Should Army be given constitutional role in Politics?

[he-man]

How? Where is his street power?

Public memory is very short,,,like a firefly.
Never underestimate their stupidity when imran khan fails to do anything in 1-2 years.And what magic can he do in such time when

1)No one pays tax
2)All are sealing electricity
3)Army dosen't let pakistan do business with india???

 

[Norwegian]

Never underestimate their stupidity when imran khan fails to do anything in 1-2 years.And what magic can he do in such time when

When was IK a federal minister? Only reason why PakArmy is strong because Pakistani politicians have been never elected to power with huge popular mandate. All leaders are elected through rigging

 

[FaujHistorian]

You keep calling IK anarchist. Real anarchy only existed for few years during civil wars of the past. And they were not necessary all bad. Check this one out:
Anarchism in Spain - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

So now you jump to Spain?

hahahah

anarchists love instability. That's what IK is.

 

[he-man]

When was IK a federal minister? Only reason why PakArmy is strong because Pakistani politicians have been never elected to power with huge popular mandate. All leaders are elected through rigging

I was taking a hypothetical scenario.

 

[Norwegian]

So now you jump to Spain?

hahahah

anarchists love instability. That's what IK is.

Anarchism in Spain was not necessary end of the world. It wasn't a state of chaos if that's what you believe

I was taking a hypothetical scenario.

You cannot apply hypothetical scenarios on someone who have NEVER been in political power. Even when his party has coalition government in KPK, he still holds no minister seat

 

[he-man]

You cannot apply hypothetical scenarios on someone who have NEVER been in political power. Even when his party has coalition government in KPK, he still holds no minister seat

Because he is more interested in dharnas than actually ruling a state.

 

[Norwegian]

Because he is more interested in dharnas than actually ruling a state.

IK has never been tested as a minister. So we many never know his efficiency. But he truly is a statesman and a great leader if he single-handedly manages to paralyze entire government with 2/3 majority seats in Parliament. It means he must be doing something right when government will all state-machinery at its disposal is unable to crush PTI under its feet because majority of Pakistanis support PTI

 

[he-man]

IK has never been tested as a minister. So we many never know his efficiency. But he truly is a statesman and a great leader if he single-handedly manages to paralyze entire government with 2/3 majority seats in Parliament. It means he must be doing something right when government will all state-machinery at its disposal is unable to crush PTI under its feet because majority of Pakistanis support PTI

No he can be the chief minister of kpk,,who stops him??

 

[Norwegian]

No he can be the chief minister of kpk,,who stops him??

He is not interested in ministries like your Modi He wants to change Pakistani society as it was envisioned by its founder Jinnah and Iqbal. Its smack in the face of those who tirelessly claim IK is doing all this to become PM. If he wanted to become PM, he first needed to prove himself as CM of KPK and then win next elections easily!

 

[FaujHistorian]

No he can be the chief minister of kpk,,who stops him??

He cannot be.

IK is elected MNA

Someone in KP has to resign their PA seat, to allow IK to be elected.

This may be possible now that he has resigned from his NA seat.

 

[he-man]

He is not interested in ministries like your Modi He wants to change Pakistani society as it was envisioned by its founder Jinnah and Iqbal. Its smack in the face of those who tirelessly claim IK is doing all this to become PM. If he wanted to become PM, he first needed to prove himself as CM of KPK and then win next elections easily!

Beta modi ruled and transformed gujrat for 12 years before he could lay claim to pm post.

 

[FaujHistorian]

He is not interested in ministries like your Modi He wants to change Pakistani society as it was envisioned by its founder Jinnah and Iqbal. Its smack in the face of those who tirelessly claim IK is doing all this to become PM. If he wanted to become PM, he first needed to prove himself as CM of KPK and then win next elections easily!

Iqbal had no vision as he died long before Pakistan came into being.

Iqbal had very little input (nothing to say) into the makeup of Pakistani state during 1930s round table conferences. The only thing attributed to Iqbal is via his Allahbad speech where he talked in general terms where Muslim majority provinces would have been part of united India.

Please read instead of throwing names around.

Jinnah wanted a stable civilian run state like UK.

That's all.


Anything more and you will be reading tea leaves in the name of Jinnah and Iqbal.

Beta modi ruled and transformed gujrat for 12 years before he could lay claim to pm post.

good point.

IK is less experienced even comapred to his hero Kejarwal.

 

[Dubious]

If PTI is such a positive everything, then why are its tactics so negative? Care to explain this little anamoly?

I never said it is 100% positive...I ONLY pointed out it is A positive approach as compared to all the negative and harri wi attitude of everyone else to win their rights AND justice!

 

[he-man]

I never said it is 100% positive...I ONLY pointed out it is A positive approach to all the negative and harri wi attitude of everyone else to win their rights AND justice!

bacho,,bas bacho

 

[Norwegian]

Iqbal had no vision as he died long before Pakistan came into being.

LOL:
Iqbal's Vision of Pakistan: A Philosophical and Political Study | History PakHistory Pak

Jinnah wanted a stable civilian run state like UK.

And he wanted relations between Pakistan and India, like US and Canada. How about that fauji?

IK is less experienced even comapred to his hero Kejarwal.

LOLZ. IK has 18+ years of experiance in politics

Beta modi ruled and transformed gujrat for 12 years before he could lay claim to pm post.

Yeah, he did that while India already had gone through severe election reforms. IK cannot change Pakistan no matter how much he changes KPK!