The Greatest Generals of World

[waraich66]

What do mean by "devine power"?

During Gazwa Khandak Muhammad PBUH gave basharat of defeat of Persia and Rome.Munafeqeen were laughing at that time.Allah helped muslim army against more then 5 to10 times greater armies of Romans and Persians.

 

[Evil Flare]

What do mean by "devine power"?

Al Mighty ALLAH was Helping there .. Even Before Wars they knew they'll win ... & Mostly Muslim were so low in Numbers compare to their Enemies ...

 

[dabong1]

During Gazwa Khandak Muhammad PBUH gave basharat of defeat of Persia and Rome.Munafeqeen were laughing at that time.Allah helped muslim army against more then 5 to10 times greater armies of Romans and Persians.

What about the Battle of Uhud.....did the muslim not lose becauce they not follow the strategy that was laid out.......defend the flank-rear

You can have all the faith you want but without the right tactics and strategy you will lose......a combination of faith-weapons-tactics used in the right way will make you the winner but to ignore or to underestimate the enemy is folly.

 

[waraich66]

What about the Battle of Uhud.....did the muslim not lose becauce they not follow the strategy that was laid out.......defend the flank-rear

You can have all the faith you want but without the right tactics and strategy you will lose......a combination of faith-weapons-tactics used in the right way will make you the winner but to ignore or to underestimate the enemy is folly.

Agreed both strategy and right faith are important for Holy War.

 

[Peshwa]

Everyone has mentioned some excellent candidates for this position....

However I consider Prophet Mohammed, Jesus and Buddha to be the greatest generals.....these men have conqured people not only in their own lifetime but do so even after their death through their words and ideas....in fact more men would fight for the cause of these men than any general could have inspired their soldiers.....
Its important to note that to conquer someone by way of sword is easy, but one who can capture you without lifting a finger is extraordinary.....Makes one think about the philisophy of "The Pen is mightier than the sword"

Im a fighter at heart, but the more I grow up I realize that being buff and having brute strenght only makes people afraid of you.....a true general is one who people respect and follow out of sheer admiration....one who people would die for....and one whose ideology lives beyond his/her own life...

 

[Omar1984]

Did you read the Title...Greatest Generals not the dumbest ones...they teach you some history in Pakistan,he appointed himself field marshal, he led the first coup...carried out Gibraltar in his overconfidence and got soundly beaten back...how come you name him as a great when he lost his only battle??

He successfuly defended Pakistan when India invaded Lahore and Sialkot in 1965. When Indian trops invaded Lahore and Sialkot in 1965 he beat them and saved Pakistan from Indian aggression. It was India who lost the Battle of Lahore.
Battle of Lahore - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Also he gave us Islamabad, one of the greatest cities of South Asia.
Islamabad - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[satishkumarcsc]

Why isnt Viktor Zhukov's name not mentioned here?...Why isnt Adolf Hitler considered a great strategist himself? I dont see George Patton's name? King Arthur is not mentioned if there are divine generals, Joan of Arc is not named here. Fiedel Castro is also not mentioned. Mao is also a great strategist. Lord Nelson's name is not here.

 

[salahuldin786]

1.muhammed p.b.u.h

2.khaild bin waleed- sword of allah

3.tariq bin ziyad -conquered spain

4.muhammed bin qasim- conquered sindh

5. muhammed ghari -conquered india

6. mehmet 2 - conquered Constantinople

7. salahudin yusuf ayyubi - defender of Jerusalem

and they are many more muslim general's who have fought with faith and skill.

 

[waraich66]

1.muhammed p.b.u.h

2.khaild bin waleed- sword of allah

3.tariq bin ziyad -conquered spain

4.muhammed bin qasim- conquered sindh

5. muhammed ghari -conquered india

6. mehmet 2 - conquered Constantinople

7. salahudin yusuf ayyubi - defender of Jerusalem

and they are many more muslim general's who have fought with faith and skill.

Well said,

No one could reach the level of wisdom of Muhammad PBUH and Shabah RA and other Prophets and Wali Allah kutab Abdal Gaus

 

[Kamakazi 69]

1. Khalid bin Waleed (His deeds speak for themselves)

2. General George S. Patton ( For his audacious nature, his daring tactics and his strategy of attack, attack and then some more attack)

3. Field Marshall Erwin Rommell (did I spell that right?).

 

[garibnawaz]

Field Marshal Sam Maneckshaw.

Period.

GB

---------- Post added at 06:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:46 PM ----------

1. Mahatuma Ganduji

Check the spelling. Hope you are not doing it intentionally to insult the man.

GB

 

[bandit]

He successfuly defended Pakistan when India invaded Lahore and Sialkot in 1965. When Indian trops invaded Lahore and Sialkot in 1965 he beat them and saved Pakistan from Indian aggression. It was India who lost the Battle of Lahore.
Battle of Lahore - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Also he gave us Islamabad, one of the greatest cities of South Asia.
Islamabad - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

India Invaded in reply to Ayubs imbecilic plan to invade Kashmir...Theres a thread running on 1965...please read it to decide if you even won

 

[SQ8]

I believe Ayub Khan belongs in the greatest disasters of all time thread..

 

[Musalman]

He successfuly defended Pakistan when India invaded Lahore and Sialkot in 1965. When Indian trops invaded Lahore and Sialkot in 1965 he beat them and saved Pakistan from Indian aggression. It was India who lost the Battle of Lahore.
Battle of Lahore - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Also he gave us Islamabad, one of the greatest cities of South Asia.
Islamabad - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

No yaar he was really stupid to let Pakistani border at Sialkot, Lahore and Kasur left open for any Indian attack

 

[Musalman]

Field Marshal Sam Maneckshaw.

Period.

GB

---------- Post added at 06:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:46 PM ----------



Check the spelling. Hope you are not doing it intentionally to insult the man.

GB

He won you guys a war but had it not the political wits of Indra Gandhi you would not have been successful. Unfortunately we can not find a single good general in this part of the world Pakistan and India.