Support builds for ailing Pakistani Christian facing death for drinking from Muslim water cup

[C130]

you break the law you gotta pay the price.

 

[Shot-Caller]

Read my post again i said C.M,president,Chief justice etc.

Weak argument. They're part of the system and thats what matters.

 

[انگریز]

Typical Fox news commedy

Typical Fox news commedy

 

[saurav]

Well.. Pakistan.. Another day.. Another minority person killed.. No big deal..

 

[Sheikh Rauf]

Surprisingly how we getting articals which is against islam, Pakistan and Pak army if nothing els they come up with then ethnics..
We sud critize all kind of this nonsence which is doing nothing but trying to devide our nation.
Insteat of helping nation or nation building like how we sud eliminate cruption and crupt people from Pak, they are just comming with negativity.
This stupidity sud stop.

Well.. Pakistan.. Another day.. Another minority person killed.. No big deal..

U sud concentrate whats happening in india how they are killing Kashimiries muslims in indian occupied kashmir people in Assam and every now and then killing christians sikhs and muslims all over india...
We cud say same thing but i guess Pakistani just dont go to indian forum and bash like how indians comming to Pakistani forum and showing their grudge against Pakistan...

 

[Djinn]

you break the law you gotta pay the price.

There's no such law. This story is clearly fabricated with a malignant agenda to show Pakistan in bad light.

 

[Azad-Kashmiri]

A Pakistani Christian woman facing death for drinking water out of the same vessel used by her Muslim co-workers is in such poor health her supporters fear she won't make it to her date with the executioner.

Sorry, I don't,...I can't believe this story! It seems like more anti-Muslim propaganda. On a positive side, from their complaining, I've learned there are Christians and Hindus in our country. The Government needs to help them integrate into our way of life and at the same time, educate the masses not to fear them and treat them with respect and dignity as per Islamic dictates.

 

[TankMan]

This water cup/well story is very, very unlikely to be true. It is most likely that they had a fight over something material and some people decided to use the law as a weapon. Fabrications like this water cup story do more damage to Aasia's case than they do good.

 

[Ghareeb_Da_Baal]

weird story!
Our christian maid's kids used to sit and play on our prayer rug that was used 5 times a day for salah and no one had issue with that!

 

[TankMan]

weird story!
Our christian maid's kids used to sit and play on our prayer rug that was used 5 times a day for salah and no one had issue with that!

My school's headmistress was Christian (and this was quite a while ago). Never had any problems either.

I suppose it all boils down to what type of people they live among. Clearly, Aasia was unlucky to be surrounded by a bunch of intolerant and violent people. Or she was unlucky to have encountered someone so malicious that they'd try to get her killed over a petty dispute.

The Blasphemy Law needs to be changed massively. It's too easy to abuse the way it is now. It's not even Islamic. There is no Blasphemy Law in Islam.

 

[Faiez]

There's no such law. This story is clearly fabricated with a malignant agenda to show Pakistan in bad light.

Sorry, I don't,...I can't believe this story! It seems like more anti-Muslim propaganda. On a positive side, from their complaining, I've learned there are Christians and Hindus in our country. The Government needs to help them integrate into our way of life and at the same time, educate the masses not to fear them and treat them with respect and dignity as per Islamic dictates.

I've been following this story for several years.....It's not a fake story or anything...Stuff like this regularly happens in rural areas. Infact, similar backward stuff even manages to get into the cities...Just last year or so there was a woman who was stoned to death IN FRONT OF LAHORE HIGH COURT by her own relatives simply for marrying the person she wanted to marry (which the family didn't approve). And these were muslims.

Pakistan doesn't need fabricated stories to look bad, it's already in a pretty bad shape. Step out of DHA/bahria for a while, Pakistan is alot bigger than that...

This water cup/well story is very, very unlikely to be true. It is most likely that they had a fight over something material and some people decided to use the law as a weapon. Fabrications like this water cup story do more damage to Aasia's case than they do good.

Go to a pind and start talking to people, you'll find out what these people are........I don't think anything in this story is fabricated. Also, I think she most likely did end up saying some offensive words as well after being provoked.

And this thing where you don't eat/drink in plates/cups that have been used by non-muslims, that also happens in rural areas. The thing is that they are simply ILLITERATE, 100% total JAHIL people. They do such backwards things....It happens.

 

[TankMan]

Go to a pind and start talking to people, you'll find out what these people are........I don't think anything in this story is fabricated. Also, I think she most likely did end up saying some offensive words as well after being provoked.

And this thing where you don't eat/drink in plates/cups that have been used by non-muslims, that also happens in rural areas. The thing is that they are simply ILLITERATE, 100% total JAHIL people. They do such backwards things....It happens.

I've been to a Pind, I actually originate from one. Mine might not have been the most intolerant of Pinds, but I've seen enough of the totally jahil people you're describing. Still, drinking from the same cup or well would not have been the only reason for this extreme of a reaction. Like you said, it is most probable that she did respond with offensive language.

The entire story is not fabricated, that's for sure, but this part about ''drinking from Muslim cup'' almost certainly is.

 

[Faiez]

I've been to a Pind, I actually originate from one. Mine might not have been the most intolerant of Pinds, but I've seen enough of the totally jahil people you're describing. Still, drinking from the same cup or well would not have been the only reason for this extreme of a reaction. Like you said, it is most probable that she did respond with offensive language.

The entire story is not fabricated, that's for sure, but this part about ''drinking from Muslim cup'' almost certainly is.

I don't think so....

the story is that she was spotted by some muslims jahils drinking from where she shouldn't have been and they most likely said something to her (probably tried to stop her) and naturally she would have felt so bad after that it's only reasonable if she says something blasphemous...I mean everything has a limit. You are treating someone as if they're filth and as if anything they touch becomes filth as well...She probably couldn't take it anymore and said something offensive and that's what lead to the rest of it, sexual abuse etc......and obviously you know the local imaams are also nuts, they must have played a role in it too....

It's all too sad what happens in rural areas in low income countries like our's....all due to illiteracy.

 

[TankMan]

I don't think so....

the story is that she was spotted by some muslims jahils drinking from where she shouldn't have been and they most likely said something to her (probably tried to stop her) and naturally she would have felt so bad after that it's only reasonable if she says something blasphemous...I mean everything has a limit. You are treating someone as if they're filth and as if anything they touch becomes filth as well...She probably couldn't take it anymore and said something offensive and that's what lead to the rest of it, sexual abuse etc......and obviously you know the local imaams are also nuts, they must have played a role in it too....

It's all too sad what happens in rural areas in low income countries like our's....all due to illiteracy.

If she responded by saying offensive things, it's simply a matter of responsible reporting to mention it instead of saying she's facing death for ''drinking from a Muslim cup''. The dispute may have been started by that, but at the end of the day it was the dispute that led to this and not the drinking.

This entire concept of 'untouchable' is painfully horrible. Just like the Blasphemy Law, it goes completely against the religion of Islam, yet is believed by too many illiterates.

Local Imams are a big, big problem. It pains me to think of the good they could be doing if only they were decent human beings. They have the influence to improve society tenfold, yet they use it to further add to the degeneration and depravity.

 

[Azad-Kashmiri]

Pakistan doesn't need fabricated stories to look bad, it's already in a pretty bad shape. Step out of DHA/bahria for a while, Pakistan is alot bigger than that...

If the story is true then it's shameful! On another matter, I'm from Mirpur, F-3 sector, from a humble background. I don't mingle with Rupyal and Nafees restaurant eaters.