US cannot counter China in Asia without India's support: MK Narayanan

[singh sahab]

My views are American views. I would be false flagging if I put a Pakistani flag

You are a Pakistani who is posing to be an American to bash India and hoping doesn't get bashed in return. Your post are an explicit example

 

[Echo_419]

I do not want US to bases troops in India. India need to protect itself instead of relying on us. If it's up to me, I want troop withdrawal across from Asia and Europe, leaving a token presence in strategic areas such as Singapore and Hormuz.

Didn't knew non Americans had a say on American Foreign Policy

 

[axisofevil]

the oldgaurd in CIA andits stooges all over the world are trying to restart the old equations but they forget much has changed

no matter what india wont side with USA and be used as a US proxy against china as india and china friendship is the onli way forward for a better future for both of us great nations

india will definatelli form an allience with vietnam +japan+phillpines and US but that dosent means india is going to war with china

itwill be like a balancing act by india much against the immidiate dangers posted by pakistan china courtship

we will give china constructive opposition

Wrong man. Read this

B. Raman was a part of this think tank before he died


INDIA-RUSSIA STRATEGIC COOPERATION: Time to move away | South Asia Analysis Group

 

[SQ8]

hatred is, but at least we are not some one else's proxy. that much you have to admit.

Proxy of convenience, not proxy by force. Pakistan hates India because it does, not because China wants it to... that much you have to admit.

 

[axisofevil]

One stone two birds, isn't that clear enough?, US's present in IOR is very welcome, you can contain China and keep India in check at the same time, isn't that wounderfull.

It's your country's fault. Your hegemonic ambitions is what has created this scenario. Learn from your past infinite Chinese wisdom, and realize how your mistakes have led to this.

 

[Donatello]

Former diplomats are not expected to make balanced statement and there are plenty.

He can even say US can only colonize pluto with help of Russia.

Fine, but then a true diplomat would maintain his sanity under all circumstances.

 

[WAR-rior]

That is a very "Be my daddy" comment. One would have expected a more balanced statement from a former diplomat coming from the country known for its balanced poise within its region.

Why shud he be balanced? Hes afterall an EX. He caan shoot his mouth without any accountability.

 

[SQ8]

You're just mad that you didn't get your way with and after the British. You are also mad we split your country and kept Kashmir and Hyderbad. Trust me, we know.

Making idiotic comments will only have you thrown out. Be glad we let you on this forum for such a long while.. as a joke on the rest of the members.

 

[Tshering22]

The ancient Pakistanis ruled Indians from the Taj Mahal for 800 years. With our Chinese nuclear missile help, they will enter Delhi again like Timur the great conqueror. You will woe your ghar wapsi on your minority then.

Okay here are some things FYI

1- Timur was a Chagtai Turk; not even remotely south Asian.

2- There was no nation called Pakistan until 68 years ago.

3- Taj Mahal is a tomb, Not a palace.

4- Only a Pakistani would raise the question of ghar wapsi so vehemently. What's wrong with Communists on this? It is our country, our wish.

5- Like in any political establishment, there are pro and anti something entities. This man thinks that we should actively support US in holding you guys back. Then there are those who want to completely run into your arms as well.

However, the government policies are decided by seeing the pros and cons of everything.

Even CCP despite its unlimited and unquestioned political power in China will not be hasty or rash.

Politics is all about sensibility.

 

[shree835]

Former National Security Adviser MK Narayanan is good for nothing...Just to make news he has given this statement... This useless guy became NSA all because of Italian Sonia the Mino...The Antonio Mino.

 

[Luca1]

Just how many Indians here really believe US cannot counter China without Indian support?

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

It's your country's fault. Your hegemonic ambitions is what has created this scenario. Learn from your past infinite Chinese wisdom, and realize how your mistakes have led to this.

Sure blame everything on us, nobody ask you nor prevent you to have honeymoon with US. We chinese will sure welcome more US navy activities in Indian Ocean because we Chinese has nothing to lose there . The more internation navy involvement in Indian Ocean, the less Indian Navy significant will be...that why our Subs was there to trigger and get US navy attention...so American can use that as an excuse to get more involvment in Indian Ocean and Indian will have not option but to accept more US present...and guess who is the ultimate loser

 

[Jlaw]

KOCHI: Former National Security Adviser MK Narayanantoday said the US cannot counter China in the Asian region without India's support.

"India is the only country in the Asian region capable of standing against China," Narayanan said while delivering a keynote address at a two-day conference on 'US Rebalance and the Asia Pacific Region', here.

He said Chinese "exceptionalism poses a danger" to all countries which have an interests in Asia and India's approach to the situation that prevails in the region is different.

Citing loopholes in the way Washington operates in the region to counter China, Narayanan said, "The US cannot hope to go it alone or hope to succeed only with the support of smaller nations. India must factor
very highly in the designs of the United States."

There are certain incompatibilities between Washington's rebalancing strategy and India's priorities, he said in the conference also attended by former RAW chief PK Hormis Tharakan.

The former West Bengal Governor said India's effort is to see that the situation in the region "does not reach a point where China feels it could threaten India's position in Asia".

He said India does not want to see itself as a nation seeking to contain China individually or in association with the United States in the region.

Referring to the defence capabilities of both the nations, Narayanan said the current reality is that despite the Chinese military build up, China does not have any major advantage vis-a-vis India.

Speaking on the occasion, US Consul General Phillip Min said, "India's Act East policy and our rebalance to Asia are complementary approaches based on our shared democratic values and respect for the stability and prosperity that the rules-based international system has brought to the world."

"And as the United States implements our rebalance, we see India as a fundamental provider of economic growth and security across the region," Min said.

The two-day conference, which began today, is hosted by the US Consulate General, Chennai, in association with the Center for Public Policy Research (CPPR).

US cannot counter China in Asia without India's support: MK Narayanan - The Economic Times

----------
Indeed US is just useless without India , my comment stop here..better do more and talk less @kurup

This is written for an Indian stand up comic?

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

Just how many Indians here really believe US cannot counter China without Indian support?

For your information, go watch Indian 2030 video than you will understand how Indians can come up with such claim.

 

[KAL-EL]

One stone two birds, isn't that clear enough?, US's present in IOR is very welcome, you can contain China and keep India in check at the same time, isn't that wounderfull.

Your 'double meaning' is blatantly obvious, but you're laying it on a bit thick.