Should Muslims of India indulge in Strategic Migration?

[my2cents]

Why should Indian people leave their own country because some people don't value their religion? I suppose we can spin the argument the other way. If you don't agree to people having the freedom to put religion above the state then you are free to leave for some other country (and looking at the number of overseas Indians quite a few already have ).

You cannot ask the majority to change their laws for your religious obligations. Your religion may say to stone a woman to death for adultery but law of the land has different punishment. Which one do you think should take precedence?? For us it is the law of the land. Our laws evolve as we evolve but the religious laws are set in stone. So you see the conflict you impose on others.

 

[Doctor Strange]

Strategic Migration towards South and North. Control sea route from south. And connect two Muslims land from North, Pakistan and Bangladesh.

 

[rishav]

There is hindutva is some of the south indian states too . Recently in karnataka BJP emerged as the single largest party . Amit shah used full on hindutva politics in coastal karnataka and won votes for BJP . Even in 2014 LS BJP got 18/27 seats . Congress proposed to give separate religion to lingayats , result ? still majority of lingayats voted for BJP . BJP got good number of SC/ST votes in karnataka .
I think kerala hindus also have hindutva hidden in them . BJP just needs to give them a little push .
Tamil nadu no chance ever.

 

[Cookie Monster]

I have said it many times before, Migrate to South if you dont want to be victim of state sponsored sanghi swines. Southern are much more tolerant.

Muslims of that region already make good % of population but if their northern brothers help increase their numbers they can gain self rule in some states.

They should pick a state that already has a sizable Muslim population...preferably bordering Bangladesh, or Pak, or China, or the ocean(in the south)...so that if another secession was to happen, they wouldn't end up with a state smack in the middle of India...landlocked and entirely dependent on India. This would essentially be meaningless bcuz they will end up being a vassal state.

I think Uttar Pradesh currently has the highest Muslim population in India...that way they will end up bordering Nepal I think...
The best one might be West Bengal...if they were to concentrate there over time...and secede. They will have access to the ocean and depending on the level of commonality with Bangladeshis may even merge with Bangladesh.

This is all theoretical of course...I don't think Indian Muslims are clamoring for secession nor are they going to move around in such mass numbers with a strategic long term goal in mind. Moreover even if they did...Indian armed forces would forcefully try to put a stop to it.

 

[Chhatrapati]

Bangladesh.

Yuck

 

[Max]

They should pick a state that already has a sizable Muslim population...preferably bordering Bangladesh, or Pak, or China, or the ocean(in the south)...so that if another secession was to happen, they wouldn't end up with a state smack in the middle of India...landlocked and entirely dependent on India. This would essentially be meaningless bcuz they will end up being a vassal state.

I think Uttar Pradesh currently has the highest Muslim population in India...that way they will end up bordering Nepal I think...
The best one might be West Bengal...if they were to concentrate there over time...and secede. They will have access to the ocean and depending on the level of commonality with Bangladeshis may even merge with Bangladesh.

This is all theoretical of course...I don't think Indian Muslims are clamoring for secession nor are they going to move around in such mass numbers with a strategic long term goal in mind. Moreover even if they did...Indian armed forces would forcefully try to put a stop to it.

Assam, west Bengal, Kerela etc have good chunk of Muslim and Christian population..

I agree Hindu establishment will resist any mass migration in the name of Muslims. But they can get on with RSS passport. They should join RSS Muslim branch to migrate easily.. lol

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Barring the racial profiles, you're mirroring my point.
This post would've been better aimed at convincing your fellow countryman @khansaheeb

The vast majority of Pakistanis ARE racially different to indians. Concentrating on the small minority that may be similar is even more pointless than concentrating on the greater percentage of Pakistanis that are racially identical to Iranians/Afghans. It is completely irrelevant and inconsequential.

 

[Politico]

I love fairytales. Will somebody please create a thread on Cinderella

 

[PurpleStone]

Good proposal

Thanks Brother.

I have said it many times before, Migrate to South if you dont want to be victim of state sponsored sanghi swines. Southern are much more tolerant.

Muslims of that region already make good % of population but if their northern brothers help increase their numbers they can gain self rule in some states.

South Indians are very docile unlike their North Indian counterparts who are very militant.

Strategic Migration towards South and North. Control sea route from south. And connect two Muslims land from North, Pakistan and Bangladesh.

There are three proposals being debated in the Indian Muslims circles.

@The Last Jedi The proposal in blue that you are alluding to is the most practical one.

The proposal is to have vulnerable Muslims in pockets within fanatical Hindu areas to move to save havens of Majority Muslim areas. At present the Indian Muslims are being castigated and intimidated , being forced to dilute their values, beliefs and religion by the not so tolerant Hindu extremists. Muslims should be higher concentration areas where they can eat beef and perpetuate Islam in safety. Indian Muslims should migrate to Delhi, Mumbai, Calcutta, Rajastan , Kerala, etc

Just moving to cities which are spread out would not help. The land should be contiguous and should have border with either Pakistan or Bangladesh or the Sea.

 

[Tea addict]

I think Uttar Pradesh currently has the highest Muslim population in India...that way they will end up bordering Nepal I think...


a.

Larger Muslim population is in Uttar Pradesh, and most of them are in western UP where there are cities like deoband, Bareli, aligarh and many other cities which has significance of Muslims of south asia. 40 % of west UP is muslim and as mentioned above, their clergy is extremists.. They have more percentage than West Bengal, Kerala, Assam but do you know why they don't try the same shit they do in those states? Because the other side is 40 %jaats, gujjars, Rajputs, tyagis, rors etc.. In 2013 muzaffarnagar riots, they targeted only Jaats and still they had their back handed to them even though the police was targeting jaats.
Good luck trying that shit in UP.

 

[Crixus]

It’s news that in Haryana they are 5-10% but they are shit scared to even have even Muslim names ..... I hav a Muslim class mate with Hindu name came to know after 3 years that he was Muslim ......... We are OK if they leave Haryana

Thanks Brother.



South Indians are very docile unlike their North Indian counterparts who are very militant.





There are three proposals being debated in the Indian Muslims circles.

@The Last Jedi The proposal in blue that you are alluding to is the most practical one.

View attachment 478078

View attachment 478079



Just moving to cities which are spread out would not help. The land should be contiguous and should have border with either Pakistan or Bangladesh or the Sea.

 

[Cookie Monster]

Larger Muslim population is in Uttar Pradesh, and most of them are in western UP where there are cities like deoband, Bareli, aligarh and many other cities which has significance of Muslims of south asia. 40 % of west UP is muslim and as mentioned above, their clergy is extremists.. They have more percentage than West Bengal, Kerala, Assam but do you know why they don't try the same shit they do in those states? Because the other side is 40 %jaats, gujjars, Rajputs, tyagis, rors etc.. In 2013 muzaffarnagar riots, they targeted only Jaats and still they had their back handed to them even though the police was targeting jaats.
Good luck trying that shit in UP.

Perhaps u didn't read my last paragraph before getting emotional...this is a theoretical/what if thread...read my last paragraph where I said this is highly unlikely to happen.

And spare me ur BS about Jaats and what not. There's no race on earth that's superior to others in their martial capabilities. Each and everyone of us has the capability to be compassionate/benevolent or be a psychopathic murdering maniac.

 

[Imran Khan]

throw them in Indian ocean we don't care

 

[PurpleStone]

Larger Muslim population is in Uttar Pradesh, and most of them are in western UP where there are cities like deoband, Bareli, aligarh and many other cities which has significance of Muslims of south asia. 40 % of west UP is muslim and as mentioned above, their clergy is extremists.. They have more percentage than West Bengal, Kerala, Assam but do you know why they don't try the same shit they do in those states? Because the other side is 40 %jaats, gujjars, Rajputs, tyagis, rors etc.. In 2013 muzaffarnagar riots, they targeted only Jaats and still they had their back handed to them even though the police was targeting jaats.
Good luck trying that shit in UP.

Muslims of Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan & Gujarat should migrate to UP, Bihar and West Bengal.

 

[khansaheeb]

indian Muslims have got nothing to do with Pakistan. They are completely different to us in every way possible. In fact bar religion, indian so called "Muslims" are identical to sikhs and hindus in every other way. Your people, your problem.

In Islam there is no difference between one Muslim and another, it is universal brotherhood.