What's new

Tainted past of Indian peacekeeping force

BATMAN

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Mar 31, 2007
Messages
29,895
Reaction score
-28
Country
Pakistan
Location
Switzerland
BBC reveals tainted past of Indian peacekeeping force

New Delhi: A BBC investigation has thrown some shocking allegations about the Indian Army peace-keepers.


The investigation claims that Indian Army peacekeepers in Congo traded in gold with militia responsible for the Rwandan genocide, sold UN rations to rebels for more gold and even bartered ammunition for ivory.


The BBC investigation also suggests that the UN is involved in a cover-up, not wanting to offend one of the largest troop contributors. There was predictable denial.


"The ethos and culture of this army does not permit the type of activity that is reported by the media," said the War College’s Ex-Commandant, Lt Gen (Retd) V K Kapur.


The Army, on its part, is finally admitting that some of its men in Congo, including an officer, did buy gold dust, which turned out to be spurious. However, it is still peddling their innocence, claiming concocted complaints were made after the Indians forced the rebels to return their money.


The Indian Army is still in denial but gold-diggers in the Army's olive-greens have dealt a telling blow to India's image as the world's preferred peacekeepers"


Aware of the damage done, the establishment says there will be no hand-holding.


“If it is contrary to the mandate, or if it is detrimental to the image of the nation, we will definitely act on this," asserted Minister of State for Defence, M M Pallam Raju.


After being seen as doing business with murderous militias and seeking to profit from strife and conflict, the damage has already been done.
 
.
Not just Indian's tainted past, here is the complete story.

UN troops 'armed DR Congo rebels'

The FNI militia is accused of carrying out massacres of villagers in DR Congo

The UN has covered up claims that its troops in Democratic Republic of Congo gave arms to militias and smuggled gold and ivory, the BBC has learned.

The allegations, based on confidential UN sources, involve Pakistani and Indian troops working as peacekeepers.

The UN investigated some of the claims in 2007, but said it could not substantiate claims of arms dealing.

UN insiders told the BBC's Panorama they had been prevented from pursuing their inquiries for political reasons.

Gold and ivory

The United Nations Mission in the Democratic Republic of Congo (Monuc) is the global body's largest, with 17,000 troops spread across the country.

It's true they did, give us arms. They said it was for the security of the country

'Kung-fu'
FNI leader


Meeting Kung Fu and Dragon
Spotlight on India and Pakistan
DR Congo: Key Facts

The BBC's Martin Plaut, who returned to DR Congo to follow up his initial investigation into the allegations, says they have managed to bring a measure of stability since they were first established by the UN in February 2000.

They have also helped disarm the warring factions, run democratic elections and assisted with reconstruction.

But an 18-month BBC investigation for Panorama has found evidence that:

- Pakistani peacekeepers in the eastern town of Mongbwalu were involved in the illegal trade in gold with the FNI militia, providing them with weapons to guard the perimeter of the mines

- Indian peacekeepers operating around the town of Goma had direct dealings with the militia responsible for the Rwandan genocide, now living in eastern DR Congo

- The Indians traded gold, bought drugs from the militias and flew a UN helicopter into the Virunga National Park, where they exchanged ammunition for ivory

The UN looked into the allegations concerning the Pakistani troops in 2007.

It concluded that one officer had been responsible for dealing in gold - allowing traders to use UN aircraft to fly into the town, putting them up at the UN base and taking them around the town.

But the UN decided that "in the absence of corroborative evidence" its investigators "could not substantiate the allegation" that Pakistani peacekeepers supplied weapons or ammunition to the militia.

It did, however, identify "an individual who seemed to have facilitated gold smuggling".

Ammunition boxes

But returning to eastern DR Congo, the BBC spoke to several residents of the mining town of Mongbwalu, who said they had seen the FNI re-armed.

One former militant told our correspondent he had witnessed seven boxes of ammunition being brought from the UN camp to re-supply the FNI during a critical fire-fight.

Two FNI leaders known as "Kung-fu" and "Dragon", who have been jailed in the capital, Kinshasa, have stated publicly that they received help from the UN.


Pakistani peacekeepers have helped train the army in DR Congo


The BBC managed to get into the maximum security jail and both confirmed this.

Kung Fu, whose real name is General Mateso Ninga, said: "Yes, it's true, they did give us arms. They said it was for the security of the country. So they said to us that we would help them take care of the zone."

The FNI has been described by Human Rights Watch as "some of the most murderous individuals that operate in eastern Congo".

The ethnic Lendu militia was involved in the bitter clashes with their Hema rivals in the Ituri district.

UN insiders close to the investigation told the BBC they had been prevented from pursuing their inquiries for political reasons.

Our correspondent says that in short, the Pakistanis, who are the largest troop contributors to the UN in the world, were too valuable to alienate.

Pakistan has said it has no means of influencing the UN and that there is no evidence that its troops were involved in an illegal gold trade or re-armed militia, describing the allegations as baseless.

The Indian Army told Panorama that an investigation by the UN watchdog had revealed that all but one of the allegations were based on hearsay or had no credible evidence.

'Interests'

The special representative of the UN Secretary-General in DR Congo, Alan Doss, told the BBC that any effort to re-arm militias "would be a great concern to us".



The UN's Alan Doss responds to the allegations
"After all, we've lost lives fighting these militias - let's not forget that," he said.

Mr Doss dismissed the allegations of the militia leaders who said they had received weapons from UN troops based in the country.

"Militia leaders are militia leaders. They always have their interests," he said. "All I can say is that this investigation didn't confirm that."

Our correspondent says these are not the only allegations to have been brought against peacekeepers in DR Congo.

In December 2006, then UN Secretary General Kofi Annan said Moroccan troops had been involved in widespread sexual abuse.

Panorama: Mission Impossible is on BBC One, 2030 BST on Monday 28 April 2008
 
.
Bat,

Forgot about the Pakistanis?

Maybe this will warm your heart that Pakistan has not been left behind and that it leads!!

The UN's own report, dated 2 July 2007, which it has never published, concludes that the Pakistani contingent in Mongbwalu did indeed trade in gold with a group of Indian traders based in East Africa.
Mongbwalu
Mongbwalu - could one man have organised $7m in gold trade from here

The UN goes on to hold just one Pakistani army officer responsible for what took place. It is hard to believe that one single officer, based in an isolated Congolese village, could organise a trade involving an estimated $7m in gold passing through four countries, but that was the UN's conclusion.

On the question of re-arming the FNI militia the UN report, which removed the names of those involved, was unequivocal: "In the absence of corroborative evidence, (the UN's Investigation Division) could not substantiate the allegation that (Pakistani peacekeepers) deployed to Mongbwalu had supplied weapons or ammunition" to FNI fighters.

BBC NEWS | South Asia | Congo spotlight on India and Pakistan

As they say, Look Before You Leap!! ;) :)
 
.
Salim,

Since when did this thread turn into Pak VS India? :P
 
.
Take Salim's post and post it in the Pakistani "Ground Forces" thread and that'll make him happy...there justice done! :P
 
.
Bat,

Forgot about the Pakistanis?

Maybe this will warm your heart that Pakistan has not been left behind and that it leads!!



As they say, Look Before You Leap!! ;) :)

This was a propaganda proven wrong but what I have posted is reality and investigations are going on as we speak.
It is also written that biased UN is involved in coverup.
I guess 'bankey moon' has employeed little bit too much Indians.
 
.
I guess 'bankey moon' has employeed little bit too much Indians.

You do realize that Pakistan has more troops than India in Congo.
 
.
While Pakistani and Indian troops are taking a black eye on this Gold smuggling issue, Congo is the first place where Pakistani troops under the UN flag and with Indian Army Aviation support had taken on the rebels and given them an *** kicking...which is something that UN normally does not do...many Pakistani soldiers made the ultimate sacrifice and this included some of the best in the Army (including our SF cadres).

Its unfortunate that for the acts of a few, the entire Army (or the two Armies here) is/are receiving flak. Maybe the positives and the heroism of the same troops should also be highlighted. Let me start:
U.N. troops destroy Rwandan rebel camps in Congo

By Marlene Rabaud
REUTERS

9:52 a.m. July 21, 2005

MIRANDA, Congo – U.N. peacekeepers and government soldiers destroyed a remote rebel base in eastern Congo in their latest operation to pressure Rwandan gunmen to lay down their guns and return home peacefully.
More than 1,000 Guatemalan special forces soldiers, Pakistani commandos and Congolese government troops were airlifted to a hill-top rebel headquarters, which they searched for weapons and then torched to the ground on Wednesday.

The raid was launched days after about 1,000 rebels had fled into the nearby forests. There were no reports of casualties.

'The general strategy is to put them under a lot of pressure to take them away from the population and to isolate them,' Gen. Ali Khan Shujaat, commander of the U.N. Pakistani forces in South Kivu, said as 100 huts were being torched in the rebel camp, 45 km (28 miles) west of the city of Bukavu.

'They will have to leave – we left them no options. We'll keep pushing them deep into the forests making heir lives more miserable,' he added, referring to the 10,000 rebels that are based in eastern Congo.

Rwandan Hutu rebels, known as the Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Rwanda (FDLR), have operated in the region since many took part in the 1994 genocide in Rwanda, during which 800,000 Tutsis and moderate Hutus were killed.

After a decade of preying on civilians and following massacres in eastern Congo this year, they are under increasing pressure to keep a March promise to disarm and go home.

Rwanda has invaded eastern Democratic Republic of Congo twice saying it wanted to neutralise the rebels, fuelling a conflict compounded by conflicts over power and resources.

Joseph Mutaboba, secretary-general of Rwanda's internal security ministry, welcomed the operation by the U.N. mission, known as MONUC.

'If indeed this is happening, then that's good news though it comes long overdue. The U.N must keep pressure on these genocide forces to make sure they put down their arms,' he said.

'We hope it is not another public relations story for MONUC but indeed a commitment that will eventually show results.'


NO MANDATE TO DISARM

The U.N. force does not have a mandate to disarm the rebels, but peacekeepers say Wednesday's operation is the latest in a series aimed at disrupting rebel control of farming areas, gold mines and extortion rackets used to maintain the FDLR.

So far, the FDLR have complied with U.N. ultimatums to vacate their camps, there have been no gun battles and the villagers have been happy to see peacekeepers, long accused of standing by while civilians bore the brunt of Congo's wars.

'They stole my clothes ... they even killed my father,' said Muendwa Kahegesha, a Congolese boy told U.N. peacekeepers, wearing his one remaining tattered T-shirt.

Peacekeepers and diplomats in Kinshasa are concerned that the Rwandan rebels may react to the U.N. and Congolese army by stepping up operations against them by targeting civilians.

Earlier this month 39 villagers were burned alive in an attack blamed on the Rwandan rebels.


http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/...ratic-raid.html


________________________________________
Congo's peacekeepers tackle rebels and red tape
08 Aug 2005 01:04:00 GMT

Source: Reuters

By David Lewis

KINSHASA, Aug 8 (Reuters) - Battle-hardened from hunting al Qaeda militants in the mountains at home, Pakistani commandos are finding that donning blue helmets to tackle rebels in the jungles of Congo can pose unexpected dilemmas.

Part of the most expensive U.N. peacekeeping operation ever, the Pakistanis are backed by Guatemalan special forces and attack helicopters but face challenges from red tape to a lack of logistical muscle and reliable intelligence.

Charged with tackling Rwandan rebels causing havoc in lawless eastern Congo and shoring up a peace agreement, they are again facing a foe who knows the terrain intimately and who is practised at killing.

"We have the experience of fighting against al Qaeda in our own country but this is another challenge," says a Pakistani peacekeeper who has taken part in crackdowns against militants in Pakistan's mountain passes and is now based in Congo's lush South Kivu province.

"In Pakistan, we had a lot of liberty to operate as we wanted and we had access to money, technology and intelligence. And the Western nations are interested in what is happening there, which helps," he said.

There are 2,700 Pakistani peacekeepers based in South Kivu, alongside Guatemalan commandos and Uruguayan troops, in an area where thousands of Rwandan gunmen continue to terrorise villagers two years after Congo's latest war ended.

Many of the gunmen fled to Congo after participating in the 1994 genocide in Rwanda. Kigali used the rebels' presence as justification for invading Democratic Republic of Congo twice during the 1990s, sparking two large-scale conflicts.

The rebels promised earlier this year to lay down their weapons but instead have stepped up attacks on civilians and, with the fledgling Congolese army still fragmented, the United Nations has been pressured into taking action.

U.N. troops have no mandate to disarm the rebels by force but they have launched a wave of operations, issuing deadlines to the rebels before destroying camps and scattering the gunmen into the bush.

For the soldiers, it is a slow, dangerous task -- illustrated by the killing of nine Bangladeshi peacekeepers in an ambush in February.

"Elsewhere peacekeepers can travel in armoured personnel carriers but in South Kivu we have to be dropped in by helicopters and walk in by foot for several hours. This is very dangerous as they (the rebels) know the terrain and have selected their positions intelligently," the peacekeeper said.

Pakistanis participated in an operation in which an estimated 50 people were killed at a militia base in March with a new get-tough approach that won praise in some quarters but angered many Congolese, who saw the attack as misplaced revenge.

The dilemma did not end there. Rwandan rebels have killed dozens of civilians since then in attacks that survivors have described as shows of force to counter growing pressure by U.N. troops.

BATTLING THE BUREAUCRATS

Peacekeepers are supposed to be conducting joint operations with the Congolese Army. However, regional analysts question whether the army's leaders are really prepared to take on the Rwandan gunmen, with whom they fought against separate Congolese rebels backed by Rwanda during an invasion in 1998.

"We are two forces and we should be coordinating our actions. But we have seen that army units have been collaborating with the rebels. A number of commanders are in business with them," Major-General Patrick Cammaert, the head of the U.N.'s Eastern Division, told Reuters.

Accused of not doing enough to protect civilians, particularly in the northeastern town of Bunia in 2003 when hundreds of people were massacred, peacekeepers are finding their more robust approach is getting caught up in red tape.

Soldiers and U.N. administrators have clashed on issues such as whether helicopters could be flown at night, or whether local interpreters and Congolese soldiers are insured to travel in helicopters on supposedly joint operations.

"Are the rules and the regulations ready to support the mandate that we are trying to fulfil?" asks the cigar-smoking general. "Can they keep up with the tempo of the operations that we are carrying out? In order to keep the peace, sometimes we have to enforce it."

The United Nations says the operations are moving the gunmen away from civilians on whom they have preyed for years, but the complexities of eastern Congo could yet pose problems.

With national army integration faltering -- and the 3,000 U.N.-trained government soldiers in South Kivu lacking pay, uniforms and logistics -- some analysts fear that the peacekeepers' efforts may push the rebels into more attacks on civilians, rather than towards disarmament.


http://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/LEW946957.htm

Here is another one:

SOUTH AFRICA

Wounded soldier tells of fierce DRC firefight

He managed to drag severely injured comrade to safety after explosion
March 4, 2005

By Graeme Hosken and Sapa

A Pakistani special forces operator is fighting for his life in a Pretoria hospital after an anti-tank rocket exploded in front of him in the Democratic Republic of Congo.

Ihtibhar Khan, who is currently in the Pretoria Eye Institute, was critically injured during an attack by UN peacekeepers on a militia base in the DRC's Ituri district, in which South African troops were also involved.

Doctors have removed both his eyes and are treating him for severe burns to his face, neck, head and chest.

Khan and fellow Pakistani soldier Gulzar Ahmed (27), who are peacekeepers with the UN mission in the DRC, known as Monuc, were airlifted from a Ugandan hospital on board a mercy flight to South Africa on Wednesday after a gunfight in which at least 50 Congolese militiamen are believed to have been killed by UN peacekeepers.

Khan sustained third-degree burns to more than 70% of his body, while Ahmed's right eardrum burst and an eye was injured in the explosion.


The two were part of a Monuc mission to hunt down the militiamen responsible for the killing of nine Bangladeshi peacekeepers last Friday.

The Bangladeshi troops, several of whom were executed after being taken prisoner, were ambushed while on patrol in the DRC's north-eastern region of Ituri.

Speaking from his bed in 1 Military Hospital in Thaba-Tshwane, Ahmed, a member of the 21 Punjab Regiment, said they had been involved in a three-hour fire fight with more than 400 militia troops.

"The militia were taken by surprise when we were dropped into their base by helicopter, but they were able to put up a fierce fight with anti-tank rockets, RPGs, heavy machineguns and missiles," he said.

Ahmed, who is to be discharged from hospital next week, said they had been in the process of withdrawing to a new position when some of the militiamen ambushed them with anti-tank rockets.

"As Khan and I jumped out of our armoured vehicle, the Indian helicopters attacked, firing more than 20 rockets before one of the rebels' rockets exploded in front of us, setting Khan alight," he said.


Injured, but still conscious, Ahmed dragged Khan to safety, using his body to put out the flames, before administering medical attention.

Asked what the explosion felt like, Ahmed said everything had gone dead quiet.

"I remember lying on my back thinking how peaceful everything was. It was strange because I knew I had been hit, but I was not panicking."

"Everything seemed to happen so smoothly. I grabbed Khan and dragged him backwards, like we were taught, and did everything to help him, holding him down and talking to him to stop him panicking," he said.

A helicopter airlifted the two to a Uganda hospital, from where they were flown to South Africa.

Brigadier Jehanzeb Raja, defence adviser for the Pakistani High Commission in Pretoria, said Khan was still in a critical condition. He said it would take more than three months before Khan would be able to fly back to Pakistan.

Raja added that, once fully recovered, Ahmed would rejoin his battalion in the DRC.

Meanwhile the South African Defence Department said yesterday that South African troops had played just a small role in the attack on the militia camp.

Two platoons of South African infantry were initially in reserve with some Nepalese troops, while two companies of Pakistani troops attacked the camp.

"At 10.30am (on Tuesday) the Monuc force drew fire from the militia and returned fire. The South African reserves and a Mil Mi25 attack helicopter were called in to reinforce the Pakistani forces," SANDF spokesperson Colonel John Rolt said in a statement.

"No South African soldiers were injured," Rolt added.

Monuc chief of staff General Collot d'Escury said yesterday the attack was a "proportionate" reaction to the killing of the nine Bangladeshi soldiers.

Monuc has denied rebel claims that troops killed several civilians during the hard-hitting strike against the militias.
 
.
Salim,

Since when did this thread turn into Pak VS India? :P

It is not.

But the purer than driven snow attitude of Bat, required a little reminder!

I can post many more of Pakistani misdemeanours, but I don't since it is a waste of time.

I am sure the Pakistan govt is competent to handle the issues as the Indian govt is.

What the Indian officer does is disgraceful and he shall face the consequences as would a Pakistani if he had done the same thing.

But Batman oozing with glee from all orifice required him to be reminded of taking stock!

I am a soldier and I am proud of my fraternity, irrespective of nationality. Any misdemeanour by any soldier of any nation violates our code of conduct of this fraternity. It shames me and I do not accept the same.

If Indian soldiers are at fault I expect their govt to take the most stringent action. Likewise for Pakistan. Likewise for Russia, Likewise for China or the US or even Burkina Faso!!
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom