raptor22
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Dec 8, 2011
- Messages
- 7,064
- Reaction score
- 9
- Country
- Location
Then how did they come to power?
and what about hazrat ali (ra) ?.
how did he come to lead?
Divine decree!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!may be
Go read by yourself ... if even there were elected they were caliphs of People not Khlafata-Allah ... Khalphata-Allah must be chosen by Allah not by people .. as Rasoul-Allah were chosen by Allah .... as all prophets and all sucossors were ... as the last one is chosen too ....
By the way Abubakr caliphate came through "Saghife" ... when Bani Hashem were preparing for Prophet (pbuh) funeral they gathered in Saghife and neglected their prophet (pbuh) funeral ... while men like Imam Ali(As) , Abuzar , Salman, Balal, Ibn Abbas and many others were not present in Saghife ....
Second one was directly chosen by the first one.
The last one was chosen through a committee set by second caliph ... and one with veto ... Imam Ali (as) refused to follow the Sunna of two previous caliphs and insisted on Book of God and sunna of prophet (pbuh) something that Uthman accepted (Sunna of two previous caliphs) and became caliph ...
Imam Ali (as) were chosen by Allah .. no doubt in that ... but people chose him too go and read it by yourself how people forced him to accept the caliphate and he was rejecting ...
Imam Ali (as) was born in Kabba ... what about your caliphs?
Last edited: