Was Ladakh ever part of modern "India" at any point in its history?

[KhanBaba2]

what practicality?
they are different distinct people compared to you. that is just a fact.

They still want to be part of India. Not every distinct people wants to leave India.

The Pushtuns are distinct people in your country. So are the Hazara.

 

[BL33D]

what have they to do with this?

People of Ladakh don't really feel any belonging to the Indian Union.

They have been exploited by the Indian government for too long and now are stateless.

Show some evidence. Last I checked the ladakh MP was all praise for granting UT and was supporting wholeheartedly the govt. I will post speeches and videos from the UT proving it if needed. Do you have proof for what you are suggesting ??? Other than some isolated case.

They still want to be part of India. Not every distinct people wants to leave India.

The Pushtuns are distinct people in your country. So are the Hazara.

Balochs ??

 

[El Sidd]

They still want to be part of India. Not every distinct people wants to leave India.

The Pushtuns are distinct people in your country. So are the Hazara.

Pashtuns and Hazaras live throughout Pakistan. They are an intrinsic part of the Pakistani society and community.

Show some evidence. Last I checked the ladakh MP was all praise for granting UT and was supporting wholeheartedly the govt. I will post speeches and videos from the UT proving it if needed. Do you have proof for what you are suggesting ??? Other than some isolated case.

of course some isolated individuals directly benefitting from corruption will chant anything that brings in money.

the common people in Ladakh suffer from being put in what can only be defined as human zoos forced to live in harsh realities while accommodating for tourists.

 

[BL33D]

Pashtuns and Hazaras live throughout Pakistan. They are an intrinsic part of the Pakistani society and community.




of course some isolated individuals directly benefitting from corruption will chant anything that brings in money.

the common people in Ladakh suffer from being put in what can only be defined as human zoos forced to live in harsh realities while accommodating for tourists.

I am not here for your anecdotal or emotional and biased assumptions. If you have any strong evidence for it do provide and I will respectfully discuss on it. Otherwise its just your words against mine. And at least I can back up my words with representatives directly elected by the people whereas yours is just opinion without any evidence.

 

[El Sidd]

I am not here for your anecdotal or emotional and biased assumptions. If you have any strong evidence for it do provide and I will respectfully discuss on it. Otherwise its just your words against mine.

without any evidence.

https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/f...kh-locals-wary-outsiders-191104054956887.html

https://feminisminindia.com/2018/04/12/racism-ladakh-woman/

 

[BL33D]

https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/f...kh-locals-wary-outsiders-191104054956887.html

https://feminisminindia.com/2018/04/12/racism-ladakh-woman/

Ladakh MP

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.in...new-union-territory-status-1577650-2019-08-06

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.li...akh-now-is-very-bright/amp-1565363595231.html

https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.econ...nfused-uncertain/amp_articleshow/70943954.cms

 

[El Sidd]

Ladakh MP

Thats just pro government puppets. No Ladakhi will compromise freedom over material economic growth.

 

[KhanBaba2]

Balochs ??

I thought we are talking of people who are different but are not having a separatist movement.

 

[BL33D]

Thats just pro government puppets. No Ladakhi will compromise freedom over material economic growth.

Yea your 30 odd peoples are a diverse set and here 100s gathered are not a good enough sample for you. BJP has 10 crore members and leaving aside the supporters. So obviously people supporting the centre will be plenty everywhere. Or is it that anyone not confirming to your point of view is wrong ??

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

How much of the Buddhist population will be left if Tibetan refugees are sent back to Tibet in China?

It is a majority Muslim region traditionally, with Buddhist minority.

Pakistan should work with China to resolve this issue @viva_zhao

 

[vi-va]

How much of the Buddhist population will be left if Tibetan refugees are sent back to Tibet in China?

It is a majority Muslim region traditionally, with Buddhist minority.

Pakistan should work with China to resolve this issue @viva_zhao

I believe it will only happen when India become a historical geographic noun as before.

 

[Fireurimagination]

Separatist nonsense is prevalent in just 6-7 districts of the valley. Rest Jammu and Ladakh has always been pro-India infact seperation from Kashmir was always been a demand of Ladakhi people.

 

[El Sidd]

Yea your 30 odd peoples are a diverse set and here 100s gathered are not a good enough sample for you. BJP has 10 crore members and leaving aside the supporters. So obviously people supporting the centre will be plenty everywhere. Or is it that anyone not confirming to your point of view is wrong ??

30 odd people braved the million troops to come out and protest.

the women protesting war rape is nothing new in delhi it seems these days.

RSS is flooding the sacred Buddhist valley under the auspices of the imperial indian army

always been a demand of Ladakhi people.

referendum has always been the demand if not straight out independence.

 

[Fireurimagination]

referendum has always been the demand if not straight out independence.

This is what their very popular MP has to say. They actually hate muslims of Kashmir and are finally happy to have distinct identity.

 

[Chhatrapati]

Ladakh is a Shia majority region. Remember how people in Kargil supported army to squash the intruders in 1999.