You said two things that I found interesting.
First, you claim that Shoaib is a 1 night work. i.e. he plays good in only a few games.
However, statistics prove otherwise.
Secondly, you claim that it's best to compare players head to head. i.e. Shoaib vs Sachin.
It's hard to find statistics on that and I was unable to find such statistics. But if it helps, in the games that Shoaib played, Sachin averages 41.6 (in tests). In ODIs, it's back to his normal average of 45, but nothing outstanding like Indians suggest.
Now as far as your argument is concerned, what you were doing was misrepresenting what I was saying and attacking the misrepresented position. If you thought I should look at other posts that you wrote, you should say that.