What's new

View through the burka

Skeptic

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
May 5, 2009
Messages
1,146
Reaction score
0
Country
India
Location
India
View through the burka
By Sadia Qasim Shah
Saturday, 16 May, 2009 | 09:27 AM PST |

A WELL-BUILT, middle-aged maid working for a wealthy family in the restive Swat valley was once stopped by the Taliban on her way to work. Objecting to her traditional parhoonay or covering, one of the Taliban asked her, ‘Why are you not wearing a burka?’

He ordered her to wear the all-enveloping garb that has only a latticed ‘opening’, resembling a grill, in front for a woman to see and breathe. This garment is popularly called a shuttlecock burka. Some say it resembles a tent.

The next day the maid was taking some food in a huge pot covered by her burka to some relatives of the family she worked for. Once again she was stopped — this time by the police who assumed she was a security threat.

‘I don’t know what to do. Should I wear a burka or not?’ she wondered. However, observing that the Taliban were harsh in imposing their self-styled Islamic edicts on women she realised she had no choice but to allow the all-enveloping material to cover her.

However, another woman from Swat who now lives in Islamabad said that she and her young nieces had decided that they would not go to Swat if they had to wear the burka. Until just a few years ago, Swat regularly saw local and foreign tourists attired in outfits of their personal choice.

Unfortunately, in the face of Talibanisation, many women have no choice but to hide themselves inside the shuttlecock burka. The view from behind the ‘grill’ is not very clear. There is hardly any opening for fresh air. The shape of the burka ‘cap’ perhaps symbolises how the Taliban do not want women to grow intellectually.

It is too early to say what the results of the ongoing military operation will be, but until just some days ago, the Taliban had not only been entering and controlling many of our towns, they had also come to affect private lives. Their demand has been for men to sport beards and women to wear the shuttlecock burka.

It is quite clear that the Taliban are averse to a role for women outside their homes — this is their policy or one-point agenda as far as women are concerned. Matters could be worse for working women, especially those who do not have male breadwinners in the family, as the Taliban expect women to be accompanied by a male family member, or mehram, when venturing out of their homes.

‘My 15-year-old son laughed when he told me how the Taliban referred to two of his young cousins wearing burkas as ‘women’ when he accompanied them to their home,’ said a young Swati widow. She is lucky to have a teenaged son to accompany her to the school where she teaches.

Previously, Swati women had donated generously — even their jewellery — for the construction of the Imam Dheri seminary on the banks of the Swat river at the call of Maulana Fazlullah who initially broadcast ‘Dars-ul-Quran’ and Islamic teachings, interpreting these in Pashto, through the FM radio channel.

Many women, who could not read or write, appreciated this. Little did they know that once the Taliban started to gain power and make inroads into their lives, they would stop women from doing the simplest of things like shopping, and that they would threaten their school-going daughters with beheading if they went out in a chaddar and did not wear a burka. True, the burka has been in use in parts of the NWFP, but it has never been so common as it is now after the rapid Talibanisation of the past few years.

Today, one can see girls as young as eight or nine (it is not easy to make an exact guess as their faces and physiques are hidden from view) walking home from school in a row wearing the shuttlecock burka on the main Bara Road just adjacent to the Peshawar cantonment area. ‘When my niece was studying in class 8, she wore the shuttlecock burka for the first time. She vomited as she felt claustrophobic,’ said a resident of Lower Dir.

If walking in the shuttlecock burka is difficult for young, agile girls, one can only imagine how difficult it is for much older women to handle the attire. ‘My grandmother who was wearing the shuttlecock burka recently fell down and sprained her ankle. When we tried to take her to hospital she cried out angrily that we should forget the hospital and go and tell Maulana Fazlullah what happened,’ said a Swati woman.

A young man from Pabbi town in Nowshera district where women have traditionally worn the white shuttlecock burka said that his grandmother was attired in one as she crossed the road. She was hit by a vehicle. But she never knew exactly what had hit her since women have only a limited view of the outside world from inside the burka. Would it be too much to ask the Taliban, who have such a penchant for the burka, to try out one themselves some time? The same young man from Pabbi certainly did. He once donned his mother’s shuttlecock burka for a college skit. ‘I couldn’t see properly. It was so suffocating,’ he recalled.

Perhaps one can use the burka experience to draw a parallel between the physical and mental constraints imposed on women who are faced with the menace of Talibanisation. Just as very little is clear inside the burka, the world outside does not hold a bright future for women who must yield to the outrageous demands on their personal space.

The Taliban mindset has come to dominate and the militant ideology has a harsh manifesto that is invading women’s private space. Women are a vulnerable group, especially in areas where protests against restrictions on personal freedoms are uncommon.

On top of that, when their boundaries are defined by extremist groups who forget that women, like themselves, are human, they lose their fundamental and constitutional human rights. They feel suffocation physically — and mentally.
 
.
i think sadia qasim shah have never had worn a burka herself, then how come she could express an opinion about that, she seems to belong to a class of women who prefer runing on the road in sleeveless,....less T-Shirts and call it liberty to women, and by the way SKEPTIC before posting such an article why u forget that hindu culture observes even tougher type of burka/perda, forexample in rajisthan they wear dresses with a long chadder which doesn't even have the opening for eyes and in addition to that those hindu women do perda even from their father in law, would u call it taiboo? no man, as liberty is in human nature so is privacy, social protection etc, plz don't become part of world propeganda, let people live the way they want to, i do not support taliban in every respect but it doesn't mean they r all wrong, the only wrong thing about them is the way to send the message, it should be more wordly,and self examplary and shouldn't be done by force, but i am sure people like sadia shah and you are pouring petrol on this fire, plz stop doing this, coz you people will also be responsible for the resultant bloodshed, by the way how good u r in imposing ur opinion on those people as compared to taliban, u who know almost nothing about them, taliban atleast belong to that place, so please put ur home in order first....
 
.
this TOPIC has been done before.....but ONE thing i would like to add ISLAM gave women rights when no other RELIGION thought of them as anything but s*xual objects!!!

MOds please close this thread i think we have debated this to death as well as debating SAATI
 
.
Womens rights means asking women what is right ! Any women should have the right to wear or not to wear the burqah. I dont buy this idea of the Taliban imposing their brand of islam on women. If Burqa was the right of women , then it would have been widespread in other parts of Pakistan and amongst Indian muslims.
 
.
don't ever judge a person by other persons flaws......if it is not widespread in pakistan or india it doesn't mean it is ISLAMICALLY CORRECT.....
 
.
Do the nuns need to get rid of there head gear also...?
 
.
Do the nuns need to get rid of there head gear also...?

Many nuns actually don't wear the habit anymore. In any case, its their personal choice and christian taliban (or the like who threaten to disrespect / attack women who do not wear em) should not force them.
 
.
i think sadia qasim shah have never had worn a burka herself, then how come she could express an opinion about that, she seems to belong to a class of women who prefer runing on the road in sleeveless,....less T-Shirts and call it liberty to women, and by the way SKEPTIC before posting such an article why u forget that hindu culture observes even tougher type of burka/perda, forexample in rajisthan they wear dresses with a long chadder which doesn't even have the opening for eyes and in addition to that those hindu women do perda even from their father in law, would u call it taiboo? no man, as liberty is in human nature so is privacy, social protection etc, plz don't become part of world propeganda, let people live the way they want to, i do not support taliban in every respect but it doesn't mean they r all wrong, the only wrong thing about them is the way to send the message, it should be more wordly,and self examplary and shouldn't be done by force, but i am sure people like sadia shah and you are pouring petrol on this fire, plz stop doing this, coz you people will also be responsible for the resultant bloodshed, by the way how good u r in imposing ur opinion on those people as compared to taliban, u who know almost nothing about them, taliban atleast belong to that place, so please put ur home in order first....

Sir with all due respect, you are plainly ranting. I'll try to explain why I hold these views about your post.

1. What makes you assume that I am a Hindu?
2. Even if I am how is that related to this article?
3. Why do you choose to attack me personally and thrash my "motives" behind posting this article.
4. You are more interested in driving this thread into an India Pakistan debate of sorts which is completely unnecessary and uncalled for.

Now I'll try and counter whatever you have mentioned.

i think sadia qasim shah have never had worn a burka herself, then how come she could express an opinion about that
I think you have also not worn a burqa yourself, what makes you eligible to reply?

she seems to belong to a class of women who prefer runing on the road in sleeveless,....less T-Shirts and call it liberty to women
And you Sir seem to be of a class which only sees flesh when confronted by women. I am no personal friend of hers but please maintain dignity when talking about women.

by the way SKEPTIC before posting such an article why u forget that hindu culture observes even tougher type of burka/perda, forexample in rajisthan they wear dresses with a long chadder which doesn't even have the opening for eyes and in addition to that those hindu women do perda even from their father in law, would u call it taiboo? no man, as liberty is in human nature so is privacy, social protection etc, plz don't become part of world propeganda, let people live the way they want to

Your line of reasoning seems to suggest that two wrongs makes a right.

i do not support taliban in every respect but it doesn't mean they r all wrong, the only wrong thing about them is the way to send the message

no one suggested that you are supporting Taliban. Why do you speak in such a defensive tone then.

i am sure people like sadia shah and you are pouring petrol on this fire, plz stop doing this
You dont even know me and you know all the people like me. I am not adding any fuel to the fire. The article was published in Dawn. If you are uncomfortable you can go on and sue the Editor for the same. I am just posting what I thought would be an interesting article to me it symbolised how people are being liberated from the opressive Taliban rule by PA. I hope you are also supporting PA in their mission. Atleast I am.

u who know almost nothing about them
I know enough about them to dislike them and their methods to the core. I know the sort of people who hide behind the name of religion to launch their political agenda.
Ding!! they are not unique to Pakistan. We also have our share of these people.

so please put ur home in order first
Your home has come to the centre-stage of world politics and I am not the only observer. Sir your country is fighting a civil war and you are worried that an Indian Hindu has posted some article which mentioned the word BURQA. All i meant was to display how lives of common people are reflecting the change of regimes from Taliban to Pakistan.
 
.
this TOPIC has been done before.....but ONE thing i would like to add ISLAM gave women rights when no other RELIGION thought of them as anything but s*xual objects!!!

MOds please close this thread i think we have debated this to death as well as debating SAATI
I think you read articles with one eye on the flag of the poster. The article is not about Islam / Hinduism and I am not here for comparative religion debate.. there are better places to discuss religion, I thought this is a defence forum. Get you act and posts together.
 
.
Salaam

I agree that the taliban are not representing Islam, rather they are representing their own twisted egos, and I am glad that these scum are finally being killed.

This is what the Qur'an says about believing women:

“O Prophet, tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to draw their cloaks close round them (when they go abroad). That will be better, so that they may be recognised and not annoyed. Allah is ever Forgiving, Merciful.” (Quran 33:59)

“O you Children of Adam! We have bestowed on you raiment to cover your shame as well as to be an adornment to you. But the raiment of righteousness, that is the best. Such are among the Signs of Allah, that they may receive admonition.” (Quran 7:26)


We see that in Islam muslim women should dress modestly so that they are not harrased, and so that they may be recognised as pious muslim women.

the burkah is completely optional and the Taliban are sinning by forcing women to cover themselves completely. Even the Qur'an says " And say to the believing women that they should lower their gaze and guard their modesty; that they should not display their beauty and ornaments except what must ordinarily appear therof ; "

In fact, the dress code is there for men also. For exanple men are not allowed to wear tight clothing etc.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom