Story about the event in Chinese social network and Chinese casualities

[52051]

There are several versions of stories around in China's internet, current this version is confirmed sidely by some employee in Chengdu hospitial:

It is quite ironic, it seems the whole event start as a mistake of reading satellite picture by unprofessional India military intelligence:

(1)The Chinese side ask constructors from ZhongTie corp. to build some small structure (dam?) at the upstream of the river.

(2)The ZhongTie constructors utilize the river as a water source, and due to the work the river turn muddy.

(3)The India satellite reveal the muddy water at the downstream of the river, believe that it is the Chinese who want to cut-down the river.

(4) The first group of Indians, lead by the col, hit the construction workers at the site, seriously injuried 2 of them, the rest just call the PLA.

(5) The fight begins, the PLA beat several indians, and the Indians left.

(6) At the same night, the Indians, lead by the Col, try to ambush the same building site, but the PLA has already anticipated their intention, and counter-ambushed them, they take out their col first, and the rest just run for their lives, that's where the majority of causalities of India take.

As for the total casualties on the Chinese side, there are two seriously injured workers from constructor company, one is back-injury, the other is head injury, they are all treated in Chengdu Hospital China by air lift.

There are also 3-5 minor injuries, some are treated in the local field hositpial, don't know how many of them are PLAs, but most could just be the workers from the construction company, ZHongTie Group.

 

[W.11]

hard to believe this story

while on one hand 20 army personnel of india dead and not one single PLA personell even injured, the injured are only construction workers?

why is china hiding the story?

sources in china have already admtted there have been casualties of chinese soldiers.

regards

 

[lonelyman]

hard to believe this story

while on one hand 20 army personnel of india dead and not one single PLA personell even injured, the injured are only construction workers?

why is china hiding the story?

sources in china have already admtted there have been casualties of chinese soldiers.

regards

Yeah, simply we outnumber and outsmarted you

poor indians jawans fell to the river and frozen to death

 

[xuxu1457]

Well, the news from China is that the Indian soldiers secretly attacked the Chinese stronghold, but the Chinese soldiers had already ambushed in their stronghold, so they arrested the Indian soldiers.Chinese soldiers were injured, but not killed.Because China has established a high altitude medical system in the rear.
Because as long as they get timely treatment, soldiers who do not die immediately will not generally die.If it is not treated in time, it is likely to cause death in plateau and cold areas.

 

[DoTell]

hard to believe this story

while on one hand 20 army personnel of india dead and not one single PLA personell even injured, the injured are only construction workers?

why is china hiding the story?

sources in china have already admtted there have been casualties of chinese soldiers.

regards

Which one is harder to believe - that the Indian soldiers could not read satellite picture or mistook Jupiter as Chinese fighter jet? Stupider things can happen my friend

 

[W.11]

Yeah, simply we outnumber and outsmarted you

poor indians jawans fell to the river and frozen to death

chinese be not chinese but justice league.

regards

 

[sur]

This poster also posted about what possibly happened:
An india also tweeted that his dad is soldier & thought that the indian col may have mis-read the map!

Hello my dear friends,I am Chinese .
I am sad for the battle caused 20 Indian soldiers casualties.But PLA definitely did not use that kind of coarse weapon with iron nails.Because that kind of crude weapons does not exist in PLA. It is even less likely to bring that low-level primitive weapon to a mountain area with an altitude of more than 5000 meters.The news I got was that Chinese soldiers used engineer shovel in battle，like this:
View attachment 642767
The fighting took place in a Chinese camp. An Indian colonel led the army across the control line of the Chinese army by 2 kilometers at night to drive away the Chinese army. But Chinese sentinels and drones discovered them first. The quarrel continued deep night, later the two sides began to fight. Three Indian soldiers were killed at the scene, the other Indian soldiers began to run away, PLA chased them behind, and many people fell into the valley and river in the chaos.
The initiator of the incident was the frontline officers and soldiers of the Indian army, and the Indian military senior officials did not issue an order. Similar things have happened frequently in the near future, so the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs told India to manage their frontline troops.
Few people care about India in China, because more important things require us to expend energy to deal with it, such as the United States, Taiwan and Hong Kong. The reason why we care about LAC is that we are worried that India will have to get more land and want more land. I think you have a deep understanding of this.
Finally, I hope that all countries can get along with each other and trust each other, such as the following video:

There are several versions of stories around in China's internet, current this version is confirmed sidely by some employee in Chengdu hospitial:

It is quite ironic, it seems the whole event start as a mistake of reading satellite picture by unprofessional India military intelligence:

(1)The Chinese side ask constructors from ZhongTie corp. to build some small structure (dam?) at the upstream of the river.

(2)The ZhongTie constructors utilize the river as a water source, and due to the work the river turn muddy.

(3)The India satellite reveal the muddy water at the downstream of the river, believe that it is the Chinese who want to cut-down the river.

(4) The first group of Indians, lead by the col, hit the construction workers at the site, seriously injuried 2 of them, the rest just call the PLA.

(5) The fight begins, the PLA beat several indians, and the Indians left.

(6) At the same night, the Indians, lead by the Col, try to ambush the same building site, but the PLA has already anticipated their intention, and counter-ambushed them, they take out their col first, and the rest just run for their lives, that's where the majority of causalities of India take.

As for the total casualties on the Chinese side, there are two seriously injured workers from constructor company, one is back-injury, the other is head injury, they are all treated in Chengdu Hospital China by air lift.

There are also 3-5 minor injuries, some are treated in the local field hositpial, don't know how many of them are PLAs, but most could just be the workers from the construction company, ZHongTie Group.

 

[52051]

hard to believe this story

while on one hand 20 army personnel of india dead and not one single PLA personell even injured, the injured are only construction workers?

why is china hiding the story?

sources in china have already admtted there have been casualties of chinese soldiers.

regards

casualties in China simply means injuries and/or death, it doesn't mean death.

And the official statement from Chinese west military district just merely said "cause casualties", not "cause casualites by both sides".

If you read the official Chinese statement, they ask the India to investigate and punish the planner behind scene of the event, when there are fatalities in China involved, the Chinese statement usually use "凶手" (murderer behind scence) instead of "肇事者".

 

[W.11]

Which one is harder to believe - that the Indian soldiers could not read satellite picture or mistook Jupiter as Chinese fighter jet? Stupider things can happen my friend

one can only speculate on china's version, when the entire story has been buried by the CCP.

regards

And the official statement from Chinese west military district just merely said "cause casualties", not "cause casualites by both sides".

officially there has been no story from china, only from the indian side, the story has been buried by the CCP.

regards

 

[52051]

one can only speculate on china's version, when the entire story has been buried by the CCP.

regards

CCP have never release details of any of the skirimishes in the past, but thanks to social network, at least we can have something to guess with.

 

[lonelyman]

CCP have never release details of any of the skirimishes in the past, but thanks to social network, at least we can have something to guess with.

To do modi a favor and save his face

 

[RuralHunter]

hard to believe this story

while on one hand 20 army personnel of india dead and not one single PLA personell even injured, the injured are only construction workers?

regards

Most of the Indian casualties is not caused by the fighting. The casualties mostly occurred when IA ran down off the hill at the night, at the meantime PLA and the works threw stones from upside. It's the night/height/cold killed those wounded IA members.

 

[DoTell]

To do modi a favor and save his face

Apparently our goodwill was misguided. We grossly underestimated the thickness of their skins and skulls

one can only speculate on china's version, when the entire story has been buried by the CCP.

Speculate at will sir. Bet you can reason a little bit too. How is it that the Indians managed to yank multiple barbed clubs from our soldiers' hands and carried them down the hills to take pictures, but failed to apprehend a single soldier from us? Did the Indians really choose to carry the clubs for photo over helping their dead/injured bodies?

 

[obj 705A]

hard to believe this story

while on one hand 20 army personnel of india dead and not one single PLA personell even injured, the injured are only construction workers?

why is china hiding the story?

sources in china have already admtted there have been casualties of chinese soldiers.

regards

Frankly you sound quite b*tt hurt that no Chinese were killed, hard to believe you say? It was 50-80 Indians vs 200-300 Chinese, the Chinese were armed with clubs with barbed wire , what do you think would happen if one single guy went up against 4 or 5 club weilding people? What happened there was not a battle , it was a one sided massacre, like a horror movie but without the exaggerated effects.

 

[AfrazulMandal]

hard to believe this story

while on one hand 20 army personnel of india dead and not one single PLA personell even injured, the injured are only construction workers?

why is china hiding the story?

sources in china have already admtted there have been casualties of chinese soldiers.

regards

It sounds plausible.

IA suffered 70 odd casualties including 23 at least dead and tens captured.

And the PLA suffered 0 casualties but a few construction crews got some cuts and bruises.

Apparently our goodwill was misguided. We grossly underestimated the thickness of their skins and skulls

Defeating the IA will be a piece of cake for the PLA. This is not the time to show goodwill to Sanghis but march to Delhi.