South China Sea Forum

[Eliter]

You are idiot.

After 1954, by Geneve aggreement signed by China and North Vietnam, Islands are located below 17 pararell so Islands belong to us South Vietnamese people.
1/ North Vietnam don't have right over Islands of South Vietnam.
2/ The letter (by personnally) stated only North Vietnam will be respected 12 coustline of maind land China only and didn't mentioned about the Islands.
1/ Any case this is useless paper for China.

Do you understand, idiot chinese boy ?

idiot reply.history of knowledge as poor.
You said 50% Vietnamese(North Vietnam) was agreed Xi sha Islands(Paracel Islands ) and Nan sha Islands(Spratly Islands ) belong to China.
================



Nansha Qundao, Nansha Islands, Spratly Islands(南沙群&#23707
Jiuzhang Qundjiao, Union Banks and Reef, Union Tablemount 九章群礁

3600X2930

 

[romia]

Bullshit!
Japanese dog found China in ancient times?when and where?DASHABI

 

[EastSea]

idiot reply.history of knowledge as poor.
You said 50% Vietnamese(North Vietnam) was agreed Xi sha Islands(Paracel Islands ) and Nan sha Islands(Spratly Islands ) belong to China.
================



Nansha Qundao, Nansha Islands, Spratly Islands(南沙群&#23707
Jiuzhang Qundjiao, Union Banks and Reef, Union Tablemount 九章群礁

3600X2930

You are liar.
Your troll admitted that your English is very poor, idiot boy. You do not understand Geneve Aggreement 1954, or in other words The Geneva Conference (April 26 – July 20, 1954[1]) was a conference which took place in Geneva, Switzerland, signed by North Vietnam and China PRC with France 1954.
North Vietnamese do not have right over Islands of South Vietnam to "agree" as you lie. The letter of PM PVD didn't do that. North Corea can't say any words about sovereignty of South Korea over Dokdo. Lying is chinese job.

 

[Soryu]

Plese,offer testimony.

September.4.1958,China government was declared Chinese territorial waters included Xi sha Islands(Paracel Islands ) and Nan sha Islands(Spratly Islands ).

September.14.1958,Vietnam government was present a note to China government. declared"agree and support".

this note made in China too?

China: we have proof about our sovereignty over Island.

Vietnam: where's it?

China: ........... bla bla bla ... ....

Vietnam: where is it? Here is your map and our map, Nothing show it belong to china, but show it belong to VietNam.

China: .... We have th letter your Prime Misnister sign and agree with our claim!

Vietnam: That letter was said to agree with your 12nm territorial waters!

China: ... idiot, bla bla bla,.... bullshjt, bla bla bla,... ungraceful, bla bla bla ... we will destroy Vietnam, bla bla bla... we will teach you another lesson ... bla bla bla...

Vietnam: Where's your proof about your claim over two Islands !?

China: ................................ bla bla bla ..............

 

[Zero_wing]

You are liar.
Your troll admitted that your English is very poor, idiot boy. You do not understand Geneve Aggreement 1954, or in other words The Geneva Conference (April 26 – July 20, 1954[1]) was a conference which took place in Geneva, Switzerland, signed by North Vietnam and China PRC with France 1954.
North Vietnamese do not have right over Islands of South Vietnam to "agree" as you lie. The letter of PM PVD didn't do that. North Corea can't say any words about sovereignty of South Korea over Dokdo. Lying is chinese job.

They are trolls idiot who love to pick fight with no logic what so ever

 

[hoangsa]

China is using jungle law and muscle law. Discussion here is just for fun. They are no way to understand the international law of modern law. They are thinking they are in chaos time of three kingdoms .

Unlucky China' neighbors like Vietnam or Philippine are weaker but will stand still bravely and strongly in front of a perverse China. South East Asian Sea will become sea of fire to burn all of supplier Chinese ships, while US and Japan are ready to use muscle to teach China which age they are living.

 

[cirr]

The PLA Army （note：not PLAN） has an existing force of 181 such ships for the baboons and monkeys in the SCS，and can easily convert hundreds，if not thousands more， of similar or bigger vessels for the same use：

Pic taken of a recent exercise in the SCS。

 

[cirr]

DDG 153 seen docked at a naval port during her recent sea trial：

FFG 597 “Qinzhou” nearly ready for the Hong Kong PLAN Garrison：

 

[Eliter]

China: we have proof about our sovereignty over Island.

Vietnam: where's it?

China: ........... bla bla bla ... ....

Vietnam: where is it? Here is your map and our map, Nothing show it belong to china, but show it belong to VietNam.

China: .... We have th letter your Prime Misnister sign and agree with our claim!

Vietnam: That letter was said to agree with your 12nm territorial waters!

China: ... idiot, bla bla bla,.... bullshjt, bla bla bla,... ungraceful, bla bla bla ... we will destroy Vietnam, bla bla bla... we will teach you another lesson ... bla bla bla...

Vietnam: Where's your proof about your claim over two Islands !?

China: ................................ bla bla bla ..............

You are liar.Look here!

 

[Soryu]

China's sovereignty story:

We were claim this Islands > It's useless and not reliable > we have proof about > It's fake and not reliable > we have your words accept our claim > It's your failure proof and useless > we have our PLA for rob anything that we want > It's useless, fail and not reliable, thief ....

 

[Soryu]

You are liar.Look here!

You were lied by your Government and some greedy man:

No matter your "included", our PM Pham Van Dong just agreed with PRC's 12 nm territorial waters, nothing more.

 

[Eliter]

You were lied by your Government and some greedy man:

No matter your "included", our PM Pham Van Dong just agreed with PRC's 12 nm territorial waters, nothing more.

Then,Pham Van Dong Government's map

 

[Soryu]

Then,Pham Van Dong Government's map

What's proven that image is PVD government map, but was not propaganda image from PRC ?

Why did Chinese scholars not show that map in any international & regional conference about SCS ?

...

 

[VietHome]

Qing Dynasty Map in 1904 printed by Shanghai Publishing House showed that Chinese territory stops at Hainan Islands. End of story

Truong Sa, Hoang Sa not belong to China: 1904 Chinese map - News VietNamNet

 

[VietHome]

Further questions on Pham Van Dong's letter, read my post here.

http://www.defence.pk/forums/china-...shi-channel-between-taiwan-philippines-8.html