What's new

Sindh concedes it doesn’t control up to 70 per cent land in Karachi

Kabira

BANNED
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
14,383
Reaction score
-20
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
The Sindh government has conceded that it had no authority to control up to 70 per cent of Karachi’s area that was controlled by different federal landowning agencies.

The startling disclosure came as Sindh Information and Local Government Minister Syed Nasir Hussain Shah and Sindh Education and Labour Minister Saeed Ghani addressed a joint press conference on Sunday.

According to the information minister, federal landowning agencies that control up to 70 per cent areas of Karachi include cantonment boards, the Civil Aviation Authority, the Karachi Port Trust and the Pakistan Railways.

“But even then,” said Nasir, “the Sindh government in all areas of the city had worked day in and day out without any discrimination, as it had the support of the district municipal corporations and other such civic agencies.”

He said on several spots on Sharea Faisal and other road intersections in the city “which don’t come under the administrative control of the KMC or the DMC, provincial ministers were present on a night-long basis to supervise the operation to drain out accumulated rainwater”.

He said such troubled spots in Karachi came under the administrative control of cantonments or other land-owning agencies, “but still the Sindh government had dispatched its entire machinery and manpower to resolve the drainage issues there”.He said the 12-kilometre patch of Sharea Faisal which connected the Karachi airport to the Metropole road intersection was managed by different cantonments but “the Sindh government has been conducting sanitation work on this portion too".He said the Civil Aviation Authority in Karachi had failed to build a proper drainage system on its land in Karachi although several letters had been sent to the authority on this issue. The minister said the Sindh government had also assumed the responsibility of the waste disposal work on the CAA’s land in the city.He said all provincial ministers, advisers, and special assistants to the CM had been fully active to help the people in distress as the city had received heavy rain this time round as compared to the previous years.

Speaking on the occasion, Saeed Ghani claimed that land in the city had been encroached, including the drainage areas of Karachi, before the Pakistan Peoples Party had come to power in Sindh. He said the media and the the public knew very well that who were the people behind the encroachment in Karachi and during which era this anti-social practice had taken place.

In the past, Ghani said, “even in my own constituency in the city, the land of Karachi Water and Sewerage Board reserved for constructing Treatment Plant-II had been leased out on an illegal basis”. Later, he added, up to 2,000 houses had been constructed on this land.

Ghani said this incident had taken place despite his serious protest against the encroachment. He said unlawful settlements on the land of parks and drains in Karachi by constructing houses was quite easy while destroying those settlements was quite difficult.

He conceded that certain illegal encroachments in the city had been regularised as “now a transparent probe will be conducted into this issue and no concession will be given to the officials who abetted this unlawful practice”.
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/69...n-t-control-up-to-70-per-cent-land-in-karachi
 
.
The Sindh government has conceded that it had no authority to control up to 70 per cent of Karachi’s area that was controlled by different federal landowning agencies.

The startling disclosure came as Sindh Information and Local Government Minister Syed Nasir Hussain Shah and Sindh Education and Labour Minister Saeed Ghani addressed a joint press conference on Sunday.

According to the information minister, federal landowning agencies that control up to 70 per cent areas of Karachi include cantonment boards, the Civil Aviation Authority, the Karachi Port Trust and the Pakistan Railways.

“But even then,” said Nasir, “the Sindh government in all areas of the city had worked day in and day out without any discrimination, as it had the support of the district municipal corporations and other such civic agencies.”

He said on several spots on Sharea Faisal and other road intersections in the city “which don’t come under the administrative control of the KMC or the DMC, provincial ministers were present on a night-long basis to supervise the operation to drain out accumulated rainwater”.

He said such troubled spots in Karachi came under the administrative control of cantonments or other land-owning agencies, “but still the Sindh government had dispatched its entire machinery and manpower to resolve the drainage issues there”.He said the 12-kilometre patch of Sharea Faisal which connected the Karachi airport to the Metropole road intersection was managed by different cantonments but “the Sindh government has been conducting sanitation work on this portion too".He said the Civil Aviation Authority in Karachi had failed to build a proper drainage system on its land in Karachi although several letters had been sent to the authority on this issue. The minister said the Sindh government had also assumed the responsibility of the waste disposal work on the CAA’s land in the city.He said all provincial ministers, advisers, and special assistants to the CM had been fully active to help the people in distress as the city had received heavy rain this time round as compared to the previous years.

Speaking on the occasion, Saeed Ghani claimed that land in the city had been encroached, including the drainage areas of Karachi, before the Pakistan Peoples Party had come to power in Sindh. He said the media and the the public knew very well that who were the people behind the encroachment in Karachi and during which era this anti-social practice had taken place.

In the past, Ghani said, “even in my own constituency in the city, the land of Karachi Water and Sewerage Board reserved for constructing Treatment Plant-II had been leased out on an illegal basis”. Later, he added, up to 2,000 houses had been constructed on this land.

Ghani said this incident had taken place despite his serious protest against the encroachment. He said unlawful settlements on the land of parks and drains in Karachi by constructing houses was quite easy while destroying those settlements was quite difficult.

He conceded that certain illegal encroachments in the city had been regularised as “now a transparent probe will be conducted into this issue and no concession will be given to the officials who abetted this unlawful practice”.
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/69...n-t-control-up-to-70-per-cent-land-in-karachi

Then how come. It takes all revenue from karachi? As per mayor of karachi
‘Where is the amount Karachi pays in taxes spent?’


KARACHI: Mayor Karachi Wasim Akhtar on Monday said that the people of Karachi pay 65 percent and 95 percent taxes to the federal and Sindh governments, respectively. He asked as to where these amounts were spent.


https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/699032-where-is-the-amount-karachi-pays-in-taxes-spent


Sindh govt is a curse on karachi
 
.
Then how come. It takes all revenue from karachi?
Sindh govt is a curse on karachi

Yeah I don't get it either. Like pretty sure Lyari isn't only district paying provincial taxes in Karachi.
 
.
Ok Sindh gov excuses doesn't make sense.

EfX14DqXYAAmucI


EfX13wxXgAAkTY2


Federal agencies only control 12% of Karachi land.
 
. .
Ok Sindh gov excuses doesn't make sense.

EfX14DqXYAAmucI


EfX13wxXgAAkTY2


Federal agencies only control 12% of Karachi land.

These vast tracts of land lie well outside city limits:
Screenshot_1.jpg


48.5-21.7-17.7 = 9.1% <- This the total land area of the city (not division) under Sindh government's control.
 
.
These vast tracts of land lie well outside city limits:
View attachment 661106

48.5-21.7-17.7 = 9.1% <- This the total land area of the city (not division) under Sindh government's control.

Ok leave out outside city limit for now. KMC/Local is 40% is controlled by Sindh government. Because devolution of power never happened.

70-80% of Karachi city still under Sindh gov control vs 20-30% for DHA/federal looking at that map. Saying 70% of Karachi city land is under federal/DHA is a lie.
 
.
Ok Sindh gov excuses doesn't make sense.

EfX14DqXYAAmucI


EfX13wxXgAAkTY2


Federal agencies only control 12% of Karachi land.
Just because federal govt control peace of land doesnt mean uitilies will not be provided by province

Whats pppp educated tola problem ..are they confused ..?
Can they or not tske care of karachi
If not then let it become another province
 
. .
Ok Sindh gov excuses doesn't make sense.

EfX14DqXYAAmucI


EfX13wxXgAAkTY2


Federal agencies only control 12% of Karachi land.
Thank you for posting this now we need some data on the taxes paid to federal and provincial government as well.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom