Twitter Trend #DeportAllRefugees started by SIndhis aims at deporting All Afghan Refugees

[hamilcar of carthage]

No tata kho za khom lagyayum, chae puhktoon sirf da pakistan di, asae wakht tarae ao khpal soch kae lag dae kor na bahar roza ao laga dunya owena, dunya sta na sirf na tawegi.

This 5000 story ran its course. Pakistani pushtunes are tired of Afghans themselves.

Ground realities tell a different tale.

 

[tarrar]

There is no choice but to deport all Afghan refugees out of Pakistan asap, there is no more reason left to keep national security threat in Pakistan. All they have done is caused trouble or harm to Pakistan.

 

[tman786]

Recall afghan fans who attacked Pak fans in the UK last year?

You bet these afghan namaak haraamis lived in Pak before smuggling themselves into the UK.

Kick them all out..with force if possible

 

[Flash_Ninja]

Just asking: What about Pashtuns' political unity under the Pakistan? Do the Pakistani people welcome such an approach? More precisely, is there such a trend in the country's recent history?

I'd say that Pakistani Pashtuns have a stronger Pakistani identity. There's groups like PTM, but the base of their support tends to be through Afghan refugees.

There's also ANP which used to have a big following in KPK and FATA, but has been slowly dying when PTI came to the scene.

 

[krash]

Stop the hate. After 40+ years in the country they don’t have any other country that they can call home. Many of them were born in Pakistan and are eligible for Pakistani citizenship.

Pakistan does not afford the right to citizenship by birth to anyone.

Just asking: What about Pashtuns' political unity under the Pakistan? Do the Pakistani people welcome such an approach? More precisely, is there such a trend in the country's recent history?

Pukhtuns aren't exactly a single political entity on both sides of the border. For example, twice Afghans have tried to invade Pakistani territory, both times they were beaten back by Pakistani Pukhtun Tribal Militias. The divide has only further increased since they came over as refugees.

There was a time when an overwhelming majority of Pakistanis supported Afghans, Pukhtun or otherwise. However, seeing their track record over the decades, here as refugees and across the border as geopolitical rivals, their welcome has long since run out, both amongst Pukhtuns and the rest of Pakistan.

Ground realities tell a different tale.

Tell that to the proud Pakistani Pukhtuns who've been beating Afghans black and blue since the 60s.

 

[Iltutmish]

Pakistan does not afford the right to citizenship by birth to anyone.

http://www.dgip.gov.pk/Files/Immigration.aspx

(i) Citizen by Birth:
Persons who or any of their parents or grand parents were born in the territories now included in Pakistan before the commencement of citizenship Act, 1951 are citizens of Pakistan.
Any person born in Pakistan after the commencement of Pakistan Citizenship Act, 1951 is citizen of Pakistan. Children of foreign diplomats and children of enemy alien born in Pakistan are not included in this category.

 

[hamilcar of carthage]

Pakistan does not afford the right to citizenship by birth to anyone.



Pukhtuns aren't exactly a single political entity on both sides of the border. For example, twice Afghans have tried to invade Pakistani territory, both times they were beaten back by Pakistani Pukhtun Tribal Militias. The divide has only further increased since they came over as refugees.

There was a time when an overwhelming majority of Pakistanis supported Afghans, Pukhtun or otherwise. However, seeing their track record over the decades, here as refugees and across the border as geopolitical rivals, their welcome has long since run out, both amongst Pukhtuns and the rest of Pakistan.



Tell that to the proud Pakistani Pukhtuns who've been beating Afghans black and blue since the 60s.

Proud Pakistani Pukhtoon has not been beating afghans since the 60s maybe indians. I guess being Indian blood brothers, the inferiority complex is still embedded in you. We all know who have really taken advantage of pashtoons for the past 70 years and what they have endured for 20 years in this stupid war. Apart from that, Afghanis are not building kalabagh dam to flood a whole city for their benefit.

 

[krash]

Proud Pakistani Pukhtoon has not been beating afghans since the 60s maybe indians.

"This incursion was repelled by Pakistani forces and local tribesmen inflicting heavy casualties on afghan infiltrators."

http://yalejournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/Article-Gartenstein_Ross-and-Vassefi.pdf

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bajaur_Campaign

Since the 60s.

I guess being Indian blood brothers, the inferiority complex is still embedded in you.

Elevated a little after feeding, clothing, sheltering and providing alms to millions of Afghan brothers for decades.

We all know who have really taken advantage of pashtoons for the past 70 years and what they have endured for 20 years in this stupid war.

They really have. No one has suffered or given more than the Pakistani Pukhtuns. All because right across the border from them is a cesspool of terrorism.

Apart from that, Afghanis are not building kalabagh dam to flood a whole city for their benefit.

1) Kalabagh dam is not being built.

2) Pukhtuns don't live where the Kalabagh Dam would be built.

3) Afghanis cannot build anything. Not even a country.

 

[hussain0216]

Get them out

Get them out

It's enough
We have all had enough


Right from the foundation of Pakistan these afghans have been after us for the first 30 years we did nothing to them

Then we took in millions of them and help defeat a superpower

They spread terrorism everywhere



And now even whilst born here they plot with PTM and NDS


Enough,. GET THEM OUT

 

[krash]

http://www.dgip.gov.pk/Files/Immigration.aspx

(i) Citizen by Birth:
Persons who or any of their parents or grand parents were born in the territories now included in Pakistan before the commencement of citizenship Act, 1951 are citizens of Pakistan.
Any person born in Pakistan after the commencement of Pakistan Citizenship Act, 1951 is citizen of Pakistan. Children of foreign diplomats and children of enemy alien born in Pakistan are not included in this category.

I stand corrected. Thank you.

It is their birth-right under the constitution and should be afforded to them asap.

I WILL CITE RESEARCH PAPER, READ THAT, https://www.researchgate.net/public...Kala_Bagh_Dam_Pakistan_to_Flood_Risk_A_Review
IF YOU THINK KALABAGH IS A DREAM THAT WILL CHANGE PAKISTAN.
YAH, AND WHOSE FAULT WAS IT FOR BEING HIRED GUNS. WHOSE FAULT WAS IT NOT BUILDING THE FENCE BACK THEN. WHOSE FAULT WAS IT THAT OUR ECONOMY IS IN DOLDRUM. WHOSE FAULT WAS IT THAT INDIA CAN BULLY US. WHOSE FAULT IS IT THAT THEY COME INSIDE PAKISTAN AND BOMB US AND WE ONLY BOMB INIDAN OCCUPIED KASHMIR. WHOSE FAULT WAS IT THAT WE LOST BANGLADESH. WHOSE FAULT WAS IT THAT WE ARE INDEBTED TO PARIS CLUB. WHOSE FAULT WAS IT THAT WE LOST SIACHIN IN 80S. Whose fault is it that in 48 our armed forces did not take part with the tribal people in liberating Kashmir. I guess Afghanis have a lot to talk about in their defence. Pakistan got paid and thats why they kept afghanis for so long. When the money ended so ended the refuge. Pakistanis did not keep them for goodwill, its all about money.

Yeah look at how Siachin and the formation of Bangladesh ruined the Afghans and the riches Pakistan has made off their refugees. Please don't flood the thread with nonsense which has nothing to do with the topic or what is being discussed.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

Who has the political will to kick a few million Afghans, some of whom have been born in Pakistan, and for all intents and purposes are Pakistanis?

Will PPP force them out? They are running Sindhis and Karachiites into the ground. Yet here comes convenient Afghans to scapegoat for all their problems.

Pakistanis need to be sensible here and not become emotional. You have known mafia and criminals of PPP, who at times threaten treason and betrayal to our state to keep Pakistan from targetting them.

PPP is the big problem here, not Afghans who are earning their daily bread for their families.

If there are criminals, either Pakistan or Afghan, they should be arrested and have charges brought against them. A whole population should not be penalized.

Good luck with PPP. I already know their next trick, they will say Imran Khan is supporting Afghans in Pakistan for Pukhtoon dominance. Shame on Zardari and Bilawal.

 

[Genghis khan1]

Who ever promise this for next elections, will get the most votes. Expulsion of Afghan, Completion of Dams and ICBM.

 

[Ahmet Pasha]

They should be respectfully repatriated not deported.

 

[Max]

I don't hate them, I consider them (Afghans) my brother except the ethnic terrorists , but I can't ignore just demand of Sindhis. Sindh should not be treated as international hub for refugees.

Punjab should take some responsibility, take half Afghan, Bengali, Burmese from Sindh at least.

 

[FuturePAF]

Having spend the past 40 years hosting the Afghan refugees in Pakistan, and on the verge of an end to the Afghan wars, it would be counterproductive to say the least to expel the Refugees.

The deep connections formed by the bulk of the refugees will incentivize Afghans to view Pakistan as an Ally, once a more representative government comes to power in Kabul. These 40 years have bonded the two countries and now is the time to focus on economic development so that what many view as a burden can be viewed as a major plus.

Goodwill should not be squandered, and a plan for Afghan reconstruction with FDI (which could responsibly allow Afghans to return home if they so chose) can benefit both nations.

With peace, Afghan Mining and modernized Agriculture that gets processed and exported via Pakistan is a major opportunity that can pay to rebuild the Afghan nation and help build up both nation’s economies. Karachi as a city with a major Pashtun population and a port city would have an incentive to do business for Afghan minerals over any other city in the region.

Iran’s hostility and recent murderous actions have tarnished their trade potential, we should not do the same by expelling the refugees.