What's new

US wants India to shun role of Afghan peace spoiler

Shahzaz ud din

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 12, 2017
Messages
7,877
Reaction score
14
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
US wants India to shun role of Afghan peace spoiler
By Kamran Yousaf
Published: May 12, 2020
TWEET EMAIL
2219345-indiankhalilzad-1589223450-446-640x480.png

File photo of US special envoy Zalmay Khalilzad (L) and Indian External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar (R)

ISLAMABAD: At a time when official and private businesses are conducted virtually across the globe because of the Covid-19 threat, yet the US chief diplomat for Afghan peace recently toured New Delhi, Doha and Islamabad to engage directly with officials in the respective capitals.

The agenda was to review the ongoing efforts seeking a political end to the United States’ longest war. Zalmay Khalilzad, the US Special Representative for Afghan Reconciliation, frequently travels to this part of the world and undertook countless trips to Islamabad and Kabul.

But he included New Delhi in his itinerary only in recent months, raising questions that what prompted the US to reach out to India when it played little or no role in the Afghan peace process.

While other regional players, including China, Russia and Iran, remained part of Afghan peace efforts one way or the other, India was nowhere to be seen. Primarily because Pakistan always objected to India’s role.

In fact, Pakistan views India as a spoiler, a view tacitly endorsed by the US when Washington kept New Delhi at bay while it was negotiating a peace deal with the Taliban. But Khalilzad in his recent visit to New Delhi wanted India to play a role and even suggested India to speak directly to the Afghan Taliban.

Officials and diplomatic sources say one of the reasons the US has reached out to India is because it fears that New Delhi is creating impediments in the way of intra-Afghan talks. These sources believe India was behind President Ashraf Ghani’s reluctance to abide by the peace deal including the prisoners swap agreed in the US-Taliban deal.

Khalilzad meets Gen Qamar amid deadlock in Afghan peace process

The delay in the prisoner exchange has put on hold the start of critical intra-Afghan talks, which were originally scheduled for March 10. But the Ghani administration’s reluctance to free 5,000 Taliban prisoners has put the process in jeopardy.

It is believed that Khalilzad travelled to New Delhi with a brief, urging India not to create hurdles in the Afghan peace efforts.

India is the principal backer of Ghani after his controversial victory in the presidential elections. India feels that the peace deal in Afghanistan will erode its influence while Ghani also fears his political demise if the US-Taliban agreement succeeds.

This, according to observers, brought India and Ghani on the same page in opposing the deal with Taliban. But the Trump administration is keen to see this deal succeeding and hence is willing to make all out efforts.

Pakistan, nevertheless, is not happy with the US outreach to India on Afghanistan. A senior official, while speaking on the condition of anonymity, here said that Pakistan felt this was not the time for talking about Indian role but it was time to focus on the issue in hand.

“At the moment what is important how to proceed ahead with the Afghan peace process. The role of India is a secondary issue,” added the official, indicating that Pakistan and the US were not on the same page on the issue. But the official made it clear that Pakistan was not concerned over the engagement between the US and India on Afghanistan.

Islamabad has long viewed Indian role in Afghanistan with suspicion and often accused New Delhi of using the neighbouring country to create trouble in Pakistan. Officials here say that continued instability in Afghanistan serves the purpose of India and that is why it is using the Ghani administration to create obstacles in the way of peace process.


Read more: Afghan peace , india , Khalilzad
 
.
2219345-indiankhalilzad-1589223450-446-640x480.png


It really says it all. Among the smiles there is a feeling of unease.
 
.
2219345-indiankhalilzad-1589223450-446-640x480.png


It really says it all. Among the smiles there is a feeling of unease.

Of course there is. Indian policy in Afghanistan was never in sync with US policy, or with NATO policy. Remember Trump's gibe: the Indians only built a library. Right. Rather than blowing up Afghans, educating them is a better way forward.
 
.
Afghans know in their heart that India has held their best interests in heart. In the long march towards stability and development India will continue to support in the same way. I see the Taliban government being more liberal and in sync with today's values because they realize there is no other way towards a strong self reliant and prosperous nation.
 
.
Afghans know in their heart that India has held their best interests in heart. In the long march towards stability and development India will continue to support in the same way. I see the Taliban government being more liberal and in sync with today's values because they realize there is no other way towards a strong self reliant and prosperous nation.

Have you made any friends with Afghans? They are glowing praise and stoic vision about India role in AFG (the ones I have befriended thus far).
 
.
Afghans know in their heart that India has held their best interests in heart. In the long march towards stability and development India will continue to support in the same way. I see the Taliban government being more liberal and in sync with today's values because they realize there is no other way towards a strong self reliant and prosperous nation.


Loool. You Indians are masters at sucking up no? I've heard what your media says about Taliban. Don't cover up now.
 
.
Afghans know in their heart that India has held their best interests in heart. In the long march towards stability and development India will continue to support in the same way. I see the Taliban government being more liberal and in sync with today's values because they realize there is no other way towards a strong self reliant and prosperous nation.
typical bharat mata style lol
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
Indian boots on the ground in Afghanistan is a must to assist the Kabul government in maintaining grip over the rule of law. Nothing less than that should be acceptable.
 
. .
We should work together with the afghans .

You should try and work together with your immediate neighbour nepal first.

Have you made any friends with Afghans? They are glowing praise and stoic vision about India role in AFG (the ones I have befriended thus far).

Forget Afghanistan and Central Asia for good. While you keep yourself fixated on afghanistan, the dragon keeps on plucking your neighbors one at a time. Nepal is a gone case, check out who the next is; Srilanka, Maldives or Bangladesh. At the end, you would be like

'Dhobi ka kutta - na ghar ka na ghaat ka'
'A launderer's dog has no where to call home; neither the house, nor the laundry'
 
Last edited:
. .
Of course there is. Indian policy in Afghanistan was never in sync with US policy, or with NATO policy. Remember Trump's gibe: the Indians only built a library. Right. Rather than blowing up Afghans, educating them is a better way forward.
Mildly amusing... So, officially a spoiler, policy? Zalmay perhaps(knowingly) then seeks the word from bonafide snakes...

Wonder what's on the catalog of the library, an alphabet soup with a limited shelf life? Mukti Bahini redux? Chanakya's chant written by, a Sanghi? Freal tho?
 
Last edited:
.
Mildly amusing... So, officially a spoiler, policy? Zalmay perhaps(knowingly) then seeks the word from bonafide sankes... I

Wonder what's on the catalog of the library, an alphabet soup with a limited shelf life? Mukti Bahini redux? Chanakya's chant written by, a Sanghi? Freal tho?

It is so sad that a library should invite ridicule instead of praise. However, water must find its own level.
 
.
Have you made any friends with Afghans? They are glowing praise and stoic vision about India role in AFG (the ones I have befriended thus far).
I don't have any Afghani friends on a personal level, but I am well informed about the relationship we share on a national level. Even today there are several Afghan communities in India. We will help them rebuild.
 
.
I don't have any Afghani friends on a personal level, but I am well informed about the relationship we share on a national level. Even today there are several Afghan communities in India. We will help them rebuild.

No joke, Every Indian on this forum is a statistician. When they post they know what all populations think of other populations just based on their imaginary friend..
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom