What's new

Some myths and legends about Shia people which are not true

Status
Not open for further replies.

Zibago

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 21, 2012
Messages
37,006
Reaction score
12
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Some myths and legends about Shia people which are not true
October 8, 2016 Majid Khan 4 Comments differences, pakistan, rumors, shama gul, shia, sunni
Some myths and legends about Shia people which are not true
The shia sunni differences were always there since Karbala and I don’t think they are going to solve ever. We can see the misconceptions on both sides but shia people are mostly the target of a lot of rumors.

When I was in class 3 I heard something from somewhere and said to a class fellow shia girl “Shia loog na biryani ki daig banatay hain aur sunniyon ke bachon ka sar kaat k os mein se khoon daig mein daltay hain aur phir wohi biryani hamare ghar bhejtay hain”. She told this to her mother was the Vice Principal of our school and I was made to stand in the ground for whole day with my hands up in the air.

This was just an example how rumors have been affecting the mindset of people from other sects.

Shias are peaceful people I have witnessed the Abbas Town Blast of Karachi 2013 myself as I was standing at Abul Hasan Isphani Road that moment and what I saw was that they were trying to minimize casualties and save as many people as they could
Anyway coming toward our main focus are I have to talk about some rumors we have been hearing about our Ahl-e-Tashee brothers and how wrong they are.



1 – SPITTING IN FOOD AND WATER BEFORE SERVING US
This is the most basic type of misconception a great number of people have about them. Greater problem is that people actually believe this thing. Even I used to believe on that but later on Syed Sibte Hasan Qaim Naqvi became my best friend in ACCA and I ate so much food at his home that nothing really matters now. Think logically. He is taking food from the same dish you are. Why would they spit on it? Not even some junglee people will do that.


via: addtext


2 – 40 PAARAHS OUT OF WHICH A GOAT ATE 10
This is another legend which says that
Shias believe that originally there were 40 paarahs but 10 were eaten by a goat. Okay this is complete bullshit. A few concepts and principles are different but the ideology is same. Allah is same, Quran is same, Holy Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him) is the same one.


via: islammircals.blogspot
3 – SHAMA GUL
Okay this one is seriously taboo and wrong at so so so many levels. Some seriously disturbed people say that in some sort of mehfil people are allowed to do whatever they want with any girl or guy they want in the darkness. If a child is born due to the activities of this mehfil he/she will become a cleric. Now I don’t have any words to explain if you have any such ideas in your mind.
,I once tried to sneak into a Sham-e-Ghareban mehfil when I was like 15 years old to find out something like that but i was slapped around 30-40 times by some mustanday. It was obvious for them to find out that I am not one of them. I was wearing a yellow tee shirt.

Anyway if any of you have any such doubt you may visit a nearby Imam Bargah (Not wearing a yellow tee shirt), clearly tell them that you are a sunni and wanna attend the Sham e Gareeba. Nobody will stop you and you will be allowed to sit there till everybody leaves. You will get your assurance that no sex orgy is organized there.


via: dore-kau


EPILOGUE:
A number of my friends and a lot of my students are shia. I have never seen them in any such activities mentioned above. We have some basic differences we already know about. They are not so material that we cannot live with each other in harmony.
P.S. Shia girls are really beautiful. I always wanted a girlfriend from them. But I never dared to try because why should I try on 10 when I am already rejected by fives and sixes.
http://www.raddipaper.pk/2016/10/08/myths-shia-people-false-true/
@The Sandman @Moonlight @django @Vapnope @User @Jonah Arthur @EAK @Mr.Meap @WAJsal @Chauvinist
 
.
The hatred starts from mosque as i was listening my home town charsada when we were in Friday prayer and the Scholar started to fill mind of people with hatred against Shia my brothers were surprised to see no one were saying anything.
 
.
The hatred starts from mosque as i was listening my home town charsada when we were in Friday prayer and the Scholar started to fill mind of people with hatred against Shia my brothers were surprised to see no one were saying anything.
Lol you are talking about Charsada i saw that in mosques of Islamabad city
 
.
The only myth which unfortunately is true is that they loathe many of the Sahaba e Karam and there is no doubt about it, you can go and ask any shia about his views on let's say Hazrat Umer (R.A).
 
.
One day,i was coming in a Uber cab where a teen age driver with Afgan Origin was talking with me in my 1 hour drive. He was very much opinionated. It seems to me that he is a 2nd generation Afgan.

In spite of being brought up in USA, he was very confident and expressing his views that Sunnis are the only pious Muslims and Shias are Shias only. They are not Muslim. ..On top of that he told so many racist and ridiculous thing about killing some people is not sin, all these non sense stuff, that one will surprised and amazed about how much brain washing happens about these Shia Sunni thing among educated Muslims....And the at last, i started protesting when he started expressing views about Indian who are Muslims. Based on his fairy tale world, Indian Muslims are also not pure muslims, as they are Hindustani Muslims and they do not practice the way it should be...They out of my curosity, i asked him if he has ever been spent good number of time in Arab countries. So to confirm with my surprise, that kid has spent 3-4 year of his time in Arab world...
So i got my answer where is this rigid mindset is originated from...
 
.
1 – SPITTING IN FOOD AND WATER BEFORE SERVING US
This is the most basic type of misconception a great number of people have about them. Greater problem is that people actually believe this thing. Even I used to believe on that but later on Syed Sibte Hasan Qaim Naqvi became my best friend in ACCA and I ate so much food at his home that nothing really matters now. Think logically. He is taking food from the same dish you are. Why would they spit on it? Not even some junglee people will do that.

The same myth is used by Bodu Bala Sena in Sri Lanka to spread hate against muslims.
 
.
I think The sole reason of differences is just one.. which is they don't believe in Siddique ,Umar and Usman.. and consider them Munafiq ( NaoozBillah)..

First time when I heard this from a Sunni molvi... personally I don't believe them so I deemed him a liar.. but then I explored.. I have some shia friends I asked them in detail.. I attended their majaalis and the thing was correct..

All other myths about them don't matter but this is the thing which they believe and we non shia can't bear it.

I'll quote a few things that I learnt from them.. I told her that Muhammad (P.B.U.H) said a prayer behind Siddique when he was sick once.. I told her detail and he said no that's wrong.. you people are taught wrong by your mulla's..

Then I told her that He(P.B.U.H) said if there was another Nabi he would be Umar... she said no aysa nahi ho skta.. I showed her reference again and she denied it. She even said that Sahi Bukhari, Sahi Muslim are quoted with wrong Ahadeeth which don't exist even..
According to them their belief is correct they consider Ali a mazloom while others as zaalim as he deserved Khilafat not they. They also quote that meeting very after Nabi(P.B.U.H)'s death in a wrong perceptive of Siddique and Umar..and they strengthen their belief by the incident of Ghadeer where it was said "man kuntu mawlahu fa `Aliyyun mawlahu"

She linked it to an ayah of Surah Baqrah ayah 14...in which stated about Munfqeen and she referred it to Siddique ,Umar and Usman..

I argued with her alot but their belief is this .. and when something is someone's belief you can't take it out of them at any cost..!!
@Zarvan
 
.
“Shia loog na biryani ki daig banatay hain aur sunniyon ke bachon ka sar kaat k os mein se khoon daig mein daltay hain aur phir wohi biryani hamare ghar bhejtay hain”.
:rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl:
 
. . .
I heard about haleem dear.Not biryani. :D
Dont care mein to shok sey khata hoan aur kayi baar to jaloos sey bhi khaya tha G 6 waley sey wo jo 7th avenue sey guzarta hay

Pichley sey pichley saal to itna dhakam peel huyi kay tent hi tor diya logoan nay :-//

Phir sab ney dandey khaye mein to us tine siee pay bhait kar matam daikh raha tha har sobay ka apna elehda group bhi tha aur mixed groups bhi that
@The Sandman @Moonlight @Chauvinist
 
.
Dont care mein to shok sey khata hoan aur kayi baar to jaloos sey bhi khaya tha G 6 waley sey wo jo 7th avenue sey guzarta hay

Pichley sey pichley saal to itna dhakam peel huyi kay tent hi tor diya logoan nay :-//

Phir sab ney dandey khaye mein to us tine siee pay bhait kar matam daikh raha tha har sobay ka apna elehda group bhi tha aur mixed groups bhi that
@The Sandman @Moonlight @Chauvinist

Tum se yahi umeed ki ja skti hai..!!! 1 2 sotay parh jatay to insaan hotay aj "sheikh" nahi..

BTW that Haleem is so tasty..wesi aj tak nai khai kahin se. Main har dafa majlis main sirf Haleem ki aas pay e jati hun..:cheesy:

@Jonah Arthur in my university once they brought Zuljinnah Hazrat for treatment.. itna awla tha wo I asked him "iss ghorhay ko ap kya detay hain??" And that man was about to strangle me.. he complained about me cause I said him "ghorha"..:lol:
 
.
Dont care mein to shok sey khata hoan aur kayi baar to jaloos sey bhi khaya tha G 6 waley sey wo jo 7th avenue sey guzarta hay

Pichley sey pichley saal to itna dhakam peel huyi kay tent hi tor diya logoan nay :-//

Phir sab ney dandey khaye mein to us tine siee pay bhait kar matam daikh raha tha har sobay ka apna elehda group bhi tha aur mixed groups bhi that
@The Sandman @Moonlight @Chauvinist
G-6 jalos is mighty one. I visited many times to see shabeeh e Zuljanah due to my love with heavy breed horses.
Yes there are many groups Pashto matami group have unique style of matam, i heard most of them belong to Parachinar.

Tum se yahi umeed ki ja skti hai..!!! 1 2 sotay parh jatay to insaan hotay aj "sheikh" nahi..

BTW that Haleem is so tasty..wesi aj tak nai khai kahin se. Main har dafa majlis main sirf Haleem ki aas pay e jati hun..:cheesy:
My Shia friends especially invites me on Chehlum jaloos (19 Saffar) for Haleem. They prepare 100 plus daighs to serve attendants.

Tum se yahi umeed ki ja skti hai..!!! 1 2 sotay parh jatay to insaan hotay aj "sheikh" nahi..

BTW that Haleem is so tasty..wesi aj tak nai khai kahin se. Main har dafa majlis main sirf Haleem ki aas pay e jati hun..:cheesy:

@Jonah Arthur in my university once they brought Zuljinnah Hazrat for treatment.. itna awla tha wo I asked him "iss ghorhay ko ap kya detay hain??" And that man was about to strangle me.. he complained about me cause I said him "ghorha"..:lol:
Most of these Zuljanah belong to heavy breed horses and they are cared very well.
 
.
Tum se yahi umeed ki ja skti hai..!!! 1 2 sotay parh jatay to insaan hotay aj "sheikh" nahi..

BTW that Haleem is so tasty..wesi aj tak nai khai kahin se. Main har dafa majlis main sirf Haleem ki aas pay e jati hun..:cheesy:

@Jonah Arthur in my university once they brought Zuljinnah Hazrat for treatment.. itna awla tha wo I asked him "iss ghorhay ko ap kya detay hain??" And that man was about to strangle me.. he complained about me cause I said him "ghorha"..:lol:
Muhallay waley jo bhejtey hain us mein sey 90% mein lhata hoan aur ghar mein jo banti hay wo bhi mein hi ziyada khata hoan :D
Jalos key rastey mein bhi khata hoan but ziyada time nein matam ko daikhney guzarta hoan

Oh bibi ghora na kaho log awein mind kartey hain zuljinah ko special bara hi is liye kartey hain key wo prcoessions ka hissa banay unko desi ghee waghera khilatey hain takey wo motey aur sehat mand hoan
 
.
Muhallay waley jo bhejtey hain us mein sey 90% mein lhata hoan aur ghar mein jo banti hay wo bhi mein hi ziyada khata hoan :D
Jalos key rastey mein bhi khata hoan but ziyada time nein matam ko daikhney guzarta hoan

Oh bibi ghora na kaho log awein mind kartey hain zuljinah ko special bara hi is liye kartey hain key wo prcoessions ka hissa banay unko desi ghee waghera khilatey hain takey wo motey aur sehat mand hoan
You have good digestive system BTW. Khate jao chalte jao subha se lei kar raat tak.
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom