TRADERS VERSION ON THE SHABBAR ZAIDI TAX SYSTEM

[Yaseen1]

I think he should come and explain more and more to the people because the other side is also playing with the sentiment if people by building a fake narrative of fictional taxes .
Aptama ended their strike after 17 days today . So their issue is solved now of machenism of repayment .
Traders and retailers have to give taxes and people think only very few tax comes from here. While the major chunk would come from here.
Haven't seen shabbar for many days. He must come often and explain his policy .
He is a very intellgent and as in his own old interviews he said that even ever government tries to mend thing either they don't do in the fear of people or people and powerful lobbies and mafia acts against them .
Markets are all open but the traders the real problem makers who stock things and can create shortage or excess of anything and they have to come under the net.
Why not our factories have direct outlets that diliver directly to the retailers.

Traders are major investors as most markets are keeping the products supplied by traders and have not bought it but keep them on credit/ sale or return basis .Factories and suppliers cannot do this directly as they need money immediately and cannot give their products to shops or retail outlets on credit and also they have no warehouse, storage facilities and inventory management is not their major focus, their focus is to produce or supply products and involving in such things will cost them much which not feasible for them unless they have huge capital available to buy whole supply chain which is very difficult in Pakistan like poor country.Chairman fbr has to work silently and it is work of finance ministry to interact with media.If too many people speak to media it creates confusion and doubts in public.This chairman fbr has failed to raise more taxes on politicians such as on members of parliament and ministers and is wasting huge money in conducting seminars/confrences at five star hotels and for media projections.He should not use his post for political purposes

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

People who can't pay tax , should close their business and go on road ask bheek

Not responsibility of state to give subsidies

 

[airmarshal]

When traders are paid by consumers, the GST part is government's. I think the traders have not been honest paying that part too. The only way it can be documented is to encourage consumer not carry cash or show CNIc on every transaction.

IK and his team is not childish. The only way forward for the country is to generate income from its own resources. And everyone will have to pitch in.

In Canada, USA or Europe. Look at each of the First World countries. Each of them have robust tax system. No one here can escape taxation. Even if you have no income for a year, a student, you still have to file tax.

Childish is when you find excuses not to pay taxes as these traders are.

All these traders. They will be f*cking crying al l the time about conditions and environment. It has to be better no doubt. There should be no crime and there should be stable policies. But those same traders, you will see them prospering. Adding more branches or expanding their shops. But when ask to pay tax, they will protest!!!

 

[Maxpane]

traders are thieves

 

[Malik Usman]

These are those culprits who sell smuggled items came from Afghanistan and Iran. That's why they don't want to give the information to Govt. and making lame excuses.....These are the people who give million of rupees to Noora League and PPP for Party fund and when it comes for country they start crying........