Stateless and helpless: The plight of ethnic Bengalis in Pakistan

[Maula Jatt]

Nah this option is Bengali specific and only for Bengalis and Biharis
Those who backwd us deserve citizenship those who doesn't need to be deported from land of Khan sena

?

 

[GHALIB]

So if a Algerian Muslim, a Nigerian Muslim, a Chinese Muslim, a Turkish Muslim, Bangladeshi Muslim, Indian Muslim lands in Islamabad Airport, declares he is a Muslim and wants Pak citisenship are you going to ask them if they supported Pakistan in 1971?

What about two nation theory ?
Pakistan was made for muslims who lived in british india , bangladesh was part of pakistan . Those Bangalis who were loyal to pakistan , had been living in pakistan have every right to live in pakistan.

 

[Zibago]

?

They used to call Pakistan army "khan sena" and Pakistanis as "shala punjabi"

 

[GHALIB]

They used to call Pakistan army "khan sena" and Pakistanis as "shala punjabi"

Oh , That was bad .

 

[Zibago]

Oh , That was bad .

Also they killed lakhs of pro Pak Bengalis, Biharis and west Pakistanis with some cases in Khulna where they would bash heads of infants against walls to kill them

 

[kingQamaR]

sadly been outstanding for some 1947

our establishment will not offer anything to the afghans , Bangladeshis, Biharis , royinga and others- could do with our local Pakistanis are very racists to certain above groups not to all

 

[untitled]

Only if they can prove that they were with Pakistan during 71 war

How is someone born after the 71 war going to prove that?

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

Story of two Bangali girls who want to represent Pakistan internationally in Gymnastics.

They are living here pre 71.

These are post-71.

Thousands of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants arrived in Pakistan in the 1980s, while Bangladesh was battling extreme poverty.[2] By 1995, continuous migration of Bangladeshis crossed the 2,500,000 mark. During the administration of Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto, some top advisers became concerned with the large Bangladeshi migrant population, afraid they could become the second largest group in Karachi after Urdu-speaking Muhajir people and disturb sensitive demographics. Accordingly, Bhutto ordered a crackdown and deportation on Bangladeshi immigrants. Benazir Bhutto's action strained and created tensions in Bangladesh–Pakistan relations, with Khaleda Zia, who was in power in Dhaka during the time, refusing to accept the deportees and reportedly sending two planeloads back towards Pakistan and Muslim political parties in Pakistan criticising Bhutto and dubbing the crackdown as anti-Islamic. She was ultimately forced to abandon the order.[3][4]

They were cheering on Indian troops as they entered Dhaka but migrated to Karachi in droves when the newly independent state could not economically sustain them.

 

[GHALIB]

Disagree. Muslims first. Any Muslim should get Pakistan citizenship as matter or right.

View attachment 780950

Islam does not allow boundary for muslims .

 

[Fahad20007]

These people have been living here since before 1971s. This group also includes around 650,000 Rohingyas and they number around 3-4 million in total. Tahera's been doing some great work with the Bengali kids. Unfortunately the citizenship issue is even more controversial because they're centered in Karachi and it opens up another Pandora's box from PPP side

 

[Maula Jatt]

sadly been outstanding for some 1947

our establishment will not offer anything to the afghans , Bangladeshis, Biharis , royinga and others- could do with our local Pakistanis are very racists to certain above groups not to all

Why should we give citizenship to Afghans who we are not sure are loyal to Pakistan

Point- 14 August Peshawar

As for Bangladeshis if they were economic migrants of 90s living in an already overcrowded city of Karachi
Again makes little sense but as far as I know they're not talking crap about Pakistan or are loyal to the state with no major anti pakistan incident

But I am still a little hesitant with them- don't mind this situation...

Bihari and Rohingyas who were born in pakistan should 100% get ctizenship

 

[GHALIB]

Why should we give citizenship to Afghans who we are not sure are loyal to Pakistan

Point- 14 August Peshawar

As for Bangladeshis if they were economic migrants of 90s living in an already overcrowded city of Karachi
Again makes little sense but as far as I know they're not talking crap about Pakistan or are loyal to the state with no major anti pakistan incident

But I am still a little hesitant with them- don't mind this situation...

Bihari and Rohingyas who were born in pakistan should 100% get ctizenship

They are muslims , pakistan was made for muslims .

 

[Maula Jatt]

They are muslims , pakistan was made for muslims .

you are a secular state
why are you taking in only dharmic refugees from nieghboring countries?
what kind of secularism is this

btw TNT is a belief that muslism majority people cannot live under a Hindu majority country - your Hindutva's were the founders of this theory
doesn't mean every Muslim who ever existed becomes a Pakistani

These people have been living here since before 1971s. This group also includes around 650,000 Rohingyas and they number around 3-4 million in total. Tahera's been doing some great work with the Bengali kids. Unfortunately the citizenship issue is even more controversial because they're centered in Karachi and it opens up another Pandora's box from PPP side

send em to Punjab if they decide to give Bihari's or Rohingya's citizenship

 

[Skywalker]

All these bengalis should get the PAkistani citizenship, they are umpteenth times better than the haramkhor afghans.

 

[kingQamaR]

Nah, you not going to get to pick and choose on your personal prejudices

kick them all out Bangladeshis, afghans, royingas or 71 Biharis coming. I don’t want any of them in Pakistan