What's new

The Taliban and Salarzais

sonicboom

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Mar 13, 2009
Messages
704
Reaction score
2
The Taliban and Salarzais



Sunday, September 27, 2009
Farhat Taj

I was in Pakistan in August and had the opportunity to meet the leaders of the anti-Taliban lashkar (volunteer army) of Bajaur’s Salarzai tribe. I am honoured that upon my request they travelled from Bajaur to meet me in Nowshehra and shared with me information about their anti-Taliban struggle. I am not mentioning their names for reasons of their security.

The area of the Salarzai tribe is on the border with Afghanistan. The tribe have collectively decided that there won’t be any Taliban on their soil. The Taliban have been driven out of the Salarzai area. The Salarzai lashkar, mostly made up of labourers and peasants, has successfully kept the Salazai area free of the Taliban.

Tens of Salarzail lashkar leaders have been target-killed. The Salarzai leaders informed me they hold the ISI responsible for the targeted killings. “The Taliban are just a façade. The real force is the ISI punishing us for our anti-Taliban struggle,” said one of the leaders.

The leaders said that Mamond Taliban headquarters used to be in Damadola, which is a few kilometres from the FC fort in Bajaur. The Mamond Taliban used to bomb Salarzai villages. The Salarzai tribal elders requested the Political Agent, the authorities of the FC and the Pakistani army to stop the Mamond Taliban. None of these offered any help. Finally the Salarzai lashkar took positions on the mountains and for two hours heavily bombarded the surrounding villages of the Mamond Taliban. At that point the political agent and a colonel of the army asked the Salarzai lashkar to stop the bombing. They gave the same old logic: who will fight the NATO forces from across the Afghan border if you eliminate the Taliban?

Following such encounters with the state authorities, the Salarzais decided to fire at any forces entering their area: be it the Taliban, Al Qaida, the army or the US or NATO. The Salarzais have taken up positions all over the area and are always on guard. The tribesmen take turns to defend those positions. Unlike the bombed out schools in the Taliban-controlled areas, all schools in the Salarzai region are functioning. The tribesmen are performing security duties in both girls’ and boys’ schools in the area.

The leaders informed me that there is a set pattern of target-killing of anti-Taliban Salarzai leader. Before each targeted killing all telephone links with the far-flung Salarzai area are cut off. The targeted killing takes place in 24 to 48 hours later. The telephone links are restored a couple of days after the assassinated leader has been buried. A day or so later a news item of a few lines appears in the newspapers about the killing. “No one in Pakistan seems to be bothered about the state-sponsored targeted killing of anti-Taliban Salarzai leaders. Our area is too far from the rest of Pakistan and our agony means nothing to fellow-Pakistanis. The Pakistani media never ever tries to probe into the targeted killings,” said one of the Salarzai leaders.

All telephone lines to the Salarzia area were dead the day I was meeting with the leaders. They said they were deeply worried whose turn it might be to be targeted for killing. Two days later the telephone links were restored. The same day they informed me on telephone that Malik Munasib Khan, the spokesman of the Salarzai lashkar, had been killed. They held the ISI responsible for his killing.

The Salarzai leaders also informed me that last year the army deliberately fired at those villages in Bajaur that were known to be staunchly anti-Taliban. They said one of their colleagues called Maj Gen Alam Khattak to ask him to stop the bombing of his village. “Major General Sahib! I will start a vendetta with you if you did not halt the bombing of my village immediately. I will make sure to kill you and your family at the first available opportunity,” they quoted one of their colleagues as saying. The major general asked him to meet Col Sajjad who was bombing the anti-Taliban villages from his base in Timergara. That colleague saw a big Bajaur map affixed on the wall in the office of Col Sajjad. The map had several encircled villages. Col Sajjad informed him that the map had been handed over to him by his commanders with the order to bomb all the encircled villages. “Our colleague’s blood boiled with anger: none of the villages had Taliban in them,” said the Salarzai leaders. The villages included Butmali, Danqul, Attkay, Matasha, Baro, Raghjan and Nazkai.

On the other hand, those Salarzai villages that had Taliban were not marked on the map or bombed by the army. Such villages are Pashat, Banda, Malasyed, Darra and Gundai. Now the Salarzai lashkar has cleared these villages from Taliban control, without any state support.

The leaders also made the accusation that the Salarzais are discriminated against by the state in allocation of developmental funds due to their hostility to the Taliban. The FATA Rural Development Project (FRDP) is working in Bajaur Agency but entire Salarzai area of the agency has been deliberately excluded by from the project. “A wilful under-development has been imposed on us as punishment for our anti-Taliban stance. The Salazai area would be included in FRDP if we allowed the Taliban to take control of our area. Without this, we Salarzais can beg as much as we can for development, but the state will never budge,” said the Salarzai tribal leaders.

The reason I write this piece is not to defame the institution of the Pakistani army, which I hold in high esteem. I just wish to request the President of Pakistan, the Chief of Army Staff and the DG of the ISI to pay attention to the complaints of the Salarzais and resolve their problems to the satisfaction of the tribe. The Salarzai leaders categorically told me they are loyal Pakistanis, but they are not ready to let the peace of their area be destroyed for the power games of the intelligence agencies. All they want from the state is peaceful and development.

I would request fellow-Pakistanis all over the country to support the Salarzais. I wonder why the civil society of Pakistan is so silent over the heroic anti-Taliban struggle of the Salarzais. Salarzais are the natural allies of all those who are against the Taliban and civil society should forcefully support them. I would request the Pakistani media to keep a close watch on the Salarzai area to discourage targeted killings there.

The Taliban are anti-civilisation. The Salarzais are the embodiment of civilisation because they are so oppose to the Taliban. I would request all civilised people in the world to morally support the Salarzais in the name of human civilisation.

The writer is a research fellow at the Centre for Interdisciplinary Gender Research, University of Oslo, and a member of Aryana Institute for Regional Research and Advocacy.

The Taliban and Salarzais
 
Last edited:
. .
A total confusing article

Not at all if you think about it,

India and others(the stress here is on OTHERS) recruit and train these criminals > tells them (and by that I mean blesses them with a very heavy purse) how evil Pakistan and PA is > target kills their enemies (Local Peace Lashkar's) leaders > spreads rumors and false evidence these killings were sponsored by ISI and PA > attains influence / low morale on the two side > the criminals become anti Pakistan which they already are > the Local Lashkars also become vary of PA and ISI > Double Game > Control / influence both sides

if you can understand all that ^ and the meaning of false flag operations then you'll understand what I am saying ;)


:pakistan:
 
Last edited:
.
bull ****

Pakistan army sacrifised a lot in bajor agency during operation Sher dil

one should have shame before posting or publishing such rubbish

My friend asad akbar khan got shahdat in operation sher dil and I find it insult to Pakistan army, ISI and Asad's family and friends to see such propoganda bull ****

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Bajaur
 
Last edited:
.
i dont understand why News papers in pakistan publish such bull ****
and why people read such ANTI LECTUALS without having a back ground cheak

I advice readers to serch Operation Sher Dil and operation lion heart by NATO then judge intellectual dishonesty of The News and The writer

I my self belong to Mamond tribe and its insult to my whole tribe
 
.
Not at all if you think about it,

India and others(the stress here is on OTHERS) recruit and train these criminals > tells them (and by that I mean blesses them with a very heavy purse) how evil Pakistan and PA is > target kills their enemies (Local Peace Lashkar's) leaders > spreads rumors and false evidence these killings were sponsored by ISI and PA > attains influence / low morale on the two side > the criminals become anti Pakistan which they already are > the Local Lashkars also become vary of PA and ISI > Double Game > Control / influence both sides

if you can understand all that ^ and the meaning of false flag operations then you'll understand what I am saying ;)


:pakistan:
The War on the intellectual battle front has been lost - I doubt if the current strategy of sheer muscle power is going to lead anywhere but the ABYSS.
 
.
I think US is trying to divide pushtoon tribes to get control on them , but still all pushtoons are united .
 
.
The Taliban and Salarzais

This report is not deniable, but the "Timing" is not correct in the current scenario.
These all facts are in time of Musharraf rule.Interference of Alqeda and Taliban in Pakistan Army in Musharaf rule is can;t be deniable.
Alqeda and thier Saudi and gulf sponsors spending millions Dollars in all departments: Pakistan Army,mullahs,political parties,journalist and media,and other key Govt. dept.

The Salarzai leaders also informed me that last year the army deliberately fired at those villages in Bajaur that were known to be staunchly anti-Taliban. They said one of their colleagues called Maj Gen Alam Khattak to ask him to stop the bombing of his village. “
The Taliban and Salarzais

report itself speaks that was LAST YEAR incident
 
.
I think US is trying to divide pushtoon tribes to get control on them , but still all pushtoons are united .

Aryana Institute has been recently formed by US and is being funded by US. Many of those working there (i and entire Peshawar media know them, they are called ghla (chor) by local journalist community). They have approached a collegue of mine at my office and given him a task to collect all the data about Orakzai Agency, and other FATA areas. And interestingly they said he will be an internee till the time he has not collected all the data.

There is one woman Farhat Taj who is also on a fellowship in US, Oslo, similarly this man who's BS is published by The News.

The News time to time publishes anti-Army propagand by US Fellowship students from this institute.

This org is formed just few months back, hardly an year passed when it was formed by US with US funds, mainly used for spreading propaganda against Pakistan and Divide Pathans in NWFP.
 
.
Aryana Institute has been recently formed by US and is being funded by US. Many of those working there (i and entire Peshawar media know them, they are called ghla (chor) by local journalist community). They have approached a collegue of mine at my office and given him a task to collect all the data about Orakzai Agency, and other FATA areas. And interestingly they said he will be an internee till the time he has not collected all the data.

There is one woman Farhat Taj who is also on a fellowship in US, Oslo, similarly this man who's BS is published by The News.

The News time to time publishes anti-Army propagand by US Fellowship students from this institute.

This org is formed just few months back, hardly an year passed when it was formed by US with US funds, mainly used for spreading propaganda against Pakistan and Divide Pathans in NWFP.


But Jana what would you say to this: http://www.defence.pk/forums/pakistans-war/26726-swat-report-frontline.html

All the columns that one has seen come out of the institute have had a pro-army bend. :what:


Tens of Salarzail lashkar leaders have been target-killed. The Salarzai leaders informed me they hold the ISI responsible for the targeted killings. “The Taliban are just a façade. The real force is the ISI punishing us for our anti-Taliban struggle,” said one of the leaders.

The Salarzai tribal elders requested the Political Agent, the authorities of the FC and the Pakistani army to stop the Mamond Taliban. None of these offered any help. Finally the Salarzai lashkar took positions on the mountains and for two hours heavily bombarded the surrounding villages of the Mamond Taliban. At that point the political agent and a colonel of the army asked the Salarzai lashkar to stop the bombing. They gave the same old logic: who will fight the NATO forces from across the Afghan border if you eliminate the Taliban?


Have heard the same for the lashkars in Malakand Division... no one comes to help them if the need arises. And heard a very similar story about a colonel in one of the tribal agencies except that he was quoted as saying: "If we go out against the Taliban, they will cut our supplies and we cannot let that happen."


The reason I write this piece is not to defame the institution of the Pakistani army, which I hold in high esteem. I just wish to request the President of Pakistan, the Chief of Army Staff and the DG of the ISI to pay attention to the complaints of the Salarzais and resolve their problems to the satisfaction of the tribe. The Salarzai leaders categorically told me they are loyal Pakistanis, but they are not ready to let the peace of their area be destroyed for the power games of the intelligence agencies. All they want from the state is peaceful and development.

I would request fellow-Pakistanis all over the country to support the Salarzais. I wonder why the civil society of Pakistan is so silent over the heroic anti-Taliban struggle of the Salarzais. Salarzais are the natural allies of all those who are against the Taliban and civil society should forcefully support them. I would request the Pakistani media to keep a close watch on the Salarzai area to discourage targeted killings there.



For all those who have been calling the piece an attempt to malign the Pakistan Army and the government, I would say the writer has clarified her position. May be there is some iota of truth in them... the tribal agencies are extensive, sparsely populated, with little infrastructure. Also, the number of helicopters and other air craft employed in the areas are limited. If any help is dispatched, it will be a long time before it reaches them.

Indeed, if these are real concerns expressed by the Salarazai tribesmen and their leaders, then those in the echelons should take notice. If there is nothing to substantiate the claims of the writer, then they should be discredited with proof.
 
.
But Jana what would you say to this: http://www.defence.pk/forums/pakistans-war/26726-swat-report-frontline.html

All the columns that one has seen come out of the institute have had a pro-army bend. :what:

That is not pro-army stance but there was nothing on ground to make up lies like HRCP did recently. The above report was compiled by a team that visited Swat, if the same was reported sitting in the Islamabad based office the result would have been different.

You can have a different stance and diffeer with me but since we here in Peshawar knows some details about the org so we have a different stance than the readers.




Have heard the same for the lashkars in Malakand Division... no one comes to help them if the need arises. And heard a very similar story about a colonel in one of the tribal agencies except that he was quoted as saying: "If we go out against the Taliban, they will cut our supplies and we cannot let that happen."

The laskhars formed with consent and cooperation of Government were backed and supported. The ones who are taking up arms on their own, indeed there is some delay or lack of support.




For all those who have been calling the piece an attempt to malign the Pakistan Army and the government, I would say the writer has clarified her position. May be there is some iota of truth in them... the tribal agencies are extensive, sparsely populated, with little infrastructure. Also, the number of helicopters and other air craft employed in the areas are limited. If any help is dispatched, it will be a long time before it reaches them.

Indeed, if these are real concerns expressed by the Salarazai tribesmen and their leaders, then those in the echelons should take notice. If there is nothing to substantiate the claims of the writer, then they should be discredited with proof.


The highlighted part in your post suggests itself the reason for lack of support specialy airpower.

On the other hand some recently formed Laskhkars, have asked the government not to deploy its troops as it will create sense of sympathy for militants among the common people.

In such a scenario what could have been done for helping the anti-Taliban lashkars should be done. But again the question is how?

Either you gave them a cover by providing airpower,

2. Provide them weapons but that again is risky as you never know when they turn against you for money from the other player.

Anyway recently the most outstanding vitcories of these local lashkars against militants were only possible with induction of some professionals ;)
 
.
This org is formed just few months back, hardly an year passed when it was formed by US with US funds, mainly used for spreading propaganda against Pakistan and Divide Pathans in NWFP.

So If US with spending billions of dollars on fighting terrorism, they realise to take an alternative route of destroying Pakistan because they could not ponder going straight ahead.
 
.
So If US with spending billions of dollars on fighting terrorism, they realise to take an alternative route of destroying Pakistan because they could not ponder going straight ahead.

US is spending money in pakistan, to make his blackish face to be white.. this will also improve corruption in government, and their allies, and also make pakistan more dependent on US. which means weak pakistan, and could be destroyed, just by removing their support.. It is very simple thing which a illiterate person can also understand.

Most of the people in NWFP knows pretty well, whose currency was used when TTP were recuirting local people. Also, which weapon is circling around whole NWFP.

Prior to 9/11, the US weapon industry was getting destroyed.. but look at them where they are now.. also now how much taxes USA gets from middle east oil trade, from KSA, Iraq, Kuwait etc.. just because of previous of their policies i.e. revoke iraq against Kuwait and here you go.. USA was expecting same thing while attacking afghanistan, because of central asian route to the sea to sell their fossil fuels... Iran and Pakistan are two key players while owning these routes..

And best of all, now USA has eye on china and russia, (china voilence is one example)
 
.
how much money does he get from his masters Raw & CIA for defaming PA and ISI?????
 
.
US is spending money in pakistan, to make his blackish face to be white.. this will also improve corruption in government, and their allies, and also make pakistan more dependent on US. which means weak pakistan, and could be destroyed, just by removing their support.. It is very simple thing which a illiterate person can also understand.

Most of the people in NWFP knows pretty well, whose currency was used when TTP were recuirting local people. Also, which weapon is circling around whole NWFP.

Prior to 9/11, the US weapon industry was getting destroyed.. but look at them where they are now.. also now how much taxes USA gets from middle east oil trade, from KSA, Iraq, Kuwait etc.. just because of previous of their policies i.e. revoke iraq against Kuwait and here you go.. USA was expecting same thing while attacking afghanistan, because of central asian route to the sea to sell their fossil fuels... Iran and Pakistan are two key players while owning these routes..

And best of all, now USA has eye on china and russia, (china voilence is one example)

Very good lecture, but you have forgotten the most important incident, 9/11. Where did that came from? It surely did come from your neck of the neigberhood, hummm!!! Did US start that or it was Pakistan responsibility to control your favored Talibans!!!!
 
.
Back
Top Bottom