What's new

The Battle of Hilli- A Narration by Pakistani Bde Commander

That remarks towards Bengalis in general are absolutely to the courtesy of Sheikh Mujib and Awami League policies & actions taken (I don’t want to go into the details) towards Pakistan and its ideology right after Independence from 1948 until 1971 when they finally got an absolute land slide victory in East Pakistan under their just “Bengali” cause & Idealogy. The ordinary West Pakistani didn’t saw any Pakistan and its ideology loving sign at that moment from any quarter in East Pakistan and that was too a hard fact of history.

The ideology of a separate Bengali nationality was created in 1948-52, during the Mother Language movement. Several other movements in 1963, 1969 strengthen it, and the most important part is that all of the movements were organised just because of the discrimination towards 'Bengalis'! So naturally there shouldn't be any Pakistan and its ideology loving sign at that moment from any quarter in East Pakistan!!

As far as the actions of Pakistani forces are concerned during these bloody 9 months, Ya..that should be investigated thoroughly along with the actions taken by Mukti bahini towards Biharis’, West Pakistanis in general as well.

Comparing between the killings of more than 3 million Bangladeshis by the PA and few thousand Beharis by the Mukti Bahini is really a matter of huge dumbness! If someone still try to put it forward as a lame excuse to their faults, than i must say that those killings against the beharis are fair enough since they also took part in those atrocities!
 
.
Comparing between the killings of more than 3 million Bangladeshis by the PA and few thousand Beharis by the Mukti Bahini is really a matter of huge dumbness! If someone still try to put it forward as a lame excuse to their faults, than i must say that those killings against the beharis are fair enough since they also took part in those atrocities!

Do you honestly believe that figure as true?
 
.
I am Happy he spoke the truth, Even speaking truth can solve our many problems
 
.
" On 15th and 16th December, when Bogra was surrounded from all sides, I was moving about in the battle area in my jeep, with the flag and stars uncovered, and announcing on the loud speaker, “We shall fight from the rooftops, the windows and in the streets but we shall not surrender.” Maj Gen (Retd) Tajammal Hussain Malik


" We shall fight in the sees and and oceans, we shall fight on the landing grounds, on the streets and beaches. Who wins if England looses ? We are not interested in the possibilities of defeat ! It does not exist "Churchill



@ We need these sort of motivated officers to fight with India otherwise we will be nowhere be it a Pakistani, Bangladeshi or Singhali.
 
.
BANGLA WAR
Leg end of Sylhet
By Mandira Nayar
Story Dated: Monday, November 28, 2011 16:0 hrs IST
Every war has its heroes. 1971 is no different.


Every war has its heroes. 1971 is no different. In the war that saw Captain Mullah go down with his ship, drinking his favourite whiskey, and Lance Naik Albert Ekka facing certain death to lob a grenade to save his men in the face of enemy fire, Major General Ian Cardozo, the second-in-command of the 4th Battalion of 5th Gurkha Rifles Frontier Force, cut off his own leg.
Cardozo's battalion, which had suffered many casualties, was sent for India's first heli-born mission into Sylhet to capture the airfield, the control tower and a bridge.
“I reached the airfield at 3 a.m.,'' Cardozo remembers. “The moon was setting. It was December and the rice had been cut. Choppers were ready to take off. But they had to wait for the first wave to come back. They needed to be briefed to know where the fire was coming from. The choppers were not armour-protected. So if any of the bullets had hit a fuel pipe it would have caught fire.”
Loaded on they landed in Sylhet. The seventh second-in-command for the battalion—all the others had died in bizarre incidents, making everyone believe that the position was cursed—Cardozo had luck against him. “The JCO told the commanding officer, 'We were very happy to have Cartosa sahib. They can never pronounce his name, but can we call him something else?' He asked them, 'What?' He suggested Wazir. I was called Wazir from then on. But the CO had a mental block. He asked me one day whether he could call me 2 IC, I said, 'fine.' The next day I stepped on to a mine and my leg blew up,'' he laughs.
A born storyteller, Cardozo narrates his battle tales with relish. Unlike most Army officers, who talk about operations in dry military terms, Cardozo brings it alive in vivid detail. “I met a JCO who I had known when I joined. He was very badly injured and was going to die. He didn't want to go alone so he begged me to stay. I was there till 3 a.m. and then I went off promising to return,'' he says.
When Cardozo returned, he could hear the Pakistani artillery. “When you hear the round leaving the gun and you count, you can hear where the shell is going to land. If you hear the whistle then you know you are safe. It will fly overhead. If you don't hear it, you know it is going to land on your head. I couldn't hear the whistle and it landed in the medical room bunker. The medicines were destroyed. So when I stepped on a mine on the last day, there were no instruments, no antibiotics, no morphine,'' says Cardozo.
This attack cost the brigade eight boys and Cardozo, then a major, his leg. Ask him whether he believes in the jinx now, he smiles and says, “No.” On December 15 the Pakistanis came with white flags to surrender. “We knew they were in strength and we were 486 only. They were a brigade and we were only half a battalion. They said, 'Please call your brigade commander, we want to surrender to him.'”
As they were only half a battalion, they couldn't fulfil this request. Terrified that they would be found out, they simulated a brigade defensive position. “We were running out of ammunition,'' he says. In heli-born operation, the idea is that the land link up has to take place in 48 hours. Otherwise the whole unit will be wiped out. “As it was only 48 hours, we thought less food and more ammunition. Each man had 100 rounds and instead of two grenades we had four. We had only one water bottle.”
So, they sent a message in Tamil asking the brigade commander, who was far away, to come immediately. “We told the Pakistanis that he couldn't accept the surrender that day because he didn't have the permission. The next day when he arrived in a chopper they [the Pakistanis] were shocked. But so were we. What we thought was a brigade was two brigades, four full colonels, 209 JCOs and officers. 7,000 troops surrendered to us. They couldn't believe it,'' he smiles.
However, soon after the mine explosion, the doctor was helpless. “He went to look for something, probably a kitchen knife,'' Cardozo says with a laugh. "I asked my batman, 'Where is my khukri?' He said, 'Here it is.' I told him, 'Cut it off.' He said, 'I can't do it.' So I said 'Okay' and cut it off.
His leg was buried in Sylhet. “So, I own land, one foot by one foot, there,'' he guffaws. Ask him how he could bear to do it, and he'll smile: “I think that I reached that level of pain that I don't think that it mattered. To tell you the truth I was very embarrassed. My leg was messed up and I didn't know what to do.”
It was the last day of the war, December 16, when Dhaka fell, and Cardozo couldn't be evacuated. “We had captured some Pakistanis and an ambulance. I was operated upon by a Major Mohammad Bashir. He did a very good job. I have never been able to thank him.”
 
.
It is nice that the Pakistani Commander came forward. Whatever attrocities were committed against our brothers, it is heartening that our folks atleast apologise.

It is also heartening that four Indian battalions including an armoured core, were unable to overrun one single battalion in the area.

not needed
 
.
If Sheikh Mujeeb and his ideology was so popular, why was he gunned down by his army??

Most accounts of brutality by PA were grossly exaggerated, read Sharmila Bose's book 'Dead Reckoning' which is banned in India.

Mujeeb was nothing but an Indian backed stooge. All in all it was a bad day for Pakistan.

Any link to prove that? , i doubt you have one .In fact ,news about this book even came on CNN IBN , it is being published by hachette India , being sold at Rs 495 .
'Dead Reckoning' tells the truth about 1971 War - Books - Book Reviews - ibnlive

You don't need to say that this book is banned in India just to encourage people to read it.
 
.
Do you honestly believe that figure as true?

Yes, the 3 million figure is absurd. It was fabricated in the Indian propaganda machines and was fed to the western Press, who had no entry to east Pakistan. Indians, now download these fabrications from western press and propagate so that east and west do not come to terms.

There were certainly killings, but the figure is below one lakh in total and not Bangalis only.
 
.
Yes, the 3 million figure is absurd. It was fabricated in the Indian propaganda machines and was fed to the western Press, who had no entry to east Pakistan. Indians, now download these fabrications from western press and propagate so that east and west do not come to terms.

There were certainly killings, but the figure is below one lakh in total and not Bangalis only.

The figure of 3 million might be a little absurd but it surely counts for at least 1 million.
 
.
if malik was the head of bengal war instead of that niazi scum, we would have not lost bangladesh, he would have also won the bengladeshi hearts by his good character
 
.
The figure of 3 million might be a little absurd but it surely counts for at least 1 million.

If one million where dead then there would have been another few millions without limb lurking around. Have you seen any one without limp due to 71 war around you?

It's a made up number and I hate when our bigot politicians use this number to gain sympathy. Anyone with common sense can not believe in this outrageous figure.

I agree with the EastWatch. The death figure must be less than 100k.
 
.
indians had deployed four infantry brigades i.e 202 Brigade, 66 Brigade, 165 Brigade and 340 Brigade, one armoured bridge i.e 3 Armoured Brigade, 471 Engineer Brigade and two artillery brigades augmented by 33 Corps Artillery plus 1 mukti brigade vs 1 Pakistani Brigade = BADAZZ PAK SOLDIERS! :tup:
 
.
indians had deployed four infantry brigades i.e 202 Brigade, 66 Brigade, 165 Brigade and 340 Brigade, one armoured bridge i.e 3 Armoured Brigade, 471 Engineer Brigade and two artillery brigades augmented by 33 Corps Artillery plus 1 mukti brigade vs 1 Pakistani Brigade = BADAZZ PAK SOLDIERS! :tup:

Still wondering why your army lost? :P
 
.
What after all Brig Tajjamal Hussain Malikhas contributed to the Battle of Hilli: His total Comd from 20 Nov 71 to 16 Dec 71: Forward viits: 07 Days , Back ward(16 Dic and Dacca): 07 Days : Hq 205 Bde 07 Days: )3 Days : He and the GOC ambushed at Pir Ganj: Giviny to en starred jeeps, marked maps and other SECRET documents: Visit to Units: 13 FF: 02 , 8 BR: 01 : 4 FF: 04(short flying visits): CAN ANY ONE TELL ME HIS CONTRIBUTION TO THE BATTLE OF HILLI: Then Captain Mian Muzaffar Gul 4 FF(peace and War Time Adjutant)
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom