What's new

Threat of Sino-Indian battle looms large ahead of 50th anniv of 1962 war

New Recruit

Joined
Jul 8, 2012
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Threat of Sino-Indian battle looms large ahead of 50th anniv of 1962 war



While Beijing spars verbally with New Delhi on a regular basis over Arunachal Pradesh and, more recently, displayed belligerence on the issue of oil hunting in South China Sea, the Communist neighbour could now be spoiling for an actual fight.

The threat of a Sino-Indian skirmish that may push the two Asian giants to the brink of war is so real that it has set the alarm bells ringing in the top echelons of the Union government. And, uncannily, the warning about the gathering war clouds comes just a few months before the 50th anniversary of the real war that had broken out between the countries when China launched simultaneous offensives in Ladakh and across the McMahon Line on October 20, 1962.

Last week, India's external intelligence agency Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) informed the government in a secret note accessed by Headlines Today that there was a possibility of a skirmish or an incident triggered by China on the Line of Actual Control (LAC). Beijing, the input stated, was contemplating such an action to divert attention from its own domestic trouble.

The assessment, shared with Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, senior national security officials and the brass of the armed forces, is now being discussed at the highest levels of the government and has raised concern.

The RAW note substantiated its claim by pointing to increased Chinese activity along the LAC. For the first time, China had stationed fighter aircraft in the Gongga airfield in the Tibet Autonomous Region throughout the winter months. It also activated new surveillance and tracking radars in the Lanzhou Military Region bordering India as well as in Tsona to monitor Indian activity, the RAW said.

According to the agency, the People's Liberation Army (PLA) conducted a large-scale India specific exercise in the Tibet Autonomous Region and Qinghai Plateau Region on June 14.

The threat assessment was made against the backdrop of these developments, coupled with the perceived threat to China's domestic stability owing to internal political developments, economic problems and social issues in the run-up to the 18th party congress, which would determine a power transfer in March next year.

Ahead of this event, a tectonic shift will be witnessed in China's political landscape in 2012. President Hu Jintao will step down later this year as the general secretary of the Communist Party and hand over the reins to current Vice-President Xi Jinping.

Xi, who is now 58, will take charge as the Chinese President in 2014. Along with Hu, seven out of the nine members of the party's highest decision-making body - the Politburo Standing Committee - are expected to retire. This includes current Premier Wen Jiabao, who is likely to be replaced by Vice-Premier Li Keqiang.

"The Chinese leadership could be tempted to galvanise inherent xenophobic fervour to divert domestic attention to an external threat. In this context, there are two potential areas of tension. The first is the ongoing stand-off in the Scarborough Shoal area and the other is Tibet," the note stated.

Scarborough Shoal, located in South China Sea or West Philippine Sea, is being claimed by three countries: China, the Philippines and Taiwan. Tension between Manila and Beijing grew when the governments of the two nations accused each other of illegally occupying territorial waters near the shoal. It sparked nationalist sentiments in both countries and the word "war" was mentioned by several commentators.

But diplomatic sources disclosed that the Indian assessment was based on the fact that Beijing may not risk a war in South China Sea because it could lead to the US and other Western countries coming to the Philippines' rescue. In the case of the Sino-Indian boundary, however, the possibility of a skirmish was much higher because it was disputed, they explained.

Sources said this assessment took into consideration China's displeasure over the role of the Dalai Lama in allegedly fomenting trouble, including immolations, in Tibet. Provoking a skirmish with India may be part of a deliberate strategy to teach India a lesson, they added.

"A prolonged conflict is, however, unlikely," the report concluded.


indiatoday india-china-border-1962-war-50th-anniversary
I THOUGHT WE WERE AT EQUALS AFTER INDIA TAUGHT THEM A LESSON IN 1967
Chola_incident 1967
 
. .
How come India is so obsess with China that hardly notices.
HAVE YOU EVER HEARD OF "FREE MEDIA"
FROM THAT WE MEAN THAT THERE OTHER MEDIA CHANNELS THAN XINHUA AND CCTV WHO ARE FREE TO REPORT ON ANYTHING THEY LEARN.
INDIA HAS THE WORLD'S LARGEST MEDIA INDUSTRY...AMONG THE MILLIONS OF NEWS ITEMS EVERYDAY IF YOU FIND YOURSELF IN AN ARTICLE I DONT THINK SO YOU SHOULD BE GLOATING ABOUT IT.....
ALSO CHINA HAS NEVER DECLARED AND INVADED NEITHER IT DECLARED AND INVADED IN 1962 with INDIA
Nor IT DID WITH RUSSIA WHEN IT INVADED A RUSSIAN ISLAND...
AND IT IS MENTIONED IN THE ARTICLE THAT THIS TO DIVERT ATEENTION OF THE PEOPLE FROM A SLOWING ECONOMY AND POLITICAL CRISIS.
 
. .
Do these guys in our intel establishment even know the repercussions of a conflict/skirmish on the Sino-Indian border? It's not that simple and straightforward. If the Chinese think that they could repeat a 1962 again, they're sadly mistaken and they know it.

Secondly, China's GDP growth (as is India's) is falling and this would be the worst time for it to indulge in an expensive conflict with India. All this talk of 'diverting the people's attention from China's internal problems' is all hog wash! China wouldn't want to be economically hit at this juncture just because they want to 'divert attention'. This is nothing but clap trap.

Thirdly, Sino-Indian trade is leaping ahead, slated to reach $100 billion in a couple of years. $40 billion in infrastructure and capacity building is underway here by Chinese companies. There's a considerable trade surplus advantage for China too. Remember, it's primarily because of the exports and NOT so much internal consumption that China's is the fastest growing economy. China would therefore never rock the boat at this stage. If external trade is affected, its GDP will sink further and faster which would spell disaster, not to talk of sanctions that would be imposed on Chinese imports to the US and EU, further hitting China's GDP.

So, I think this article from India Today is sensationalist and a gross exaggeration of intel inputs and spins, to increase their circulation and ratings. And that a$$hole Shekhar Gupta is known for the baloney he conjures up like the supposed coup by the Indian Army a few months ago!

Cheers!
 
. .
If wish for India to live peacefully with all its neighbors, China, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka. There is no other country in the world that hostile to all its neighbors
 
.
Do these guys in our intel establishment even know the repercussions of a conflict/skirmish on the Sino-Indian border? It's not that simple and straightforward. If the Chinese think that they could repeat a 1962 again, they're sadly mistaken and they know it.

Secondly, China's GDP growth (as is India's) is falling and this would be the worst time for it to indulge in an expensive conflict with India. All this talk of 'diverting the people's attention from China's internal problems' is all hog wash! China wouldn't want to be economically hit at this juncture just because they want to 'divert attention'. This is nothing but clap trap.

Thirdly, Sino-Indian trade is leaping ahead, slated to reach $100 billion in a couple of years. There's a considerable trade surplus advantage for China too. Remember, it's primarily because of the exports and NOT so much internal consumption that China's is the fastest growing economy. China would therefore never rock the boat at this stage. If external trade is affected, its GDP will sink further and faster which would spell disaster.

So, I think this article from India Today is sensationalist and a gross exaggeration of intel inputs and spins, to increase their circulation and ratings. And that a$$hole Shekhar Gupta is known for the baloney he conjures up like the supposed coup by the Indian Army a few months ago!

Cheers!
WAR CAN USED AS AN EXCUSE FOR A SLOWING ECONOMY FOR AT LEAST 5 YEARS......
BUT I THINK YES....CHINA STANDS TO LOOSE MORE THAN INDIA IN ANY WAR.......
->TRADE DEFICIT CHINA's FAVOUR
->WE CAN EXPECT ATLEAST A TRADE SANCTION FROM THE WEST
->AMERICA WILL GET AN EXCUSE TO FURTHER OPEN ANOTHER MILLITARY BASE IN ASIA..and further justify Missile defence..
->Russia stands to loose more....It would have to choose between CHina and India....One side bigger power and other side millitary engagements worth 200 billion....So Atleast Russia would pissed off at China...


ONLY AN IDIOT WILL DO ANYTHING LIKE THIS....**** YOU SHEKHAR GUPTA.....I ALSO REFUSE TO BELIEVE CHINESE WOULD SHOOT THEMSELVES IN THE FEET LIKE THIS.
 
.
If wish for India to live peacefully with all its neighbors, China, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka. There is no other country in the world that hostile to all its neighbors
See who is Talking..
Everone knows who is Hostile or not.
On topic: I still doubt the authenticity of this article.

WAR CAN USED AS AN EXCUSE FOR A SLOWING ECONOMY FOR AT LEAST 5 YEARS......
BUT I THINK YES....CHINA STANDS TO LOOSE MORE THAN INDIA IN ANY WAR.......
->TRADE DEFICIT CHINA's FAVOUR
->WE CAN EXPECT ATLEAST A TRADE SANCTION FROM THE WEST
->AMERICA WILL GET AN EXCUSE TO FURTHER OPEN ANOTHER MILLITARY BASE IN ASIA..and further justify Missile defence..
->Russia stands to loose more....It would have to choose between CHina and India....One side bigger power and other side millitary engagements worth 200 billion....So Atleast Russia would pissed off at China...


ONLY AN IDIOT WILL DO ANYTHING LIKE THIS....**** YOU SHEKHAR GUPTA.....I ALSO REFUSE TO BELIEVE CHINESE WOULD SHOOT THEMSELVES IN THE FEET LIKE THIS.
Dear Bro , dnt use capital letters...
 
.
Thirdly, Sino-Indian trade is leaping ahead, slated to reach $100 billion in a couple of years. $40 billion in infrastructure and capacity building is underway here by Chinese companies. There's a considerable trade surplus advantage for China too. Remember, it's primarily because of the exports and NOT so much internal consumption that China's is the fastest growing economy. China would therefore never rock the boat at this stage. If external trade is affected, its GDP will sink further and faster which would spell disaster, not to talk of sanctions that would be imposed on Chinese imports to the US and EU, further hitting China's GDP.

India is a Large Market for China also India has a Trade Deficit as the trade increase it will be in China favor, but aside from that 1962 has been discussed to death and China attacking India it seems it's been moved from 2012 to 2014 :azn:
Nervous China may attack India by 2012: Expert - Times Of India

http://www.defence.pk/forums/world-affairs/93421-china-can-attack-india-2014-a.html
 
. .
Can't wait for India to join the SCO there is talk of a FTA it will also be in China favor :azn: :toast_sign:.
India.gif
 
.
If wish for India to live peacefully with all its neighbors, China, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka. There is no other country in the world that hostile to all its neighbors

China ?? Japan ?? there are many countries my friend . You just have not Looked away from India ever . Talk about Obsession :)

Can't wait for India to join the SCO there is talk of a FTA it will also be in China favor :azn: :toast_sign:.
India.gif

We also Hope the Same . Russia , China and India will be the Security Cooperation of this century leaving NATO to bit Dust .
 
.
I believe China is anyway going to democratise in a few decades.
And that will be the end of suspicsions between India and CHina and start of a New found friendship...Why not Wait for a few decades holding our nerves..
There are only few hardliners left in the communist Party let them go away and China democratise....The WEST will have no where to Hide...
 
.
Can't wait for India to join the SCO there is talk of a FTA it will also be in China favor :azn: :toast_sign:.
India.gif

What do you think is the current Chinese internal problem that this article is poiting out?
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom