Ratus Ratus
PROFESSIONAL
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2008
- Messages
- 806
- Reaction score
- 0
"Could someone try to explain then what the various bombing in Afghanistan on civilians in markets and villages are all about then..."
I would presume he was referring to the Pakistan Army. Mullah Omar has been known to discourage his followers (and others) from attacking Pakistan and the Pakistan Army. Its not necessarily because 'we're Muslim' but because it would constitute a prudent strategic decision. And from the PoV of these Afghan rebels, there are non-Muslim Coalition forces in Afghanistan and not in Pakistan thus the violence there is justified and the resulting collateral damage (AKA civilian deaths) can be excused whereas in Pakistan there would be no purpose to this violence (i.e. expelling non-Muslim soldiers). All this I'm stating from their PoV ofcourse. Also, as much as I dislike them, the Afghanistan Taliban are not the only force in Afghanistan whose operations cause civilian deaths and who continue to operate despite such deaths. And if I have to choose, I'd say that the Pakistani Taliban are the more violent, brutal, mindless and crazy of the two with stronger links to Al-Qaeda. If the US/GoA is talking to Mullah Omar, doesn't mean we should talk to Mehsud too, no way. His kind deserves only one thing...and that is what comes out of the muzzle of a barrel.
The quote I initially provied comes from the atricle in the very first post of this thread:
"Where as the Real Taliban of Afghanistan and their command has strictly forbidden to Attack Muslims and ordered to concentrate against occupation forces in Afghanistan)"
This is what I question with respect to that comment and your answer does not excuse collateral damage of this nature.
guardian.co.uk, Sunday 28 December 2008
Suicide car bomb in Afghanistan kills 14 primary school children | World news | guardian.co.uk
A suicide car bomb in Afghanistan today killed 14 primary school children in what officials said was a failed attempt to blow up a meeting of tribal elders.
The blast, in the country's eastern Khost province, also killed an Afghan army soldier and a security guard, and injured 58, including at least 40 civilians, the US army said.
Video footage of the bombing, taken from a security camera, shows a group of children, apparently returning from school, walking alongside a road that had a checkpoint guarding a district centre. A dark-coloured 4x4 vehicle is seen *snaking through the barriers placed on the approach to the checkpoint, before detonating just as it drew level with the children.
In most cases of suicide bombings in Afghanistan the collateral damage is far greater than the damage to the US/ISAF/ANA/AP forces per incident.
SOme have been directly aimed at civilians so I would totally discount ant comment such as the one in the article about the so called "good" Afghan Taliban in Pakistan. The reality is as hinted, Mullah Omar will not do anything in Pakistan because it is providing him with a "protected" state.
As for:
"If the US/GoA is talking to Mullah Omar, doesn't mean we should talk to Mehsud too, no way"
The US/GoA are not talking to Mullar Omar as he will not talk till the US and ISAF leave Afghanistan. No one, US or the ISAF forces are leaving Afghanistan that I know of.