Should India Provide Direct Military Aid To Afghanistan?

[ExtraOdinary]

Pakistan and India both need to help Afghans. But being pragmatic was never a subcontinental trait

 

[my2cents]

This is the old Indian-raja's style thinking.

--- The $hitty thinking that has existed for 1000s of years.

Where one raja will do every bit to kill the "smaller" raja next door, even if he has to seek the help of Afghan hoards and war-lords, and British, and French, and Portuguese sailors.

And guess what, the result of this "monkey business" is that ultimately the Afghan hoards don't stop at killing the raja next door, and instead continue on and kill the whole group of damned rajahs. Small bands of hoards from Turkmans, to Afghans, to British East India company exploited this pathetic mindset of Indians and rule the whole damn Indian @rse for hundreds and in some cases 1000s of years.

Why because these Indian rajas were thinking like monkeys.

So please think like a human.

And not like a monkey-rajas of the past.

Thank you.

Care to explain what was the strategic depth of Pakistan with respect to Afghanistan?

If Indians contemplate strategic goals, then it is shitty monkey business... but for Pakistan it is their right.

 

[FaujHistorian]

Care to explain what was the strategic depth of Pakistan with respect to Afghanistan?

If Indians contemplate strategic goals, then it is shitty monkey business... but for Pakistan it is their right.

Since 1947, Indians in their $tupidit Raja style, have tried "Strategic encirclement" of Pakistan mainland via Afghanistan. Just read up Abdul Rehman Pizzwak's statements.

In the 90s, Pakistan got to take the revenge in its $tupid Indian-raja style and answered Indian-raja by launching "strategic depth".


Militarily speaking Afghan geography doesn't allow Pakistan any strategic depth.


However it does allow India to do "strategic encirclement" to some degree.

But both of them are $upid.

Because both of us loose in this pathetic game.


Time to think out of the box.

 

[acid rain]

This is the old Indian-raja's style thinking.

--- The $hitty thinking that has existed for 1000s of years.

Where one raja will do every bit to kill the "smaller" raja next door, even if he has to seek the help of Afghan hoards and war-lords, and British, and French, and Portuguese sailors.

And guess what, the result of this "monkey business" is that ultimately the Afghan hoards don't stop at killing the raja next door, and instead continue on and kill the whole group of damned rajahs. Small bands of hoards from Turkmans, to Afghans, to British East India company exploited this pathetic mindset of Indians and rule the whole damn Indian @rse for hundreds and in some cases 1000s of years.

Why because these Indian rajas were thinking like monkeys.


So please think like a human.

And not like a monkey-rajas of the past.





Thank you.

That was quite an emotional post to cover bungling and the f@ck up that has been Pakistan's policy towards its neighbors and for its proxy wars, direct wars, support and raising of terrorist groups, attempt at strategic depth and bringing in unwanted players from ME and the west to f@ck up the region even more with their idealogy, funding, weapons and fundoos.

About the "raja" stories, this has been the case throughout human history, throughout the regions, countries and continents so nothing new as to what happened in India - the meek surrendered - gave up their religions, gave up their brothers and starting serving the masters as converted slaves - while the free kept fighting and dying and eventually gaining freedom and becoming one among the most powerful countries of world.

So stop thinking like a camel or a goat and introspect on the f@ck up that one naive country has caused to the region by way of fundameentalists, jihaadis, wars, bringing in foreigners and giving them bases and creating unease for the whole region.

You are welcome.

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

Provide LCA, and LCH

 

[Shazhina]

i think indians should join with their pakistan neighbor to fight taliban, not over kashmir, what is point? and yes, for india, it would be best to have ties with afghanistan.

 

[Nair saab]

Supply Medicine , Food , Infrastructural Technical know how , Agriculture Know how ,etc But never Supply Arms or Finance for Arms...

Never give defence equipment in the form Aid... or Aid for the purchase of Defence equipment ...

 

[ExtraOdinary]

Supply Medicine , Food , Infrastructural Technical know how , Agriculture Know how ,etc But never Supply Arms or Finance for Arms...

Never give defence equipment in the form Aid... or Aid for the purchase of Defence equipment ...

Aql ki baat kari hai Nair Saab. Kal ka gussa thanda ho gaya aapka

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Provide LCA, and LCH

Sure man.....

 

[acid rain]

Since 1947, Indians in their $tupidit Raja style, have tried "Strategic encirclement" of Pakistan mainland via Afghanistan. Just read up Abdul Rehman Pizzwak's statements.

In the 90s, Pakistan got to take the revenge in its $tupid Indian-raja style and answered Indian-raja by launching "strategic depth".


Militarily speaking Afghan geography doesn't allow Pakistan any strategic depth.


However it does allow India to do "strategic encirclement" to some degree.

But both of them are $upid.

Because both of us loose in this pathetic game.


Time to think out of the box.

Tell that to the numerous dictators who usurped power, tell that to the Mullah brigade and the intelligence wings who brainwash, raise and train armies of jihaadis and fundamentalists to fight in foreign lands and in neighbors lands, tell that to the people who formed Al Qaeda, LET, LEJ and the thousands of lashkars and splinter cells and the mighty Taliban and the Haqqanis, tell that to the generals who brought in the west and the chinese and gave them bases and ports and destabilising the region and causing trouble to its neighbors and finally tell that to the founders and supporters of global jihaad, wahaabism, proxy wars, thousand year war and proponents of Shariah.

Tell them to think out of the box - but I doubt they will ever heed your advice.

 

[EXPERIMENT]

This is the old Indian-raja's style thinking.

--- The $hitty thinking that has existed for 1000s of years.

Where one raja will do every bit to kill the "smaller" raja next door, even if he has to seek the help of Afghan hoards and war-lords, and British, and French, and Portuguese sailors.

And guess what, the result of this "monkey business" is that ultimately the Afghan hoards don't stop at killing the raja next door, and instead continue on and kill the whole group of damned rajahs. Small bands of hoards from Turkmans, to Afghans, to British East India company exploited this pathetic mindset of Indians and rule the whole damn Indian @rse for hundreds and in some cases 1000s of years.

Why because these Indian rajas were thinking like monkeys.


So please think like a human.

And not like a monkey-rajas of the past.





Thank you.

At long last someone gets it.

 

[VeeraBhadra]

Supply Medicine , Food , Infrastructural Technical know how , Agriculture Know how ,etc But never Supply Arms or Finance for Arms...

Never give defence equipment in the form Aid... or Aid for the purchase of Defence equipment ...

We are already providing them training and some basic hardwares in the forms of firearms , we had security pact with them back in 2011 with Karzai.If you want to protect 2 Billion $ invested there then no half measures.When will we realize your true potential ??

 

[Nair saab]

Aql ki baat kari hai Nair Saab. Kal ka gussa thanda ho gaya aapka

I rarely get angry ... I dont even remember when was the last time i got angry ... I am known for being the most peaceful person in my friends circle ... & Most of them are Non-Hindus ...

 

[Sugarcane]

India should setup basis in Afghanistan. It will not be difficult because Afghanis don't hate them unlike US.

 

[Nair saab]

We are already providing them training and some basic hardwares in the forms of firearms , we had security pact with them back in 2011 with Karzai.If you want to protect 2 Billion $ invested there then no half measures.When will we realize your true potential ??

I am against Giving any Defence Aid to any country accept Nepal & Bhutan ...

Training is Fine.... even selling of Defence Equipments is Fine

But not in the form of AID...