Weakness of India

[armyoptimist]

On of the Pakistan officers told me about Pak-Indo war. He told me that Indian planes flown over our camps and destroyed a single empty vehicle. I don't know if it is Indian Air Force Weakness or it was just an incident.

 

[gpit]

Many Indian friends said it is Indian politicians that are Indian weak point. Rightly said, but maybe not quite right to the point.

I’d like to say it is much touted Indian political system that’s the weak point of India.

Politicians are created out from a political system. Indian political system produces Indian politicians. Remind you all the fact that a huge percent of Indian politicians are criminal or alleged criminals.

Please don’t ask me what is the best system for India if current one is not good. If you Indians don’t know, how would I?

However, I’d like to postulate that perhaps India should adopt limited democracy instead of western style democracy. Why? because current western democracy is very expensive and needs elevated social welfare and abundant resources to support.

If you don’t have enough quality judges to timely handle cases, criminals will run rampant. If you don’t have high enough living standards, the poor will sell criminals their voting power for 10 Rupee. If you don’t have enough literacy, your constituents are prone to propaganda…

In American earlier history, only limited democracy was conducted: only white male with properties could vote. Step by step, they emancipated black slaves, adopted woman suffrage…

I personally believe this is the way democracy should go. Of course, the existence of wise politicians with right vision, dedicated for the benefit of the country, not just personal profit, is a must.

 

[armyoptimist]

That was a real useful post. Thanks

 

[maverick2009]

India weakness is its soft on Cross border terrorism.

Too quick to forgive and forget and meek mild politicians. like DR SINGH.

India Today is large powerful industrial nation on its way to becoming a GIANT ECONOMY BY 2020 latest.

They need leaders with Arrogance and flair dare i say a Indri Ghandi was india,s toughest leader yet.

That lady gave the American 7TH fLEET A 2 Finger salute and took EAST PAKISTAN in 12 Days.

Thats India,s Weakness Today.

 

[adrenalin]

Not only did Indira liberate Bangladesh, she also terminated terrorism in Mizoram. All of you are right, when you say that Weak and Incompetent leaders are our major worry.

While the majority of educated people on either side of the border want peace, the main theme is left to the Army in case of Pakistan, and to weak & corrupt politicians in case of India.

I don't have a problem with people of Pakistan, I admire Wasim Akram, Imran Khan and so on and so forth, however I do have a serious problem with Pakistan's think tank, well!!! the same way Pakistani's have with India.

 

[ebungo]

India weakness is its soft on Cross border terrorism.

Too quick to forgive and forget and meek mild politicians. like DR SINGH.

India Today is large powerful industrial nation on its way to becoming a GIANT ECONOMY BY 2020 latest.

They need leaders with Arrogance and flair dare i say a Indri Ghandi was india,s toughest leader yet.

That lady gave the American 7TH fLEET A 2 Finger salute and took EAST PAKISTAN in 12 Days.

Thats India,s Weakness Today./QUOTE]/QUOTE]


that 100 % true. we need strong leader with vision

 

[gogbot]

India weakness is its soft on Cross border terrorism.

Too quick to forgive and forget and meek mild politicians. like DR SINGH.

India Today is large powerful industrial nation on its way to becoming a GIANT ECONOMY BY 2020 latest.

They need leaders with Arrogance and flair dare i say a Indri Ghandi was india,s toughest leader yet.

That lady gave the American 7TH fLEET A 2 Finger salute and took EAST PAKISTAN in 12 Days.

Thats India,s Weakness Today./QUOTE]/QUOTE]


that 100 % true. we need strong leader with vision

Rajiv Gandhi, can also be considered a strong leader. His government spearheaded the reforms for our economy.

and dont sell Dr.Singh short, he is the perfect leader for india at this time. This is also India's weakness , it is a country at a crossroads, recent economic growth has created a more progressive india, however India need's focus more on its economy now more than ever, And also solve its Internal Problems. Dr. Singh being a brilliant economist himself and also crafting Indian reforms in the Rajiv government, is a leader who understands the economy and its value.
And perfect man to lead the country as it consolidates its position.

 

[shravan]

As i see the only Weakness of India is there is not Hindu Brotherhood. Everyone is loyal to their own local language and culture. So if India is not disturbed by outsiders the gap increases but as soon as external forces try to destabilize India all become one.

Recent example Before 26/11 Maharashtrians where very angry with Biharis but as soon as 26/11 happened the problems started to fade. There are many examples like that in the Indian History.

But luckily even if we hate each other no one goes to the extreme like killing. And i think this has to do with caste system because people marry in their own community so others communities are not threatened by outsiders.

 

[third eye]

Many Indian friends said it is Indian politicians that are Indian weak point. Rightly said, but maybe not quite right to the point.

I’d like to say it is much touted Indian political system that’s the weak point of India.

Politicians are created out from a political system. Indian political system produces Indian politicians. Remind you all the fact that a huge percent of Indian politicians are criminal or alleged criminals.

Please don’t ask me what is the best system for India if current one is not good. If you Indians don’t know, how would I?

However, I’d like to postulate that perhaps India should adopt limited democracy instead of western style democracy. Why? because current western democracy is very expensive and needs elevated social welfare and abundant resources to support.

If you don’t have enough quality judges to timely handle cases, criminals will run rampant. If you don’t have high enough living standards, the poor will sell criminals their voting power for 10 Rupee. If you don’t have enough literacy, your constituents are prone to propaganda…

In American earlier history, only limited democracy was conducted: only white male with properties could vote. Step by step, they emancipated black slaves, adopted woman suffrage…

I personally believe this is the way democracy should go. Of course, the existence of wise politicians with right vision, dedicated for the benefit of the country, not just personal profit, is a must.

I don't think turning back the clock on democracy is a workable option. Soloutions can only be steps in the forward direction not retrograde. Franchise has to be universal.

More than the politicians it is the process. The Westminister style of Govt gives room for Pol parties ( regional) which have proliferated with no meaningful contribution to the process. Parties with 5-10 seats become king makers in a coalition politics.

What I feel we need is Presidential form of Govt which allows for selection the best form of talent in the form of a professional to head a ministry unlike the square pegs we have in round holes now. This is another debate which can hijack this thread completely hence not being pursued any more.

Next is the No of Pol parties. This has to be reduced / laid down so that they do not grow like mushrooms in the rains & fade away as fast.

 

[EjazR]

If you want to know about recent/short term threats facing India, India's Home ministers' Interview would give you a good overview

http://www.defence.pk/forums/india-...me-minister-internal-security.html#post474571

 

[EjazR]

Many Indian friends said it is Indian politicians that are Indian weak point. Rightly said, but maybe not quite right to the point.

I’d like to say it is much touted Indian political system that’s the weak point of India.

Politicians are created out from a political system. Indian political system produces Indian politicians. Remind you all the fact that a huge percent of Indian politicians are criminal or alleged criminals.

Please don’t ask me what is the best system for India if current one is not good. If you Indians don’t know, how would I?

However, I’d like to postulate that perhaps India should adopt limited democracy instead of western style democracy. Why? because current western democracy is very expensive and needs elevated social welfare and abundant resources to support.

If you don’t have enough quality judges to timely handle cases, criminals will run rampant. If you don’t have high enough living standards, the poor will sell criminals their voting power for 10 Rupee. If you don’t have enough literacy, your constituents are prone to propaganda…

In American earlier history, only limited democracy was conducted: only white male with properties could vote. Step by step, they emancipated black slaves, adopted woman suffrage…

I personally believe this is the way democracy should go. Of course, the existence of wise politicians with right vision, dedicated for the benefit of the country, not just personal profit, is a must.

The British style democracy that we have in India might not be perfect, but IMO this system with its checks and balances (i.e. ligislative, judiciary and executive) is the best solution available. qsaark recently wrote an article that discusses the points you raise about democracy in the Writers section and addresses all the issues that you raise. http://www.defence.pk/forums/writers-board/33058-literacy-democracy.html

As someone rightly said, the solution to problems in democracy is to give more democracy.

When Americans adopted limited franchise, that was wrong. If you think that they provided step by step franchise as part of a well thought out plan you are wrong. Women and African Americans had to fight for their rights. Indians are lucky that they had universal franchise from the beginning so that even the voice of the poor and women can be heard. Otherwise only the elite would have benefited while the poor would have kept feeling alienated

*For those who complain criminals being elected, let me remind you that laws have been passed that any person who is convicted in a criminal case and sentenced for two years imprisonment is banned from contesting elections.

* For those who talk about money or propaganda being used, the model code of conduct prevents and monitors any distribution of money or illegal propaganda or use of govt. funds for campaigning.

*Regarding corruption among govt. services, the recently passed Right to Information Act is a powerful tool for citizens to monitor what civil service officers are doing. Any concerned citizen can use RTI at their local collectors office to find out what's going on with state funds.

It is unfortunate that these provisions have been used setup and are being used consistently only the last 10 years, but this shows that a Democratic setup with concerned citizens can find an rectify these problems.

Sure a democratic society might be slow moving as it will always require public discussion and addressing concerns of various sections of the society, but because people atleast have a voice in major decisions taken by the country, it results in a more stable, confident and integrated society in the long run.

 

[EyelessInGaza]

India's weaknesses:

1. Population and poverty: The greatest drag on India's development is its massive population. It is the reason for high levels of poverty. Every single program meant to alleviate poverty loses momentum when confronted by the the sheer size of our population. Just check the economic and social indicators.

Population has a direct impact on quality of life, development and growth. In fact, almost every single weakness - from poor healthcare to corruption - can ultimately be traced to overpopulation. Ultimately inequity will threatn to destroy the Indian way of life; look at the suddenly ramped up Naxal movements of late.

2. Caste system: Regardless of original intent, this is one of the most pernicious social systems, especially for those who are at the lower end of the scale. Although there is a transformation underway, the caste system is the biggest barrier to individual flair, upwards mobility, innovation and growth.

3. Soft state: We are a soft state; in essence there are few modern values that are collectively agreed on. We keep our houses clean, but don't care for the trash we throw on the road outside, or the state of public libraries. Since comparatively ( we are better than most developing countries in this regard) very little power has devolved to local communities, we do not care for the fundamentals of development unless it impacts us directly.

4. Kashmir and the North East: Kashmir needs not be discussed here as we all know about it. But to me the North East is India's greatest challenge going forward. In essence we need to bring citizens of the NE states into the Indian mainstream - socially, culturally, economically. I am hopeful of the ultimate outcome, but we need a concerted plan and strategy in place.

5. Religious fundamentalism: It has the potential to be a very significant weakness, one that can tear India apart. While I understand the essentially secular worldview of India, in recent times fundamentalism has threatened to upset this balance. Gujarat is one example.

 

[ouiouiouiouiouioui]

India's weaknesses:

1. Population and poverty: The greatest drag on India's development is its massive population. It is the reason for high levels of poverty. Every single program meant to alleviate poverty loses momentum when confronted by the the sheer size of our population. Just check the economic and social indicators.

Population has a direct impact on quality of life, development and growth. In fact, almost every single weakness - from poor healthcare to corruption - can ultimately be traced to overpopulation. Ultimately inequity will threatn to destroy the Indian way of life; look at the suddenly ramped up Naxal movements of late.

2. Caste system: Regardless of original intent, this is one of the most pernicious social systems, especially for those who are at the lower end of the scale. Although there is a transformation underway, the caste system is the biggest barrier to individual flair, upwards mobility, innovation and growth.

3. Soft state: We are a soft state; in essence there are few modern values that are collectively agreed on. We keep our houses clean, but don't care for the trash we throw on the road outside, or the state of public libraries. Since comparatively ( we are better than most developing countries in this regard) very little power has devolved to local communities, we do not care for the fundamentals of development unless it impacts us directly.

4. Kashmir and the North East: Kashmir needs not be discussed here as we all know about it. But to me the North East is India's greatest challenge going forward. In essence we need to bring citizens of the NE states into the Indian mainstream - socially, culturally, economically. I am hopeful of the ultimate outcome, but we need a concerted plan and strategy in place.

5. Religious fundamentalism: It has the potential to be a very significant weakness, one that can tear India apart. While I understand the essentially secular worldview of India, in recent times fundamentalism has threatened to upset this balance. Gujarat is one example

what ever is given has to be taken..modestly........if u cannot make the change...dont discuss as politiician..just keep quiet..

 

[praveen]

http://www.defence.pk/forums/military-history/33329-1965-last-chance-get-kashmir-force-bhutto.html#post473863

This is how people percieve and this is how people get their just deserts

 

[lamayuru]

I know every country has strenght as well as weakness. All of us know the power of India now tell me the weakness of Indian Military like their atomic bombs weakness,missiles weakness etc.

I don't know about India, but Indian's have a weakness for sweets, good food & good friends among other things.