Another one like the finding oil more than Kuwait?
Don’t know why we like to believe every news item, no matter how fantastic and start jumping with joy. Since news about oil refineries keep cropping up again & again, with ‘Euphoric’ statements; let’s analyse the whole situation based on sound economic realities.
Firstly Chinese & Central Asian oil/energy requirements:
I have worked in the Oil industry for more than 40 years and am still a senior member of the American Institute of Chemical Engineers. Despite being retired, I am keeping myself informed about the world oil situation.
Turkmenistan is full of natural gas & Kazakhstan full of petroleum. Central Asia, therefore, does not need any oil from Gwadar going over the land route. For the information of fellow members, Kazakhstan is already an important exporter of petroleum products. Here is an article about it.
Kazakhstan poised to rival Russia over Central Asian fuel market
https://www.reuters.com/article/kaz...-over-central-asian-fuel-market-idUSL5N1T81ZY
China is also investing in an oil refinery in Kazakhstan. The latest news I came across about it is:
ALMA ATA, Aug. 15 (Xinhua) -- An oil refinery in Kazakhstan with a 50 per cent stake by the China National Oil and Gas Exploration and Development Corporation (CNODC) on Wednesday put the second phase of its renovation project to the final test.
http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2018-08/15/c_137392639.htm
Kazakhstan with 30-billion bbl oil reserves has borders with China, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan and the Caspian Sea. It already has 3 refineries and the 4rth is going to be built.
"Kazakhstan has three major oil refineries - Atyrau, Shymkent and Pavlodar. Pavlodar refinery has already completed its modernization program. Atyrau refinery plans to launch new units by June, while Shymkent is expected to wrap up a modernisation in September.
The refining capacity of all the three plants will increase from 13.8 to 16.5 million tons after modernization of the refinery completes. Production of all types of light oil products, gasoline, diesel fuel and aviation kerosene will increase. All plants will produce gasoline for 2.3 million tons more. The production of diesel fuel will increase for 917,000 tons and aviation kerosene for 539,000 tons."
https://www.azernews.az/region/132214.html
Gwadar to Chinese border is 5950 Km distant whereas distance from Kazakhstan oil fields to Kashghar is less than 1500 km.
Therefore when there is plenty of petroleum & its products available next door, it makes no economic sense to think that CPEC corridor will be used to import the same all the way from Gwadar.
That is why the CPEC was only envisaged for the transit of import & export of dry goods.
Now let’s look at Pakistan scenario. The article in question mentions the world’s 3rd largest refinery. Currently, the 3 largest oil refineries are:
1. Reliance Industries refinery at Jamnagar, India: 1.2-million barrels per day
2. Paraguana refinery complex, Amuay –cardon BajoGrande, Venezuela: 956K barrels per day.
3. SK Energy refinery, Ulsan, South Korea: 850K barrels per day.
To be the world’s 3rd largest, it has to be bidder than SK refinery, in other words, the nameplate capacity must be around 900K bbl per day or more. This is roughly 120 K tons per day. This means that one VLCC of 250K DWT has to be discharged every 2nd day throughout the year. Currently Gwadar port can berth up to 50K DWT ships only. This means 2.5 vessels per day received and discharged!
Unless Gwadar is substantially modified, the operation is beyond the capacity of Gwadar port.
The refinery will generate about 100K tons per day of refined products that need to be transported out. Largest tank trucks carry about 9,000 gallons which is about 30 tons. This means that one would need to ship out about 3,500 trucks every day. Double this number to include dry goods imported and exported out of Gwadar; which is the primary reason for the CPEC; IMHO so much traffic is beyond the capacity of the CPEC project.
The article also states that it would meet Pakistan’s petroleum needs.
Pakistan’s total petroleum consumption is around 450 K bbl per day. Our current refining capacity is already about 250K per day. Recently we heard that Parco is setting up a 250 K bpd refinery at Khalifa point. It means we would have sufficient refining capacity to meet Pakistan demands for the time being. Therefore such a large refinery is not needed for Pakistan for a very long time.
Finally; the first time I came to know about Khalifa Point refinery was in 2007 in the Oil & Gas Journal.
"Pakistan approves Khalifa Point refinery near Hub
10/15/2007
By an OGJ correspondent
KARACHI, Oct. 15 -- Pakistan has approved construction of the $4-5 billion coastal refinery project at Khalifa Point near the Hub area of Balochistan province. Ashfaq Hassan Khan, a briefing adviser to the finance ministry, said preliminary work has begun on the refinery, which will have a capacity of 200,000-300,000 b/d.
The facility would be established as a 74:26 joint venture of Abu Dhabi-based International Petroleum Investment Co. (IPIC) and Pak-Arab Refinery Co. The project is expected to be completed and commissioned by first quarter 2011.
The Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Resources was authorized to sign the implementation agreement with IPIC within a month. Various concessions had been announced for the project, including a 20-year tax holiday, exemption from 5% workers' profit participation, and exemption from 0.5% services charges under the export processing zones rules.
Pakistan also advises Oil & Gas Development Corp. to dedicate at least 80% of the liquefied petroleum gas produced from Chanda field for distribution in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas of northern Pakistan."
https://www.ogj.com/articles/2007/10/pakistan-approves-khalifa-point-refinery-near-hub.html
That was 11 years ago and the construction has not yet even started. ???
A 900 K bpd refinery would cost in excess of $10-billion, no one invests this much money without through feasibility analysis. I would, therefore, dismiss such speculative statements as ‘flights of fancy’ especially when the Saudi delegation has come mainly to investigate the possibilities.
GOP has asked the Saudis to defer payment for 200K bbl per day crude for 3 months it is a ‘Boon’ because this means we would increase our reserves about $1.5- billion. We should be truly thankful if Saudis agree to this request.