What's new

The CAPTURE OF TIGER HILL on July 4 th was a turning point :By Gen V. P. Malik( retd.)

Stephen Cohen

BANNED
Joined
Nov 21, 2014
Messages
8,456
Reaction score
-37
Country
India
Location
India
That July 4th

Gen V.P. Malik (retd)
The capture of Tiger Hill was a turning point

2016_7$largeimg03_Sunday_2016_223633632.jpg



Tiger Hill regained: Though picturesque, dominating and difficult, Tiger Hill is a war symbol to every Indian

Seventeen years ago, on July 4-5, 1999, the Indian army fought and won a magnificent battle victory during the Kargil war. There were two turning points in the Kargil war: the capture of Tololing which started the 'turn in the tide' and the back-to-back capture of Tiger Hill and Point 4875. Although Point 4875 was tactically more important, it was the capture of Tiger Hill which caused a physical and psychological blow to Pakistan and the 'end in sight' for us. Tiger Hill is 5,062-metre-high with sharp conical features and stands majestically among the mountaintops a few kilometres north of Dras. One cannot miss it, or help admire it, as one drives along National Highway 1A (NH 1A) from Zojila to Kargil. During the Kargil war, it was a delight for photojournalists as it provided some of the best pictures of that war.



From Tiger Hill, the enemy (one company of Pak 12 Northern Light Infantry) had a clear view of NH 1A from Dras to Bhimbat, and the road leading to Marpola on the Line of Control (LoC). They could effectively interdict vehicular movement on these roads with observed artillery fire. We were clear that unless Tiger Hill and Point 4875 (located 2 km to its South-West) were secured, movement along NH 1A will never be safe. Although Point 4875 was closer and dominated a larger stretch of NH 1A, Tiger Hill occupied by the enemy was more difficult to climb and assault.


In the second week of May, 1999, 8 Sikh moving from Udhampur to the Kashmir valley was diverted to Dras. On arrival, the Brigade Commander launched the unit into battle without acclimatisation and snow clothing to clear Tiger Hill. The unit suffered heavy casualties in its attempt to get close to the objective. It was then ordered to occupy dominating heights in the vicinity in the area called 'Parion ka Talab'. No further attempts were made to capture Tiger Hill for the next six weeks till we were able to clear the approaches and fully ready for it.


On June 27, 1999, I visited HQ 8 Mtn Div and 56 Mtn Bde at Dras. That evening, 2 Raj Rif was preparing to attack Three Pimples, another very difficult feature west of Tololing. After GOC, 8 Mtn Div, Maj Gen Mohinder Puri briefed me on the ground situation, I asked him about his next objective. He told me that after a few days, 192 Mtn Bde will attack Tiger Hill and Point 4875.


The attack on Tiger Hill was to precede the attack on Point 4857 by a day so that enemy attention would be diverted from the latter more strongly held objective. That I thought was a sound decision. Tiger Hill extends about 2,200 metres from west to east and about 1,000 metres north to south. The main extension is towards west on which there are two prominent protrusions. The first, approximately 500 metres west of Tiger Hill, had been named 'India Gate'. The second, another 300 metres to the west, was called 'Helmet'.


18 Grenadiers along with 8 Sikh, which were already in the area, were tasked to capture Tiger Hill on the night of July 3-4, 1999. They were provided a team of the High Altitude Warfare School, adequate artillery, engineer and other support. The Air Force could easily identify the prominent conical shape of Tiger Hill. It engaged the objective on July 2-3, 1999, and was able to score many bull's eyes in its missions.


The multi-directional infantry assault began at 1900 hours on July 3, 1999, with direct and indirect firing by artillery and MBRLs. 8 Sikh provided the firm base and engaged the enemy from 'obvious' approaches as part of a deception plan. 18 Grenadiers moved towards the objective from the south and north east. The weather assisted the battalions in achieving surprise. Lt. Balwan Singh led the Ghatak Platoon of 18 Grenadiers on the most difficult, north-eastern approach. His Platoon made use of ropes to reach the top at 4.30 hours and totally surprised the enemy which had already suffered due to heavy artillery shelling and air attacks. In the ensuring hand-to-hand fighting, the enemy lost 10-12 personnel. 18 Grenadiers suffered six fatal casualties. Grenadier Yogendar Singh Yadav, who was in the lead on the rope and wounded badly, earned India's highest gallantry award of Param Vir Chakra. The Ghatak Platoon with some reinforcements firmed in on the Tiger Hill top but came under enemy fire from the Western Spur. Brig Bajwa, Commander 192 Mtn Bde, quickly moved a company of 8 Sikh to occupy India Gate and Helmet. It was reinforced by another company of 18 Grenadiers. On the morning of July 5, the enemy launched a fierce counter-attack led by two officers. One, Capt Kamal Sher fought gallantly and was killed. Later, he was awarded Pakistan's highest gallantry award when we returned his body to Pakistan.


In New Delhi, I remained anxious all night till Lt. Gen Krishan Pal, GOC 15 Corps, rang up at 0600 hours on July 4, 1999, to inform me that 18 Grenadiers had reached the Tiger Hill top and heavy fighting was going on. After consulting him and the Director General Military Operations, we decided to wait for confirmation from Maj Gen Puri. At 0730 hours, Puri spoke to me and confirmed that the enemy would not be able to dislodge 18 Grenadiers from the Tiger Hill top. By then the Defence Minister was on his way to Amritsar. When he landed at Amritsar airport, I gave him this exciting news. I also informed the Prime Minister, who was to address a public meeting in Haryana at 10 am.


July 4, 1999, was an important date. Despite heavy commitments of Independence Day, President Clinton had agreed to meet Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif of Pakistan, who had conveyed desperation in wanting to meet. The meeting was to take place in the evening --early morning of 5th July in India. We made sure that the whole world got to know about the capture of Tiger Hill and thus, the likely outcome of the Kargil war.


That was a hard psychological blow for the Pakistan army. Initially, it tried to deny the existence of Tiger Hill and labelled the entire operations as a figment of the imagination. But with Indian media beaming live war pictures into drawing rooms, that kind of fooling was no longer possible. The Indian victory made Pakistanis realise the writing on the wall. In India, there was a wave of jubilation and relief in the mood of the people!


— The writer is a former Chief of the Army Staff

http://www.tribuneindia.com/news/comment/that-july-4th/260608.html
 
Last edited:
. .
nothing militarily was a turning point, diplomatic pressure from US led Pakistan to withdraw from various posts..

Pakistan still occupy point 5353 (the highest post in the Kargil region..)

http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/near-tiger-hill-point-5353-still-pakoccupied/488505/

Name some of the post you vacated so motto

You have been kicked out from there
Just like siachin

Point 5353 never a part of Indian post

It's already surrounded by 3 sides by India any misadventure will result bad for PA it has no relevance in actual war
 
.
Name some of the post you vacated so motto

You have been kicked out from there
Just like siachin

Point 5353 never a part of Indian post

It's already surrounded by 3 sides by India any misadventure will result bad for PA it has no relevance in actual war

from Wikipedia article of Kargil war..

By the end of the war, Pakistan had to withdraw under international pressure and due to pressure from continued fighting at battle front and left India in control of all territory south and east of the Line of Control, as was established in July 1972 as per the Simla Agreement.[87]

Following the Washington accord of July 4, 1999, when Sharif agreed to withdraw Pakistani troops, most of the fighting came to a gradual halt, but some Pakistani forces remained in positions on the Indian side of the LOC. In addition, the United Jihad Council (an umbrella for extremist groups) rejected Pakistan's plan for a climb-down, instead deciding to fight on.[86]

if there was no international pressure you would still be trying to liberate those posts which u got back in Khairaat (Charity) from Pakistan..

Point 5353 never a part of Indian post

From the article..

While the point is clearly on the Indian side of the LoC, it remains in Pakistani control which has fortified it with reinforced bunkers and has even built a special road nearby to carry up supplies for soldier

http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/near-tiger-hill-point-5353-still-pakoccupied/488505/
 
.
from Wikipedia article of Kargil war..

By the end of the war, Pakistan had to withdraw under international pressure and due to pressure from continued fighting at battle front and left India in control of all territory south and east of the Line of Control, as was established in July 1972 as per the Simla Agreement.[87]

Following the Washington accord of July 4, 1999, when Sharif agreed to withdraw Pakistani troops, most of the fighting came to a gradual halt, but some Pakistani forces remained in positions on the Indian side of the LOC. In addition, the United Jihad Council (an umbrella for extremist groups) rejected Pakistan's plan for a climb-down, instead deciding to fight on.[86]

if there was no international pressure you would still be trying to liberate those posts which u got back in Khairaat (Charity) from Pakistan..
Fact is there was no Indian post on 5353 even before the kargil war..it was one of those peaks, which lies on the LOC (literally), with much easier access from Pakistani side., but is also surrounded by Indian peaks on three sides.
Literacy fail.

Read the title again - 'Near' is a word that is meant to be read.

If you like Geography stuff, I recommend you to check the position of 5353 in Google Earth itself. It lies in the concave bend of the LOC, which means it was and is on Pakistan's side.
further Read
Fact and fiction on Point 5353

http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl1720/17200340.htm


In Kargil Pakistani troops occupied this feature in addition to some 140 more peaks.

After Indian offensive in Kargil gained momentum, you started loosing one peak after the other. Which is when, your then and the current prime minister realizing your imminent impending defeat rushed to US (uninvited on a fourth of July).

To try and salvage you from abject humiliation and impending military and diplomatic defeat., you tried to rope in Americans to pressurize India to solve Kashmir within limited time frame in exchange withdrawal from Kargil, but to n
o avail.

Your uncle furious over your impudence, your lies and the fact that you had brought the subcontinent on a verge of a nuclear war, told you take hike.

Which is when you withdrew..not only having loosing all your objectives in the war, loosing 700-800 soldiers(neutral estimates) but being exposed to the entire world as 'liars'.

By Kargil you did irreparable damage to your Kashmir effort.Which till then did receive some sympathy by international community ,thereafter was viewed as cross border terrorism by Pakistan.


Even your closest allies dithered to associate with you or come to your support.

Hence you lost more that 700 soldiers to capture one peak( which was not occupied by India in the first place) and suffer abject humiliation...Good Show!!

For Further Knowledge go through US Media Documentary
 
Last edited:
.
Fact is there was no Indian post on 5353 even before the kargil war..it was one of those peaks, which lies on the LOC (literally), with much easier access from Pakistani side., but is also surrounded by Indian peaks on three sides.
Literacy fail.

Stop this blabbering and accept that it was on Indian side of control line and now its under Pakistan control..

After Indian offensive in Kargil gained momentum, you started loosing one peak after the other. Which is when, your then and the current prime minister realizing your imminent impending defeat rushed to US (uninvited on a fourth of July).

It never gained momentum, India was losing more troops bcoz of height factor, yeah they free few posts, but mostly we left bcoz of international pressure..


Which is when you withdrew..not only having loosing all your objectives in the war, loosing 700-800 soldiers(neutral estimates) but being exposed to the entire world as 'liars'.

we occupy what we wanted, so militarily we achive our objective, Indian intelligence failed.. it was diplomatic defeat, as i said ur malnourished army would still trying to liberate if US would not pressure Pakistan to withdraw... Diplomatic failure on our part.. and we lose near 430 soldiers while India have to import coffin from US, bcoz cost were so high for India :unsure:.. we come in ur land, spank you, occupy point 5353, nothing we lost..:pleasantry:

To try and salvage you from abject humiliation and impending military and diplomatic defeat., you tried to rope in Americans to pressurize India to solve Kashmir within limited time frame in exchange withdrawal from Kargil, but to no avail.

Your uncle furious over your impudence, your lies and the fact that you had brought the subcontinent on a verge of a nuclear war, told you take hike.

Which is when you withdrew..not only having loosing all your objectives in the war, loosing 700-800 soldiers(neutral estimates) but being exposed to the entire world as 'liars'.

By Kargil you did irreparable damage to your Kashmir effort.Which till then did receive some sympathy by international community ,thereafter was viewed as cross border terrorism by Pakistan.


Even your closest allies dithered to associate with you or come to your support.

Hence you lost more that 700 soldiers to capture one peak( which was not occupied by India in the first place) and suffer abject humiliation...Good Show!!

Rants, every country do covert actions.. but i agree we failed to keep it covert..

From the article..

While the point is clearly on the Indian side of the LoC, it remains in Pakistani control which has fortified it with reinforced bunkers and has even built a special road nearby to carry up supplies for soldier

http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/near-tiger-hill-point-5353-still-pakoccupied/488505/

Source: https://defence.pk/threads/the-capt...t-by-gen-v-p-malik-retd.437790/#ixzz4DQWrdT3h
 
.
we occupy what we wanted, so militarily we achive our objective, Indian intelligence failed.. it was diplomatic defeat, as i said ur malnourished army would still trying to liberate if US would not pressure Pakistan to withdraw... Diplomatic failure on our part.. and we lose near 430 soldiers while India have to import coffin from US, bcoz cost were so high for India :unsure:.. we come in ur land, spank you, occupy point 5353, nothing we lost..
Crying For nothing Usual for Pakistani fanboys

Point 5353 has no Impact as usually in any thing it it hard for you to Swallow It Surrounded by India from three Sides it has Null Strategic Impact as Tiger hill or other Peaks thats was in kargil sector

Read the Article from FRontline magzine Hindu in 2000
Fact and fiction on Point 5353
http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl1720/17200340.htm


You Captured more than 140 Peaks one by one you Kicked from all ,As for Casualties you guys not even accepted you Martyr's in First Place

Do you Know Captain Sher khan was awarded Nishan-e-Haider, Posthumous After India Army Described his valor its war book
you guys are so pathetic who Disowned bodies of their own Soldiers and there Heroic deeds in War



Pakistani Casualties Figures are Hided to cover Misleads of a fake Egoistic Gen Mushraff who Genocided Soldiers in his Personal Political Motives For which he face Court Marshal by Pakistan army

Gen. Shahid Aziz, who was Director General (Analysis) of ISI at the time of Kargil War exposes Pervez Musharraf's short-sighted strategy of Kargil War, how Pakistan lost badly, how it didn't even claim the bodies of its soldiers and also manipulative attitude


Pakistan confirmed that 453 soldiers were killed. The US Department of State had made an early, partial estimate of close to 700 fatalities. According to numbers stated by Nawaz Sharif there were over 4,000 fatalities.

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/965379/posts

Many Bodies of Pakistani Soldiers are Buried In Indian border No Wonder Pakistan release it Casualties after years of war in pre planned way through ISPR


 
Last edited:
.
Pakistanis have tradition of not accepting vanquish in discussions,, irrespective of reality and veracity the whole world knows. They will go on and on putting all sort of illogical arguments, except, accepting the bitter truth. They are good at twisting history and fooling their own people and forthcoming generation. Their text book taught they had clear victory in all wars against India, only in 1971, its just because they got betrayed by Bengali defectors otherwise they would have annihilated India from the map. Such type of psyche in Pakistani society have been created deliberately that they are breed of very very superior race and they cant be defeated.

Though, nobody talks if they are such a race of superior beings, then why this country is almost bankrupt in such a bad shape and their leaders rome round the world with begging bowl. Not accepting humiliated defeat of Kargil is just one such example.
 
. .
I do not know why Indians are complaining here.

I for one would love Pakistan's stance of wrestling away point 5353 from India as part of Kargil. I would actually love if Pakistan could add couple of additional peaks to the list as this gives perfect platform for any Indian plan to taken them back in future
 
. .
Pakistan came into indian territory like Theifs when all our force withdrew from the peaks due to adverse climate
A simple question , if Pakistan didnt have the guts and balls to withstand an International pressure , then why did u go for this misadventure .... like mother in law and wife , why did sherif & mushraff fought each other on this issue
 
.
India lost in the Kargil war, bitter pill you guys will have to swallow.

About time you stop reading propaganda materials in your text book and read independent sources. You are an insult to learned Pakistanis on this forum and a joker to Indians.

Once you educated yourself taking help from Pakistani veterans, do not stop there. Continue your quest for truth and you will get cured ( you will become a depressed lot though :-) )
 
.
Pakistan came into indian territory like Theifs when all our force withdrew from the peaks due to adverse climate
A simple question , if Pakistan didnt have the guts and balls to withstand an International pressure , then why did u go for this misadventure .... like mother in law and wife , why did sherif & mushraff fought each other on this issue

It is important to differentiate between PPP (Pakistan People) and MMM (Military, Mulla & Muslim League-Feudals)

PML is very much part of MMM. It's just that they play ignorant when caught red handed like in case of Kargil or Nuclear proliferations by AQK.

Nawaz was a protege and confidant of Zia-ul-Haq.

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was leftist and had started the nationalization of Industries (to de-feudalize) which directly impacted the steel industries owned by the Sharifs. This resulted in Sharifs joining hands with Military & Mullas to counter the popular politics of Bhuttos.

No wonder Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was executed by the Military while Benazir Bhutto was allegedly killed by the Intelligence agencies.

Both were hugely popular with the people at large due to their pro-people oriented policies but had lost the battles to the MMM brigade.

Indo-Pak relations have always been great under PPP governments (be it Indira-ZAB, Rajiv-Benazir or Zardari-MMS) while under MMM they always deteriorated for obvious reasons.
 
.
About time you stop reading propaganda materials in your text book and read independent sources. You are an insult to learned Pakistanis on this forum and a joker to Indians.

Once you educated yourself taking help from Pakistani veterans, do not stop there. Continue your quest for truth and you will get cured ( you will become a depressed lot though :-) )

I have asked people who actually fought in that war, none of them support the absurd claims you government has made. India suffered several times as many casualties as Pakistan did despite outnumbering Pakistan 6:1 and having complete air superiority as the PAF was not involved. The only way India could get Pakistan to exit Kargil was by getting the US to pressure Pakistan. Also, we still hold Point 5353.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom