Somebody is trying to use the incident of Madina Masjid to incite discord

[Imran Khan]

This is why all sects should be abolished and there should only be state controlled masajid with state appointed cleric using only Quran and Sunnah for reference.

people follow here sect more then country . for them other sects are non muslim or less muslims or on wrong path . tell me how they can leave sect ?

 

[Peaceful Civilian]

we need a Deobandi mosque. You might believe in praying anywhere, we don't. We need a Deobandi mosque to pray.

This is what creates division, intolerance and hate in society. This Hate , and poison our people are spreading is against the fundamental teaching of Islam.

Holy Prophet (SAW) said in one of His hadith: “Trials will Divide the Nation (into sects) and Safety will be in adhering to the AlJamaa’ah.”

Quran is against the divisions of Muslim, fitna , or hate in society.
Quran says
"Aur ALLAH ki rassi ko mazbooti se thamay rakho aur tafarqay main naa paro" (Surah Aale Imran, Ayat 103)

 

[Imran Khan]

And if you check those mosques in the planning, they will turn out to be constructed on similarly appropriate land. So this is an attack of Deobandis. Secondly, although there are many mosques, we need a Deobandi mosque. You might believe in praying anywhere, we don't. We need a Deobandi mosque to pray.

what is deoband ? its a city in india right ? do you guys worship toward makkah or deoband ?

 

[PakFactor]

How can you offer namaz on illegal land. Surely that invalidates the prayer?

Plus because this is Pakistan the next deobandi masjid is probably within a 10 minute walk.

There is a story my father told me when I was little. One sahabi came to another sahabi and asked how he can perfect his namaz, so Allah (swt) can accept it. He said 1st make sure your rizq (income) is halal and the clothes you have on your back are from that halal income. As for this masjid whose foundation is built on theft there can’t be any blessing or barkat whoever prays there.

 

[SaadH]

people follow here sect more then country . for them other sects are non muslim or less muslims or on wrong path . tell me how they can leave sect ?

People need a dunda up their collective asses and all sects should be abolished, starting with sunnis/shias...

Don't like the law, migrate...

 

[Imran Khan]

People need a dunda up their collective asses and all sects should be abolished, starting with sunnis/shias...

Don't like the law, migrate...

one is here in this thread he can not pray in other mosque he need deoband india mosque for himself what a nation we have they are more deobandi brelvi then muslims . indian cities are ruined even islam .
جب یوگی ادتیا ناتھ دیوبندھ کا نام رام پور اور رائے بریلی کا نام بھگوان پورہ رکھ دے گا تو کیا پاکستانی دیوبندی خود کو رامبندی اور بریلوی خود کو بھگوانریلوی کہلائیں گے کیا ؟

 

[imadul]

Dawn's article says:

SC turns down plea to stop demolition of mosque built on encroached land in Karachi

"All we can do is order the mosque not to be demolished until a new site is earmarked for it," CJP remarks.

www.dawn.com

Why is this not being pursued further by all parties? I do not see any discussion on this point, which leads me to believe some liberal enemies of Pakistan are gleefully pushing this matter towards a clash. These are the advantages I personally see in pursuing the Chief Justice's suggestion:

1. First of all, it will set a just precedent for dealing with mosques constructed on spaces initially allocated for other purposes. The government will now be bound to allocate proper space in accordance with the needs of the population, hand the space to the masjid committee who can then construct a new mosque, and the old one can then be demolished.

2. Even if our Ulema succeed in avoiding the demolishing of the mosque today, this matter will keep rearing its ugly head again and again. And unsavory elements will now try to create this discord all over Pakistan.

3. If we pursue the Chief Justice's suggestion, then the government can say "We now change the allocation of this space from park to mosque". This would be a correct interpretation of the Chief Justice's instruction and would solve all problems at once.

Why isn't anyone discussing this?

@WebMaster @The Eagle @waz @Horus @Foxtrot Alpha @Kambojaric @krash are you guys able to bring these points to the notice of relevant people? Jazak Allah Khair for your efforts.

This was discussed Quiet a bit

Demolition of Madina Masjid, Tariq Road on Encroached Land!!

Pakistan Supreme Court CJ Gulzar Ahmad had ordered the demolition of Madina Masjid built on the land encroached from a Park. As usual the muminun are determined to fight the Majisd built illegally, immorally, and against Shariah. Why does not anyone from these muminun give their own home for...

defence.pk

 

[untitled]

This is why all sects should be abolished and there should only be state controlled masajid with state appointed cleric using only Quran and Sunnah for reference.

Do you also nominte your version of Islam to be the state sponsored Islam of Pakistan?

one is here in this thread he can not pray in other mosque he need deoband india mosque for himself what a nation we have they are more deobandi brelvi then muslims . indian cities are ruined even islam .

Simple. They don't have to agree with their name changes. The largest religon in the world is called the Roman Catholic Church. The Roman empire no longer exists and the Vatican is no longer part of Rome

what is deoband ? its a city in india right ? do you guys worship toward makkah or deoband ?

A muslim scholar does'nt need to have been born in Makkah

 

[Imran Khan]

Do you also nominte your version of Islam to be the state sponsored Islam of Pakistan?

Simple. They don't have to agree with their name changes. The largest religon in the world is called the Roman Catholic Church. The Roman empire no longer exists and the Vatican is no longer part of Rome

A muslim scholar does'nt need to have been born in Makkah

sr as i know prophet Mohmmad PBUH give us a very good name called MUSLIM . i dont need anything else to itroduce . go to indonesia tunisia morocco sudan and say i am deobandi they may think you are non muslim until you say i am muslim they will not recognize your faith . this BS deobandi brelvi is local south asian .

 

[Super Falcon]

First of all we are such a idiot nation dont know exactly what is islam

Islam is against all injustice even one offrom islam does it

Remember PROPHET MOHAMMAD
P. B. U. H said that if my daughter BIBI FATIMA have been zstealing she woukd get same puunishment as any one

So if masjid is built by wrongly than islam do not allow such acts ALKAH dont need masjids which is made by capturing someones rights those judges also shoukd understand where they are passing their judgment even that LAND also been wrongly used specialy karachi high courts alo should be destroyed because that part was pkan to use for sewrage water pipes so we have to do justice not to do what suits me us our

 

[Vapnope]

Actually, you are clueless in religious matters. Praying behind a Deobandi Imam is my fundamental right and my freedom of religion. You are a usurper of my freedoms and the actual educated uncouth criminal.

Goes against the order of Quran which essentially warns muslims to not get divided in sects. Some Pakistanis proudly bring in their sectarian bias against the teaching of Islam and yet claim to be the only true muslims. Amazing

 

[untitled]

this BS deobandi brelvi is local south asian .

Why can't people of South Asia have their own understanding of Islam?

 

[Imran Khan]

Why can't people of South Asia have their own understanding of Islam?

TBH you catch me from my neck. your question belongs to postmodernism philosophy . and i am forced to say yes every human and group have right to understand and explain the meaning of anything including Islam .

 

[Cryptic_Mafia]

Why can't people of South Asia have their own understanding of Islam?

we dont need some localized version of Islam,Islam is Islam its black and white its the cancerous Mullahs who have twisted things for their own "political" benefit!

what they are doing is they are making people follow their version of Islam they rule madarssas like kings and they are creating sheeps who dont follow Allahs religion but following religion created by Mullah! Mullahs are the biggest fitna in current times!

 

[MisterSyed]

I am a Shia Muslim and i have offered basically most of my Jummah Prayers in a Sunni Mosque, Nobody gives a Single F on which sect i belong too, the real Thing here is whether am i Offering my Prayers or not.