What's new

Wearing a headscarf is not a crime'

Salahadin

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jan 4, 2009
Messages
479
Reaction score
0
SVS Government College in Bantwal, near Mangalore in Karnataka, stirred up a controversy when the institution barred Ayesha Ashmin from wearing a headscarf to college. The first year degree student from Bantwal alleged that college principal Sitaram Maiyya warned her against wearing the headscarf and asked her to choose between her studies or her religion.

However, Ayesha refuses to give up her fight. She along with her father, B Mohammed are running from pillar to post seeking justice. The college, which had earlier denied have made any such demand, now says that it is necessary that every student abides by the rules and the same cannot be discriminatory in nature.

In this interview with rediff.com's Vicky Nanjappa, Ayesha along with her father Mohammad speak in length about the incident and what they plan to do in the future

Firstly, take us through the incident in brief

I study at the SVS college. The college re-opened on July 2009 and two weeks later the college elections were held. Bharath, a final year student in the college, was elected as president. One day, he came up to me and told me that I should not be wearing a headscarf. He told me that if I don't take off the headscarf it could become an issue in college.

What did you tell him?

I requested him to permit me to continue wearing the headscarf, as it was a religious issue. Bharath then told me that all the other students would wear saffron shawls and come to college. I immediately thought of discussing this matter with the principal, but he too was not in my favour. He instead summoned my parents and told them that I could not continue wearing the head scarf to college.

Did you think it was important to go to the media? Look at how big this issue has become and moreover it is sensitive in nature.


Ayesha's father speaks: We had no choice. We did try our level best. What wrong did my daughter do? Everyone has to respect sentiments of others. In her earlier college, she wore a burqa and there was no such problem. Why have the authorities made it a problem?


Ayesha: I would like to ask here. If a nun can wear a head scarf to college and there is no opposition to that why should the case be any different for me.

Your studies sure have and will continue to take a hit. Are you not worried about that?


I had no intention of getting into this controversy. My dream is to become a chartered accountant and I will fulfill that dream. I will work harder and ensure that my dreams are fulfilled.

The college has made it clear that if you don't abide by the rules then you will have to find another college. What are your views on this?


Ayesha's father speaks: We will continue to fight until we get justice. What wrong have we done?

Wearing a headscarf is not a crime.

Ayesha: What rules are we talking about here? When I sought admission to the college, nowhere in the prospectus or any other paper was it mentioned that it is against the rules to wear a headscarf.

Is there any particular reason for singling out your daughter alone? I am sure that there are several other Muslim students who wear either a burqa or a headscarf to college.


Ayesha's father speaks: I would not say that my daughter has been singled out. I am sure that such instances have occurred, but those girls did not have the guts to speak out on the issue. My daughter spoke up and this should become a precedent. There should not be any discrimination anywhere on the basis of religion.

You say that your studies are very important. This incident sure has done no good to your attendance. Don't you think you should have persuaded the college more and ensure that the matter was sorted out.


You think I have not done that. This was the last ditch attempt for me. I am extremely worried about my future and the mental torture that I have gone through is a real lot. I tried at least more than four times to convince the college, but that has not happened. My intention was never to ruin the reputation of the college. I only wish that everything falls into place.

Would you go back if the college authorities apologise?


I sure would go back. I, in fact, want them to take me back. I even have a lot of hope from the University, which I feel is taking up my case.


Ayesha's father speaks: I know it is difficult to get admission at this time of the year in some other college. I too would be happy if the college took her back. She is a brave girl and will go back to the same college. My only dream is to see to it that my daughter studies well and completes whatever she has been aiming for.

From time to time we have been hearing problems with muslims in so called secular India.. and they still want to call themselves Secular India, no wonder they are on a Religious Watch list of US.


Interview: 'Wearing a headscarf is not a crime': Rediff.com news
 
.
College Mgt. is following college rules, which are clearly mentioned in the college prospectus and application form which the student duly signed.
She is just raising an issue for some attention.
There are plenty of colleges in which hindu students are not allowed to put bindhi's on their forehead, allowed to wear flowers not jewellery.
so lets not make it a big issue of mislim discrimination. Institutions are just following rules :welcome:
 
.
You have this said prospectus? I would like to see it.
 
.
College Mgt. is following college rules, which are clearly mentioned in the college prospectus and application form which the student duly signed.
She is just raising an issue for some attention.
There are plenty of colleges in which hindu students are not allowed to put bindhi's on their forehead, allowed to wear flowers not jewellery.
so lets not make it a big issue of mislim discrimination. Institutions are just following rules :welcome:

Read the article again, its been 3 months since college started and no one objected from the administration. It was student union leader who made this an issue. So clearly it wasn't part of college policy, otherwise she would'nt have taken admission in the college in the first place. I don't think even the management wanted to do it because they took this step because of "external threats".

There was never such type of issue in Mangalore and all communities had exemplary relations. South India in general has been very peaceful and away from any communal elements. Its only after BJP coming to power in Karnataka we are seeing these things happening.

And if someone wants to wear bindis (and it is essential for her religion to wear so) then hindu students should be allowed this freedom as well. We should be moving towards the American model, not the french. I don't think we are insecure like the French when it comes to religion.
 
.
There was never such type of issue in Mangalore and all communities had exemplary relations. South India in general has been very peaceful and away from any communal elements. Its only after BJP coming to power in Karnataka we are seeing these things happening.

A college in Uttar Pradesh banned jeans. BJP is not ruling there.

Afrer the Sri Ram sene bashing of Pub in Mangalore dont forget the comments of Mr.Ashok Gehlot who is/was CM of Rajastha under INC rule.

Now student leader or not it is the decision of college management which one has to accept or change the college.

Not to forget a school bared a muslim boy from keeping beard. The boy went to court. The court ruled in favor of the school.

So BJP has nothing to do anything from this banning.

GB
 
.
College Mgt. is following college rules, which are clearly mentioned in the college prospectus and application form which the student duly signed.
She is just raising an issue for some attention.
There are plenty of colleges in which hindu students are not allowed to put bindhi's on their forehead, allowed to wear flowers not jewellery.
so lets not make it a big issue of mislim discrimination. Institutions are just following rules :welcome:
Why are such laws even created? The management clearly knew about her attire since she pre-informed them while registering.

I think its India's Hindus gone wild again. You know it, I know it, this is all to do with harassing the Muslims, nothing else. Why the insistence on wearing the safron then? Hindu colors! Petty. Real petty.

It's incidents like these that remind us how necessary the partition was or else we'd be at the tyranny of petty and zealous extremists.
 
.
Why are such laws even created?

Many muslim schools/colleges have compulsary Hijab for girls of all ages even in the cities like Mumbai.

Due to which girls from another religion don't want to go to this institutions.

Your question can be asked here as well.


I think its India's Hindus gone wild again. You know it, I know it, this is all to do with harassing the Muslims, nothing else.

You are wrong. Hindus have just come out of holy month of Shravan and are busy with Ganesh Puja this time. One college incident has nothing to do with whole of India or hindus in India.

It's incidents like these that remind us how necessary the partition was or else we'd be at the tyranny of petty and zealous extremists.

Totally off topic and not necessary here.

GB
 
.
Many muslim schools/colleges have compulsary Hijab for girls of all ages even in the cities like Mumbai.

Due to which girls from another religion don't want to go to this institutions.

Your question can be asked here as well.

A school with a religious affiliation is geared to cater to a particular religion by definition. A Hindu school would be entitled to enforce Hindu customs.

But a secular school should not discriminate against any particular religion. Most businesses bend over backwards to accomodate their customers. It's called customer service. As EjazR says, the example to follow here is the American model, not the European one.

In Australia, Sikhs are allowed to carry a ceremonial dagger to school! Talk about tolerance!
 
.
In Australia, Sikhs are allowed to carry a ceremonial dagger to school! Talk about tolerance!

In France Sikhs are not allowed to wear a turban. Talk about equal law for everyone. (Banning of burqa in France).

Talk about tolerance!

A sikh can carry a dagger or a sword in any bank in India forget schools or colleges. and they are not supposed to be ceremonial.

Gimmie a week's time. If my bank allowes I will post a snap of rules board of State Bank of India. While it says all kind of weapons are prohibited Sikhs are allowed to carry Kirpan (dagger) and talwar (sword) in the bank.

A school with a religious affiliation is geared to cater to a particular religion by definition.

I am not talking about a religious school. I am talking about a usual school run by muslim organization.
A Hindu school would be entitled to enforce Hindu customs.

There are no Hindu or Muslims schools as such in India unless you are referring to Madarssa's or Hindu Vedshala's which I am not talking about when I say a school.

GB
 
.
In France Sikhs are not allowed to wear a turban. Talk about equal law for everyone. (Banning of burqa in France).

Actually the French law bans schoolgirls from wearing the headscarf. But small crosses and star-of-david are OK because they are "inconspicuous".
 
.
Actually the French law bans schoolgirls from wearing the headscarf. But small crosses and star-of-david are OK because they are "inconspicuous".

Well I was not aware of that. Thanks for bringing it to my attention.

Back to Topic please.

GB
 
.
Why are such laws even created? The management clearly knew about her attire since she pre-informed them while registering.

I think its India's Hindus gone wild again. You know it, I know it, this is all to do with harassing the Muslims, nothing else. Why the insistence on wearing the safron then? Hindu colors! Petty. Real petty.

It's incidents like these that remind us how necessary the partition was or else we'd be at the tyranny of petty and zealous extremists.

Asim, you have made this a case to justify partition, and i oppose this in the strongest terms. You have to understand, it has BECOME AN ISSUE in india. Do you think this would have been the case in muslim majority countries. Here an injustice have been done to a poor muslim student and it has become an issue. Definitely she will get justice.

I request you not to put this thing as a REASON to justify partition, as i am of the opinion the partion was the stuipdest thing that ever happend in this sub continent. And if we where united do you think that HINDU MAJORITY WOULD ever dare to discriminate minorities. Religion really sucks when it becomes a tool to judge individuals.
 
.
Just think what could have been achieved if we were united. Brits made a wise move. They divided the country and left a mess for us that cant be cleaned so easily. There was no gain from partition but its all loss. If there was no partition, even Muslim population would have been well above 400 millions and then, forget about any religious discriminations.
 
.
Headscarf Row: Ayesha to continue studies at another college - Mangalore - City - NEWS - The Times of India

MANGALORE: Aysha Asmin, the college girl who was caught in the head scarf row, has opted to continue her studies at Hira College at Babukatte
near here.

Mohammed, the father of Aysha, told TOI that though he and Aysha wanted to continue at SVS College, Bantwal, his wife was against it. "Ultimately we decided to admit her to Hira Womens College, which is about 30 km from here, he said.

SVS College, Bantwal is less than five km from Aysha's house at Panemangalore. Mohammed said the college bus picks her up at 8 am and drops her by 4.30 pm."Earlier too she used to leave at the same time and return almost at the same time, the only difference is that in case the classes finish early, she cannot come home as the college is far away, he added.

Aysha was admitted on Monday and started attending classes from Tuesday. She got the transfer certificate from SVS College on Saturday.

A few days back, the management of SVS College, Bantwal decided to grant permission for girl students to use the shawl of the uniform as a headscarf, if they desired to do so. The decision was taken at a meeting with Mangalore University vice-chancellor, attended by locals MLAs and representatives of the college and others on last Thursday. SVS College correspondent Ganesh Prabhu wished the girl luck in her endeavours.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom