What's new

US to offer F-35 fighters to India

Sometimes I cannot believe the stupidity. No wonder the Russians and the Americans love India, as long as there are idiots like you. Lets see, suppose China and India do not fight a major war for another 20 years (which is a BIG possibility), what are you going to do with these flying junks that didn't even help you develop your own manufacturing industry? Billions of your hard earned Dell call center money just went to the Russians and the Americans that's the only thing you get. Developing our own fighter is more than just military. It contributes to a range of civil aviation, material science, aerospace engineering, mechanical engineering expertise which will benefit the quality of life in the long run.

And don't think for a second that India has anything to contribute on the technical side of the PAK FA. If India has enough know how to contribute to a top fighter like that it won't be struggling on an obsolete-before-induction LCA.

What do you sugges... get a prototype from junk yard in Ukraine (su 33 ) and develop one ?

or sign contract for 100 and after few say that it does not satisfy our purpose and make a clone of that and tell this is ingeniously developed..

.Yea Inidan IT industry is just 50 billion dollar and every money is not IT money . and even so we know what is strategic investments and how it will pay back.

Our LCA might be obsolete by the time it get inducted, but to fight other fighters (in the vicinity) that are very much in the same category( or even lesser) we dont need any thing better.


Only time will tell , making a fighter with highest amount of composit skin while doing for the first time might not be a simple task.. Inida has done that. so wait and watch
 
. .
Sometimes I cannot believe the stupidity. No wonder the Russians and the Americans love India, as long as there are idiots like you. Lets see, suppose China and India do not fight a major war for another 20 years (which is a BIG possibility), what are you going to do with these flying junks that didn't even help you develop your own manufacturing industry? Billions of your hard earned Dell call center money just went to the Russians and the Americans that's the only thing you get. Developing our own fighter is more than just military. It contributes to a range of civil aviation, material science, aerospace engineering, mechanical engineering expertise which will benefit the quality of life in the long run.

And don't think for a second that India has anything to contribute on the technical side of the PAK FA. If India has enough know how to contribute to a top fighter like that it won't be struggling on an obsolete-before-induction LCA.

I think you are stupid enough, to see your post here. Why should not India join hands with Russia to develop 5th generation fighter, Should we wait till China develops something like that ??
Why you are so worried abt India's spending on its defence sector, is someone asking you to provide loans for that ? They are investing for future threats from neighbourhood. Someone rightly said, If you want to live in peace then you have to be prepared for war today.
BTW why China is doing so much investment if there is no war with India in next 20 yrs as per your thinking??
 
. .
who need f35 when we will be getting a more capable PAK-FA..i dont understand the fuzz.. we got the cash and they will offer us stuff. in future may be even a condom with modern avionics.. American are known to destabilize the region by doing this stuff ..remember Iraq Iran war...i say go for more PAK-FA rather than going for F35 .will be less on pocket .

f-35 will be for IN not for IAF.
stealth fighter for navy sounds good.
 
.
f-35 will be for IN not for IAF.
stealth fighter for navy sounds good.
I don't think so. WHy should we waste giving away billions for something that we can produce in-house given a few years? Once we establish infra for PAKFA and AMCA, all we need is slight modifications of the two fighters and we have a naval version.

JSF is a white elephant and a waste of Indian taxpayer's money. What was touted to be the most lethal jet in the world has now become a nuisance to its own backers. We have money but not money to throw around useless, strings-attached weapon systems.

It was very nice of USA to offer us the F-35 and we appreciate their friendly gesture. But we can continue business and strategic ties through other deals.
 
.
Sounds like a good plan :tup:
You're obviously clueless and you should refrain from making absurd assertions.
Look I know you're not pleased with my comment but try to disagree the same with Australian, Dutch and Norwegian air force officials who've shown apprehensions on JSF when they have absolutely no threat of our proportions around them.

Sometimes I cannot believe the stupidity. No wonder the Russians and the Americans love India, as long as there are idiots like you. Lets see, suppose China and India do not fight a major war for another 20 years (which is a BIG possibility), what are you going to do with these flying junks that didn't even help you develop your own manufacturing industry? Billions of your hard earned Dell call center money just went to the Russians and the Americans that's the only thing you get. Developing our own fighter is more than just military. It contributes to a range of civil aviation, material science, aerospace engineering, mechanical engineering expertise which will benefit the quality of life in the long run.

That's the whole reason AMCA is being started alongside PAKFA, genius. I know you mean well and we've learnt from you guys that indigenous production is also important. AMCA recently got the approval from both the ministry and IAF who stated their requirements. Wind tunnel testing and study process of the design is over. I believe even pics (unlike PS ones that people here are used to) are there of it in one of the threads. See for yourself.


And don't think for a second that India has anything to contribute on the technical side of the PAK FA. If India has enough know how to contribute to a top fighter like that it won't be struggling on an obsolete-before-induction LCA.

India's contributing 25% technologically for the fighter and 50% financially; look it up on Google. It might not be something of super-stealth capability tech and just general, but then China is equally clueless on making stealth fighters as we are. Just because you had an earlier induction of a 4th generation fighter than us doesn't meant that stealth tech magically registers in the minds of your engineers. We're talking about totally new tech here that both you and we are not familiar with when considering F-22 and JSF as potential adversaries.


So change your tone when you want to discuss.
 
.
I think you are stupid enough, to see your post here. Why should not India join hands with Russia to develop 5th generation fighter, Should we wait till China develops something like that ??
Why you are so worried abt India's spending on its defence sector, is someone asking you to provide loans for that ? They are investing for future threats from neighbourhood. Someone rightly said, If you want to live in peace then you have to be prepared for war today.
BTW why China is doing so much investment if there is no war with India in next 20 yrs as per your thinking??
That's because of the apparent 'threat' they face from USA, they'd justify. After all, we tiny, poor Indians are not even on their charts isn't it? :P
 
.
American's showed them Lollypop and they start jumping.

Yeah..............coz we are going to have Chocolate (PAK FA):smokin:

Isn't that funny.....in the future Pak:pakistan: have to worry about another PAK (FA)........just think about it.:devil:
 
.
Yeah..............coz we are going to have Chocolate (PAK FA):smokin:

Isn't that funny.....in the future Pak:pakistan: have to worry about another PAK (FA)........just think about it.:devil:

thats right but think more worst condition for Pakistan if we have f35 and pakfa

think how will be Pakistan condition while we have both pak fa and f35
 
.
thats right but think more worst condition for Pakistan if we have f35 and pakfa

think how will be Pakistan condition while we have both pak fa and f35

May be.................but I am not a F-35 supporter. And I don't think we need another platform, when we can do very well with the current mix and proposed future. If all goes well, why do we need F-35. It requires us to create maintenance and upgrade facilities, and training infrastructure.

Also......its an US plane and US is not very reliable partner.
 
. .
Sometimes I cannot believe the stupidity. No wonder the Russians and the Americans love India, as long as there are idiots like. Lets see, suppose China and India do not fight a major war for another 20 years (which is a BIG possibility), what are you going to do with these flying junks that didn't even help you develop your own manufacturing industry? Billions of your hard earned Dell call center money just went to the Russians and the Americans that's the only thing you get. Developing our own fighter is more than just military. It contributes to a range of civil aviation, material science, aerospace engineering, mechanical engineering expertise which will benefit the quality of life in the long run. And don't think for a second that India has anything to contribute on the technical side of the PAK FA. If India has enough know how to contribute to a top fighter like that it won't be struggling on an obsolete-before-induction LCA.

:blah::blah::blah::blah::blah:
 
Last edited:
.
Sometimes I cannot believe the stupidity. No wonder the Russians and the Americans love India, as long as there are idiots like you.


No wonder the Russians and the Americans love India, as long as there are idiots like you.......Means your country don't have idiots, thats very gud to know.

Russians and the Americans love India, so do French, British, Swedish, Italian, Israeli, American, Soviet, and many other countries. Thats why we are able to get whatever we want from anywhere; whether it being fighter jets, submarine, chopper, tanks, ships, missiles, or even Nuclear Deal. I wish our romance with these countries carry on for centuries. This is clear indication of our reputation and image at world stage. They trust us and know that we are a responsible country.

If China get the same option, I am very much sure that they will leave copy/pasting the Soviet tech and go for the Western equipment. But as they are not idiot and very brainy, West put arms embargo on them, Russian hesitate to sell them now, and USA........what to say!!!

Don't cover your bad reputation and relations with world with praising so callled self-sufficiency. Everybody knows what and how you are producing and what research you made for that.


Lets see, suppose China and India do not fight a major war for another 20 years (which is a BIG possibility), what are you going to do with these flying junks that didn't even help you develop your own manufacturing industry?

Flying Junks.........you are talking about Russian and US fighter planes, right? Do you really think they are junks?.........If yes, I quit.

These flying junks give you the security.........not only the feeling, but the real security. Any country, even US, will think 10 times before attacking a country who got these junks. You don't need to use your weapons every time. In most of the cases, their possession is enough. China and India do not fight a major war for another 20 years.......yes this is a BIG possibility.........just because of these kind of junks India have.


Billions of your hard earned Dell call center money just went to the Russians and the Americans that's the only thing you get.

Really?..............We will get the Hardcore military equipments too. And two world superpowers as our ally. What else you want?


Developing our own fighter is more than just military. It contributes to a range of civil aviation, material science, aerospace engineering, mechanical engineering expertise which will benefit the quality of life in the long run.

Hummm..........but we are smart enough (oh sorry, Idiot enough) that our Defence Ministry formulated the Defence Procurement Policy (DPP) in 2005. According to the DPP, at least 30% of any order over Rs. 300 crores (~US$70 million) is to be sourced from Indian companies. This would enable Indian companies to gain expertise in defence-related technologies, as well as cycle back a large amount of any order back into the country. Good move...........isn't it?


As you are so much concerned about civil aviation of India.....just read:

Indian aerospace industry opens up
By Siva Govindasamy

India is fast becoming a major global aerospace market, aided by a combination of increasing defence spending, a booming commercial aviation market, and rising technological and manufacturing capabilities among local companies.

Comparisons with China, a major supplier for several OEMs and where AVIC, the state-owned manufacturer had a several-decades head start in manufacturing military and civil aircraft, are almost inevitable.

There will certainly not be the equivalent of Japan's Mitsubishi Heavy Industries or Kawasaki Heavy Industries - which are tier 1 suppliers for the likes of Boeing - any time soon. Even tiny Singapore, through maintenance, repair and overhaul firm ST Aerospace, has a company with a bigger global presence.

However, almost every major Western aerospace firm wants to establish a presence in the country that is one of the largest markets for both civil and military aircraft. Stringent offset requirements in fulfilment of those tenders, a government that is keen to create a manufacturing hub, and indigenous firms with greater freedom to set up partnerships and participate the sector - and establish a niche in the global supply chain along the way - all help to boost this.

"The Indian aerospace industry is one of the fastest-growing aerospace markets in the world with an expanding consumer base comprising airlines, businesses and high-net-worth individuals. The rapid growth of this industry has attracted major global aerospace companies to India. All segments in the aerospace industry, including civil and military aviation and space, are showing a significant level of growth," analysts from PricewaterhouseCoopers said in a 2009 report.

Frost & Sullivan, a research firm, says that since 2005 air traffic has grown by 18%, the cargo market has increased by 14% and overall passenger movement by 20%. Despite the downturn, international and domestic aircraft movements could grow by 13% and 14% respectively over the next seven years. Passenger growth is projected to be 20% domestically and 16% in the international segment, while cargo expansion of 12% and 10% is expected in the domestic and international markets.

Link is here:
Indian aerospace industry opens up


And don't think for a second that India has anything to contribute on the technical side of the PAK FA. If India has enough know how to contribute to a top fighter like that it won't be struggling on an obsolete-before-induction LCA.

What to say.........please help yourself

India to develop 25% of fifth generation fighter
Ajai Shukla / New Delhi January 6, 2010, 0:36 IST


Scrutinising the Sukhoi Corporation’s work on the Fifth Generation Fighter Aircraft (FGFA) — a project that India will soon sign up to co-develop — gives one an idea of Russia’s size, and its aerospace expertise. During daytime, in Moscow, the Sukhoi Design Bureau conceptualises FGFA components; by 10 pm the drawings are electronically transmitted over 5,000 kilometres to a manufacturing unit in Siberia. Here, at KnAAPO (Komsomolsk-on-Amur Aircraft Production Organisation) — seven time zones away — it is already 5 am next morning. Within a couple of hours, the drawings start being translated into aircraft production.

Having designed over 100 aircraft (including India’s Su-30MKI), built over 10,000 fighters, and with 50 world aviation records to its credit, Sukhoi understandably regards Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd (HAL) — its partner-to-be in designing the FGFA — as very much the greenhorn.

But the newcomer wants its due. Bangalore-based HAL has negotiated firmly to get a 25 per cent share of design and development work in the FGFA programme. HAL’s work share will include critical software, including the mission computer (the Su-30MKI mission computer is entirely Indian); navigation systems; most of the cockpit displays; the counter measure dispensing (CMD) systems; and modifying Sukhoi’s single-seat prototype into the twin-seat fighter that the Indian Air Force (IAF) wants.

THE FIFTH GENERATION FIGHTER:
Cost of development $8-10 billion
India's requirement 250 fighters
Russia's requirement 250 fighters
Cost per aircraft $100 million
Indian name FGFA
Russian name PAK FA

India will also contribute its expertise in aircraft composites, developed while designing the Tejas Light Combat Aircraft (LCA). Russia has traditionally built metallic aircraft; just 10 per cent of the Su-30MKI fuselage is titanium and composites. The FGFA’s fuselage, in contrast, will be 25 per cent titanium and 20 per cent composites. Russia’s expertise in titanium structures will be complemented by India’s experience in composites.

With India’s work share almost finalised, the 2007 Russia-India Inter-Governmental Agreement (IGA) to build the FGFA will soon evolve into a commercial contract between Russia’s United Aircraft Corporation (UAC) and HAL. Ashok Baweja, until recently the chairman of HAL, told Business Standard: “When HAL and UAC agree on terms, they will sign a General Contract. This will include setting up a JV to design the FGFA, and precise details about who will fund what.”

Have Fun:smokin:
 
.
I don't think so. WHy should we waste giving away billions for something that we can produce in-house given a few years?


do u think that we can produce a 5th gen fighter for navy in few year

Once we establish infra for PAKFA and AMCA, all we need is slight modifications of the two fighters and we have a naval version.
slight modification...do u think only slight modification can covert pak fa for carrier and again after having pak fa how long it will take for slight modification

JSF is a white elephant and a waste of Indian taxpayer's money. What was touted to be the most lethal jet in the world has now become a nuisance to its own backers. We have money but not money to throw around useless, strings-attached weapon systems.
.


do u have any other choice for IN.


Ur view r welcome ,,,,,
 
.
Back
Top Bottom