Should Pakistan Allow Afghan Professional Refugees to Live & Work?

[jupiter2007]

This is what happens when you fill them with PPP and PML-N cadre.
They'll literally sell their mother for a few rupees.

Everything can be fixed. Why no one can make ID card without proper paper work in western countries. They have strong laws.
We need to use technology to catch corruption and strong laws to convict these criminals. Chinese are using inmates for labors, why can’t we use them for community service, pickup trash and painting walls, etc?

 

[Pakistansdefender]

Nadra is I guess giving alien identity cards to Bangladeshi in karachi and probably Afghan refugees. Though they won't be able to vote. But would be able to work or fly abroad if they want.

-3 to 4 Million Afghan Refugees are already in our country for the past 40 years. More WILL COME!
-Mostly DONT WORKING or have Informal businesses.
-Instead of (NA kaa ke na kaaj ke, DUSHMAN anaj kE), we can ask them to work & pay taxes!
-In the past 20 years, there were some improvements Afghanistan's higher education.
-What if we allow these professional (Doctors, engineers etc) and other educated people to work in Pakistan's NEGLECTED SOCIAL & other sectors working in the private sectors.
-Mind you, MOST AFGHANS are ALREADY ALLOWED TO WORK IN PAKISTAN IF THEY HAVE ALIEN (NARA) CARD FROM NADRA.
-State can also use to them to settle some in Balochistan to DILUTE Baloch majority/separatism and demographics.
-Females can be given citizenship once married to local men as per Pakistan allow (Foreign females are given citizenship once married to Pakistani Men/Foreign Men not allowed to be citizen even if married to Pakistani Ladies)
-All above to be done after extensive & rigorous security/background check by Intelligence agencies.

What do you guys think?

 

[Baz2020]

Professional drug dealers? You meant that right? I would happily give two fingers to our afghani brothers

 

[Super Falcon]

No more refuges we already had almost 30 percent of our nation filled with themm infact send them back what we have and ban afghan visas for year or so

 

[Goritoes]

To good Afghans yes, to bad ones who hate Pakistan and still wants to hurt Pakistanis' send them back and seal the border.

 

[PakSarZameen47]

No thankyou, we have had enough backstabbing and decepit. Everyday Afghans are protesting outside pakistani embassies in Europe/America, everday they are abusing Pakistan and trending "Sanction pakistan". They are filled with hatred. Enough is enough, no more appeasement

 

[Darth Vader]

Simple fact is this anyone will want best for his family, to protect them and provide a better future what they got.

Now Pakistan can see from its past you have 4+ millions , looking at Pakistani system they number much more then what is officially stated. What resources did Pakistan provide to these people in regards to settling down as from Pakistani POV it was a short term deal and they were supposed to go back so no long term plan was implemented neither by US, Afghanistan itself or Pakistan.

Accepting more refugees just dont make any sense not just because of Pakistani - Afghanistan, political and states issues but Pakistan has no infrastructure to add these people one it will not only Affect Pakistani citizens but the Afghanis who are already living inside these camps, which will increase crime rate, drugs, human and other trafficking and biggest issue of all terrorism.

Now what about 3mil + Afghani one Pakistan must ask every one to leave no matter what ever the circumstances as they were supposed to, or 2nd Provide documents for 2nd or 3rd Generation who were born in Pakistan, but make sure they pay taxes, Are not involved in any kind of criminal activities if they are any one of family is involved whole family will be sent back, will solve many problems.

Simply keeping a blind eye from this situation will not resolve this.

Even if Afghans blame everything on Pakistan they are welcome to go back and actually stand up for the issues in Afghanistan make Afghanistan great again. Who ever is involved in any kind of criminal activity instead of wasting time put him and his family in red list drop them off safely at International border inside Afghanistan they can travel to the best country in the world ( India ) which have enough resources and expertise to handle these kind of issues easily

 

[Khanate]

@faani83 Are you Afghan?

Can't say I'm surprised to read the responses here.

After all, many of those in power in Kabul for the last two decades were once refugees in Pakistan. Karzai, Ghani, and Saleh lived or worked in Pakistan in some capacity. Yet they choose to poison the atmosphere between Pakistan and Afghanistan to please India and America, neither of whom is willing to take in Afghan refugees.

We can see some of the things Pakistan has done for Afghan refugees despite being a impoverished country. The question I have is, what did Afghans get in return from India and America for their blind loyalty?

 

[faani83]

@faani83 Are you Afghan?

Can't say I'm surprised to read the responses here.

After all, many of those in power in Kabul for the last two decades were once refugees in Pakistan. Karzai, Ghani, and Saleh lived or worked in Pakistan in some capacity. Yet they choose to poison the atmosphere between Pakistan and Afghanistan to please India and America, neither of whom is willing to take in Afghan refugees.

We can see some of the things Pakistan has done for Afghan refugees despite being a impoverished country. The question I have is, what did Afghans get in return from India and America for their blind loyalty?

No My Ethnicity is Punjabi and am Proud Pakistani National .....!

 

[SQ8]

Afghans have an inherent hate and resentment for Pakistan that dates back to the Khilafat movement. It is taught from generation to generation so I find it odd that Pakistanis want to offer anything else in return after seeing that experiment fail since 1979.

 

[Zarvan]

Afghans have an inherent hate and resentment for Pakistan that dates back to the Khilafat movement. It is taught from generation to generation so I find it odd that Pakistanis want to offer anything else in return after seeing that experiment fail since 1979.

And I agree. Keep them in Afghanistan.

 

[Maula Jatt]

Any refugee with a bachelors degree should be given citizenship imo-
but any CM of a province they are residing in can take back the citizenship if they are found to be involved in anti-Pakistan activities

 

[Menace2Society]

View attachment 810946
Any refugee with a bachelors degree should be given citizenship imo-
but any CM of a province they are residing in can take back the citizenship if they are found to be involved in anti-Pakistan activities

A degree can be faked. They can all go back home and take their culture with them. If there is a hint of chaos in Pakistan they will flip go anti state and the world will think they are Pakistanis. Already gone through enough.

Would you let Indians settle in Pakistan? You wouldn't and India have been civil compared to Afghanistan with their support to TTP and other terrorist groups which have cost thousands of lives.

Pakistan is not ready for this just yet, it needs to be incubated for longer to make the culture stronger then invite everyone from the world who does not come from a violent country which supports any anti Pakistan narratives. All refugees, migrants, children of Afghans born in Pakistan must go home.

 

[fitpOsitive]

-3 to 4 Million Afghan Refugees are already in our country for the past 40 years. More WILL COME!
-Mostly DONT WORKING or have Informal businesses.
-Instead of (NA kaa ke na kaaj ke, DUSHMAN anaj kE), we can ask them to work & pay taxes!
-In the past 20 years, there were some improvements Afghanistan's higher education.
-What if we allow these professional (Doctors, engineers etc) and other educated people to work in Pakistan's NEGLECTED SOCIAL & other sectors working in the private sectors.
-Mind you, MOST AFGHANS are ALREADY ALLOWED TO WORK IN PAKISTAN IF THEY HAVE ALIEN (NARA) CARD FROM NADRA.
-State can also use to them to settle some in Balochistan to DILUTE Baloch majority/separatism and demographics.
-Females can be given citizenship once married to local men as per Pakistan allow (Foreign females are given citizenship once married to Pakistani Men/Foreign Men not allowed to be citizen even if married to Pakistani Ladies)
-All above to be done after extensive & rigorous security/background check by Intelligence agencies.

What do you guys think?

We should.

 

[Menace2Society]

-State can also use to them to settle some in Balochistan to DILUTE Baloch majority/separatism and demographics.

They will snatch Baluchistan from you, they crave access to the sea. That has always been their grand objective. I will give your suggestion a 0 out of 10.