muse
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Oct 26, 2006
- Messages
- 13,006
- Reaction score
- 0
Pakistan has almost nothing to lose (sharp, sorry). So that, it was a good opportunity for bottoming out. Pakistan has so many wounds, the need is a realistic perception, I did not say to give up democracy, there are many forms of democracy, I will look forward to seeing the efficiency of democracy in Pakistan, which is a good reference for China.
Super comment, excellent. Exactly, what we have been pointing to with the characterization of "Westminster on the Indus" - It is a curious lack of imagination that instead of the essence, the fundamental ideas being examined and refined, Pakistan have instituted or rather supplanted Westminster on the Indus, with complete disregard to the political realities on the ground, with complete disregard to the historical, and cultural context.
The editorial says this of what Pakistanis think of "democracy" :
Most Pakistanis do not give enough importance to democracy
Is this not a amazing statement? Why, WHY, do most Pakistanis not give what the editorial calls "enough" (how much is enough?) importance to "Democracy"??? Well, Obviously, it does not produce, it does not deliver -- would you give give any, not just "enough" importance to anything that did not do what it claims it can do??
Of course, then we must ask, WHY doesn't it work? I would suggest that the there are several reasons, prime among them is that the ideas that inform "Westminster on the Indus" are deeply flawed - Democracy is not just "voting"? It most certainly cannot be "Majoritarianism" - The editorial has it right, doesn't it when it states:
The so-called democrats may themselves end up being seen as a danger to the institution of democracy.
But the editorial is also flawed in this statement, is it not? Communists killed Communism? Not that the idea of Communism fell because of it's internal incoherence, not because it was itself flawed, but because communists were flawed?? hain ji? Do so called "Democrats" have no relationship to so called "Democracy"???