Top Indian Myths about Pakistan!

[manojb]

Myth#4 is your delusion!Where did u get the numbers?
Seriiously where did the money go?

 

[Jade]

Indians like to say Pakistanis are the same as Indians.

Yet they will never dare to come to western or southwestern Pakistan and say this.

are you high?

 

[democracyspeaks]

Regarding Myth1 only people out here belive pakistan won 1965 war and India has always been the aggressor.

But the Generals and AMs who fought the war thinks different.
So either the pakistani generals/AMs dont have any knowledge or may be ppl out here knows more than them.

Follow my post regarding Myth1 along with links.

http://www.defence.pk/forums/naval-forces/9883-india-offers-pakistan-joint-naval-exercises-5.html#post769598

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Myth#4 is your delusion!Where did u get the numbers?
Seriiously where did the money go?

Myth 4 may not be as much of a myth now, but at the time almost every other Indian on this forum and elsewhere was making comments about related to the size of Pakistan's defence budget. There were even articles in the Indian press that made these absurd claims.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Regarding Myth1 only people out here belive pakistan won 1965 war and India has always been the aggressor.

But the Generals and AMs who fought the war thinks different.
So either the pakistani generals/AMs dont have any knowledge or may be ppl out here knows more than them.

Follow my post regarding Myth1 along with links.

http://www.defence.pk/forums/naval-forces/9883-india-offers-pakistan-joint-naval-exercises-5.html#post769598

The point being that India has really only won one war, and that is 1971. 1965 is at best a stalemate.

And read through the rest of the thread please, all of you, instead of regurgitating the same arguments again and again. Almost all the recent replies have covered old ground and I am not responding to the same point again and again.

 

[manojb]

Myth 4 may not be as much of a myth now, but at the time almost every other Indian on this forum and elsewhere was making comments about related to the size of Pakistan's defence budget. There were even articles in the Indian press that made these absurd claims.

If u have source link pl post. Otherwise it must be indian version of haqs moosing! Defence budget for each coutntry is well documented if notaccurate.

 

[PakSher]

According to the wikipedia the Indian Defence Budget is $32.35 billion dollars $6.35 billion more than $26 billion in Myth#4.

Indian Armed Forces - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Now I can state this before hand that from Indian members responses that wikipedia is wrong. But same wikipedia has been used for several Indian members as references before. Indians please do not contradict yourselves now.

 

[faisaljaffery]

Total budget outlay of Pakistan for FY 2010-2011 is projected to be around 3200 billion with a defense budget of 442 billion (14% of total budget outlay) so myth of 70% spending on defense is totally misconceived

 

[Sparten80]

Dont worry abt other peoples myths abt you....

 

[ramu]

The point being that India has really only won one war, and that is 1971. 1965 is at best a stalemate.

And read through the rest of the thread please, all of you, instead of regurgitating the same arguments again and again. Almost all the recent replies have covered old ground and I am not responding to the same point again and again.

And the best part is in each war, the element of surprise was with Pakistan.Pakistan decided the place and timing for the first assault but as you admitted correctly not a single chapter ends with Pakistan on the victory deck.

 

[PakSher]

And the best part is in each war, the element of surprise was with Pakistan.Pakistan decided the place and timing for the first assault but as you admitted correctly not a single chapter ends with Pakistan on the victory deck.

100% Kashmir was in India when the 1948 War started and then Pakistan captured 21% of Kashmir before the war ended. So. Ramu says"Pakistan decided the place and timing for the first assault but as you admitted correctly not a single chapter ends with Pakistan on the victory deck."

When the 1965 War started 79% Kashsmir was in India and at the end of the war India has 74% left, another loss of 5%. Ramu says"Pakistan decided the place and timing for the first assault but as you admitted correctly not a single chapter ends with Pakistan on the victory deck."

1971 War was not even a war because India knew the only way to fight Pakistan is through insurgency with other people, so 20 years of Muqti Bani terrorist training camps.

Ramu: check the map of Kashmir on August 14th 1947 and check the map now and you will know, who won 1948 and 1965. If you still do not see it see a optomotrist or a psychitrist.

India looses territory is both wars and Indian history book are telling kids India won the wars, what are you smoking dude?

 

[Hulk]

Dude 1948 you attacked Kashmir which was not India. India came in later after Maharaja signed treaty of accesion. So what you won was not against India but against Kashmir.

 

[PakSher]

Dude 1948 you attacked Kashmir which was not India. India came in later after Maharaja signed treaty of accesion. So what you won was not against India but against Kashmir.

LOL, so why the Indian Army did not take the captured area back from the small weak poor Pakistan Army?

 

[brahmastra]

#1,#2 are not myth anymore.

#3 is completely goes off topic with the thread title myth about pakistan.
so, the topic should be pakistan not India.

#4 its your money and I never heard any one saying in India that pak spends 70% on defence. btw, it iss your money and you can do what ever you want.

#5. no one cares what is the center point of pak politics as far as other country don't become victim of pak sponsored terrorism.

 

[BJlaowai]

100% Kashmir was in India when the 1948 War started and then Pakistan captured 21% of Kashmir before the war ended. So. Ramu says"Pakistan decided the place and timing for the first assault but as you admitted correctly not a single chapter ends with Pakistan on the victory deck."

Pakistan (or atleast Pakistani pastun proxies) attacked the independant princely state of Jammu and Kashmir in october 1947 and almost captured the whole state, before the maharaja of Kashmir decided to acceed J&K to India. Only then India entered the war and pushed back the invading Paksitani forces. India gained terroritory in J&K from nothing in 1947 to almost 2/3rd area in 1948.

When the 1965 War started 79% Kashsmir was in India and at the end of the war India has 74% left, another loss of 5%. Ramu says"Pakistan decided the place and timing for the first assault but as you admitted correctly not a single chapter ends with Pakistan on the victory deck."

Source please.
As far as I recall, Indian forces were threatening Muzaffarabad before Pakistan decided to attack Akhnur in operation Grand Slam to relive the pressure on Muzaffarabad.

1971 War was not even a war because India knew the only way to fight Pakistan is through insurgency with other people, so 20 years of Muqti Bani terrorist training camps.

Whatever you may call it, for most of the people it was great war which India won decisively. If by not calling it a war, may be it will mitigate some of your shame of defeat, so be it.
Just wonder why over 90,000 Pakistanis decided to surrender to Indian army in East Pakistan and call themselves POW's.

Ramu: check the map of Kashmir on August 14th 1947 and check the map now and you will know, who won 1948 and 1965. If you still do not see it see a optomotrist or a psychitrist.

Dude, You too need a reality check.

India looses territory is both wars and Indian history book are telling kids India won the wars, what are you smoking dude?

loose territtory? like in 1971 loose half the country and in 1984 loose the Siachen glacier?
What did Pakistan gain in 1965, inspite of starting the war with operations Gibraltar and Grand slam?