Shias Of Kashmir: Socio-Political Dilemmas

[kaykay]

Find Time ASAP. Trust me, you won't repent spending time their. You'll try and find excuses to visit their, like I do.

he he really? tab toh Jana padega.

Arrey ham chale jate hai

He he sure bro. we can plan for that.

 

[Echo_419]

Man you should Visit their.. Tsomoriri Lake in Leh; It's Heaven on this earth. If wish their was no article #370, I would have bought a small home their and lived their.

can you post some pics

 

[Shahmir]

Mostly people in Pakistan thinks that shias are patriotic with Iran only

This is really funny because we are sunnis and we are loyal only to pakistan not to any other sunni country including saudi arabia, this is true for both religious or non-practicing sunnis of pakistan. But I have noted this clear tendency in many shia folks in south asia that they are more loyal to Iran than they are to the countries where they have been living in for generations. I could never understand this logic, it looks more like jews in USA more loyal to Israel than to USA.

 

[RazPaK]

This is really funny because we are sunnis and we are loyal only to pakistan not to any other sunni country including saudi arabia, this is true for both religious or non-practicing sunnis of pakistan. But I have noted this clear tendency in many shia folks in south asia that they are more loyal to Iran than they are to the countries where they have been living in for generations. I could never understand this logic, it looks more like jews in USA more loyal to Israel than to USA.

Go to Shia chat forums and see how Pakistani Shias have plans on how to convert all Pakistanis to Shias. On that forum, they are definitely more loyal to Iran than Pakistan.

 

[Shahmir]

Go to Shia chat forums and see how Pakistani Shias have plans on how to convert all Pakistanis to Shias. On that forum, they are definitely more loyal to Iran than Pakistan.

I have observed this tendency even in real life so it is really nothing news for me that I have learned on internet. Practicing shias of south asia indeed have their loyalty with iran rather than their country of origin.

 

[Defender pk]

I think their loyality for iran is just because of the Iran supreme leader because most of the shia follow him as a leader but their l-loyality is for the islmic system of iran not for iran

 

[Serpentine]

Go to Shia chat forums and see how Pakistani Shias have plans on how to convert all Pakistanis to Shias. On that forum, they are definitely more loyal to Iran than Pakistan.

It's like visting an ISIS chat room and saying Sunnis want to blow up and murder most of the planet.

That's how lame your conclusion sounds, taking real world lessons from chat rooms with few anonymous random people.

 

[RazPaK]

It's like visting an ISIS chat room and saying Sunnis want to blow up and murder most of the planet.

That's how lame your conclusion sounds, taking real world lessons from chat rooms with few anonymous random people.

Well in my case, I was shocked to see the kind of stuff they were writing on the forum. In real life, I have many Shia friends, but it made me think whether they actually feel this way.

 

[APS]

Practicing shias of south asia indeed have their loyalty with iran rather than their country of origin.

Indian Sunnis(except few barelvis) are loyal towards Saudi. Nothing surprising.

 

[Shahmir]

Indian Sunnis(except few barelvis) are loyal towards Saudi. Nothing surprising.

I can understan why indian sunnis don't feel india because indian is a very weak identity and india is under hindutva ideology. But my comment was for places like pakistan or kashmir. For example kashmiri identity is historically very strong so I am unable to understand why shias of kashmir are more loyal ot iran than to kashmir.

 

[APS]

I can understan why indian sunnis don't feel india because indian is a very weak identity. But my comment was for places like pakistan or kashmir. For example kashmiri identity is historically very strong so I am unable to understand why shias of kashmir are more loyal ot iran than to kashmir.

Rest of Indian Shias are loyal towards Iran. If saudi and iran declare a war, these guys will start fighting each other in India itself. If isis destroys any holy site of shia in Iraq then it will be interesting