Salman Khurshid 'thrown out' from Islam for worshipping Lord Ram

[Pakistani E]

Do South Asians not have anything important to discuss? Like how to combat poverty? Or how to provide fresh and clean water for our populations? What a waste of 24 hours of discussion this thread has been.

 

[prashantazazel]

than he should not call himself Muslim either.

He can, that's the beauty of secularism.

 

[Yaseen1]

Define success ?

success is a name of satisfaction which is not achieved through money and luxury but I am always satisfied and feel comfortable in real sense by implementing Islamic teachings

 

[SALMAN F]

worship and respect are two different things, but in any case, no one can tell you if u r out of islam or not. That matter is between a human and God.

He can't pay respect to an idol also because it's kuffr unless he was forced to this when taqqyyia come

 

[Signalian]

He can't pay respect to an idol also because it's kuffr unless he was forced to this when taqqyyia come

You are going in a loop of respect-worship again. Worshipping any other than God is kufar.

 

[Zulfiqar1919]

Idol worship is for small minded people

 

[Bombaywalla]

he has ruined his life after death will burn in hell forever

LOL

I love how you lot actually believe in what is essentially a 1400+ year-old fairy tale!

Bravo!

 

[Yaseen1]

and you hindus also believe in 1400+ years old religion

LOL

I love how you lot actually believe in what is essentially a 1400+ year-old fairy tale!

Bravo!

 

[Bombaywalla]

and you hindus also believe in 1400+ years old religion

Indian = Hindu in your opinion? How pakistani of you!

 

[zip]

success is a name of satisfaction which is not achieved through money and luxury but I am always satisfied and feel comfortable in real sense by implementing Islamic teachings

How do you know that there are no other way to feel comfortable ?

 

[t_for_talli]

And Shirk is Haram.

I thought India boost about freedom of religion is true. But it seems it is otherwise as the poor man has to do that act to show his patriotism. Too bad. Allah knows best.

No body forced him to worship idol,

only people who are not allowing freedom of religion are the one who claim to have thrown him out,

Kaun hai ye Islam ke Thekedar, Its for Salman to decide whether he is Muslim or not and not some random mulla

Its his personal matter, he can worship idol and still be Muslim, Constitution has given him right to chose his religious belief

 

[Brahmarshi]

Welcome to Dharmic Religion Mr. khurshid.

Good to see now we will have Irani Hindu community just like Zoroastrian Irani Migrants.

(Assuming khurshid denotes that his ancestors migrated from Iran)

 

[t_for_talli]

Islam has clear definitions of what makes someone a Muslim. This definition is based on the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and are based on international scholarly concensus and have done for 1400 years.

Religion is a personal matter,
Its for Individual to decide whether he is Muslim or Christian or Hindu

No Book , No messenger , No third person like you is entitled to make that decision

 

[Yaseen1]

because islam emphasize firm believe in most powerful and only GOD ALLAH ALMIGHTY in most purest form and you can feel comfort yourself if you enter Islam.other religions are not in their pure form and have diluted concept of GOD which results in to lack of feeling of support from GOD and they solely depend on their own effort and trust the apparent objects of this world and have less expectation of GOD help

How do you know that there are no other way to feel comfortable ?

 

[t_for_talli]

The Orthodox Sunni Muslims can decide who are heretics according to the Qur'an and the Sunnah.

The Muslim authorities can decide this.

Who the hell are you to tell us what we can and cannot do?

NO
Religion is a personal matter,
Its for Individual to decide whether he is Muslim or Christian or Hindu

No Book , No messenger, No Authority , No third person like you is entitled to make that decision

Who the hell are you to tell us what we can and cannot do?

Yes exactly, you said the right thing

Who the hell are you to decide whether he is Muslim or not
Who the hell are authorities to decide whether he is Muslim or not
Who the hell are Mullahs to decide whether he is Muslim or not

Its only Salmans decision whether he is Muslim or not , and his wish to worship idol