no we are not the one & same we are genetically different, culturally different, linguistically different, if that is not correct then please correct me with some evidence.

First of all, no Bangladeshi member claimed Pakistanis and Bangladeshis as same people. We are different(no doubt about that), but it's like the difference between an Italian and a Norwegian or a French.
According to your post Pakistanis and Bangladeshis must be alien to eachother, as they are Linguistically different:

Something must be wrong in this tree! How two totally different languages like Bengali and Punjabi are in the same cluster??

Culturally different:
Culturally every south Asian ethnic groups have their own unique traditions, but these traditions were born out of some common traditions. Bangladeshi culture is a hybrid between eastern Indo-Aryan culture(mostly Buddhist heritage) and Islamic culture, Pakistani culture is divided in two parts, The Punjabi/Sindhi culture is western Indo-Aryan(Hindu and Sikh heritage)/Islamic hybrid, the Pashto/Baloch cultures is a mix of eastern Persian culture and Islamic culture.
You and your countrymen denying very simple facts, how on earth the difference between Pakistani and Bangladeshi is same as the difference between Moroccan and Pakistani
Or Chinese and Senegalese(i laughed on this one)?? Moroccans dont speak Indo European language so they have nothing in common with Pakistanis linguistically. For example, An Amazigh guy from morocco has more in common with an Arab from Yemen than a Turkish, even though they have different cultures and languages(though Arabic and Berber languages are both Afro-Asiatic). Like South Asians also their genetical structures(not components) are different, for example both groups have some Sub Saharan African admixture, Amazigh people got from ancient West Africans but Yemenis got from Northeastern Africans.

Genetically different:
Yes there are genetical difference between Pakistanis and Bangladeshis, but you cant deny that Pakistani people(including Pashto/Baloch) descend from the same early humans as Bengalis or other Indic people.These early people of both western and eastern Eurasian origin expanded and intermixed between them to form modern south Asians, for example Bengali race was born out of a western Eurasian race(that brought wheat farming and cattle herding techniques) that migrated to the east and genetically absorbed an indigenous people of Austro Asiatic(they brought Rice farming techniques) and Eastern Eurasian(Hunter gatherer) origin.The Indo Aryanization process(including genetical exchange) in Bengal occurred during Magadha era and then with the spread of Buddhism the eastern fringe of the subcontinent reached the glory under the Maurya Empire and later Pala Empire(Bilal already posted an excellent post about Buddhist Viharas in Bengal). We also got few genes related to Northeast Asians(Korean/Japanese), possibly via Tai migration in Northeastern part of the subcontinent or simply from Sino-Tibetan tribes. Eastern Bengalis are formed differently than Casteist/Endogamous Hindu Indians and formerly endogamous eastern Pakistanis and western Pakistanis.Buddhism and Islam played a big role in east Bengal, so our genetic structure is not the same as our neighbors despite having similar component mostly.

You claimed to have superior complex by comparing a malnourished atypical Bangladeshi guy with some "not bad looking" Pakistanis. Wasn't that comparison pretty ridiculous?
How about this:
A well known Pashto guy:

And an average Bangladeshi guy from Sylhet(the easternmost region of Bangladesh):

 

[A.A. Khan]

I was looking for the complete vdo, this was made and recorded in 2004-?7 but it still so reelevant and ahead of its time how a Bengali boasts, shows his fake pride, takes offense and never answer the question. This incredible entertaining icon Late Moin Akhtar was doing a caricature but literally nailed it. Our exports more than your exports, our education more than your education our sports better than your sports this is how these mentally ill Banglas interact with an indian or Pakistani.

 

[El Sidd]

I was looking for the complete vdo, this was made and recorded in 2004-?7 but it still so reelevant and ahead of its time how a Bengali boasts, shows his fake pride, takes offense and never answer the question. This incredible entertaining icon Late Moin Akhtar was doing a caricature but literally nailed it. Our exports more than your exports, our education more than your education our sports better than your sports this is how these mentally ill Banglas interact with an indian or Pakistani.

I Miss him dearly

 

[Skies]

lol

 

[Saiful Islam]

Race, race, race, race. That is what Ramadan is about? Race.

Sad Buffoons.

 

[Skies]

#Introspection

 

[MultaniGuy]

First of all, no Bangladeshi member claimed Pakistanis and Bangladeshis as same people. We are different(no doubt about that), but it's like the difference between an Italian and a Norwegian or a French.
According to your post Pakistanis and Bangladeshis must be alien to eachother, as they are Linguistically different:

Something must be wrong in this tree! How two totally different languages like Bengali and Punjabi are in the same cluster??

Culturally different:
Culturally every south Asian ethnic groups have their own unique traditions, but these traditions were born out of some common traditions. Bangladeshi culture is a hybrid between eastern Indo-Aryan culture(mostly Buddhist heritage) and Islamic culture, Pakistani culture is divided in two parts, The Punjabi/Sindhi culture is western Indo-Aryan(Hindu and Sikh heritage)/Islamic hybrid, the Pashto/Baloch cultures is a mix of eastern Persian culture and Islamic culture.
You and your countrymen denying very simple facts, how on earth the difference between Pakistani and Bangladeshi is same as the difference between Moroccan and Pakistani
Or Chinese and Senegalese(i laughed on this one)?? Moroccans dont speak Indo European language so they have nothing in common with Pakistanis linguistically. For example, An Amazigh guy from morocco has more in common with an Arab from Yemen than a Turkish, even though they have different cultures and languages(though Arabic and Berber languages are both Afro-Asiatic). Like South Asians also their genetical structures(not components) are different, for example both groups have some Sub Saharan African admixture, Amazigh people got from ancient West Africans but Yemenis got from Northeastern Africans.

Genetically different:
Yes there are genetical difference between Pakistanis and Bangladeshis, but you cant deny that Pakistani people(including Pashto/Baloch) descend from the same early humans as Bengalis or other Indic people.These early people of both western and eastern Eurasian origin expanded and intermixed between them to form modern south Asians, for example Bengali race was born out of a western Eurasian race(that brought wheat farming and cattle herding techniques) that migrated to the east and genetically absorbed an indigenous people of Austro Asiatic(they brought Rice farming techniques) and Eastern Eurasian(Hunter gatherer) origin.The Indo Aryanization process(including genetical exchange) in Bengal occurred during Magadha era and then with the spread of Buddhism the eastern fringe of the subcontinent reached the glory under the Maurya Empire and later Pala Empire(Bilal already posted an excellent post about Buddhist Viharas in Bengal). We also got few genes related to Northeast Asians(Korean/Japanese), possibly via Tai migration in Northeastern part of the subcontinent or simply from Sino-Tibetan tribes. Eastern Bengalis are formed differently than Casteist/Endogamous Hindu Indians and formerly endogamous eastern Pakistanis and western Pakistanis.Buddhism and Islam played a big role in east Bengal, so our genetic structure is not the same as our neighbors despite having similar component mostly.

You claimed to have superior complex by comparing a malnourished atypical Bangladeshi guy with some "not bad looking" Pakistanis. Wasn't that comparison pretty ridiculous?
How about this:
A well known Pashto guy:

And an average Bangladeshi guy from Sylhet(the easternmost region of Bangladesh):

Lol it is not Pashto guy. It is a Pathan. I don't know whether your post is legitimate or not!

 

[Skies]

 

[MultaniGuy]

Most Pathans are fair skinned while Bangladeshis are dark skinned.

Sorry but this is a fact.
Pathan man:


Bangladeshi man:

 

[Skies]

only stupid people are bringing the debate of skin color

comparison has to be best to best, not cherry picking