What's new

Russia Competes With China for Arms Sales to Pakistan

pakistani-jets-700x420.jpg

Pakistani fighter jets perform during the Pakistan Day parade in Islamabad on March 23, 2019. (Farooq Naeem/AFP/Getty Images)
Russia Competes With China for Arms Sales to Pakistan
BY FRANK FANG, EPOCH TIMES
April 18, 2019 Updated: April 18, 2019

For years, Beijing has been the biggest arms supplier to Islamabad, with defense purchases as a key element of their close ties. Now, Russia is looking to make inroads into the Pakistani weapons market.

Russian news agency RIA Novosti reported on April 15 that Pakistan has expressed interest in making a huge purchase of Russian military hardware, citing comments from Konstantin Makienko, deputy director of the Moscow-based defense think tank Center for Analysis of Strategies and Technologies.

The total invoice could top $9 billion, according to Makienko, who added that Pakistan would likely purchase Russian heavy and medium fighter jets, medium and short-range air defense systems, combat helicopters, tanks, and warships.

Makienko named two types of Russian military hardware that would likely be on Islamabad’s shopping list: the new Russian fighter jet MiG-35 and the heavy transport helicopter Mi-26T2.

Pakistani authorities haven’t confirmed this planned purchase, nor have Pakistani media reported on it thus far.

But Makienko noted that given the low-competitive nature of the military market in Pakistan, which is dominated by China, Russia would likely receive extremely favorable terms on the purchase contracts.

He added that Pakistan has not made requests such as technology transfer or localization of production as terms for any purchases.

China supplied weapons worth over $6.4 billion to Pakistan from 2008 to 2018, making it Pakistan’s biggest supplier, according to data from the independent arms research institute SIPRI (Stockholm International Peace Research Institute), followed by the United States with $2.5 billion, and Italy with $471 million worth of weapons.

Currently, Chinese-made jets make up the bulk of Pakistan’s fleet of fighter jets: the Chengdu J-7, and JF-17 Thunder. The former was modeled after the Russian jet MiG-21, while the latter was developed jointly by the Pakistani state-owned aerospace company Pakistan Aeronautical Complex (PAC) and China’s state-owned Chengdu Aircraft Corp.

In 2016, one of the biggest arms deals between China and Pakistan was signed, with the sale of eight Chinese diesel-electric attack submarines manufactured by state-run China Shipbuilding Trading Corporation, to be delivered to the Pakistan Navy by 2028, according to Pakistan’s English-language newspaper The Express Tribune.

Aside from arms sales, there have been other recent signs that Russia and Pakistan plan to enhance their military ties.

On March 24, Russia’s Federal News Agency (FAN) reported comments by Pakistani Major General Asif Ghafoor about expanding defense cooperation between Moscow and Islamabad. Ghafoor said that there could be more military contracts between the two countries, as Pakistan had just received its orders of Russian attack helicopters Mi-35, a purchase made in 2015.

A week later, on March 30, unnamed senior officials at Pakistan’s foreign ministry told local English-language daily newspaper The Nation that Islamabad and Moscow had agreed to exchange high-level visits more frequently, with defense being the main component of growing ties between the two countries.

Russia and China are competing for customers for their military equipment worldwide. Russian news agency TASS, in an editorial published on March 29, noted that China was a market competitor in the sale of submarines, citing the case of Thailand’s navy choosing to buy submarines from China over shipbuilders in Russia, South Korea, and Germany.

Thailand’s English-language daily The Nation, reported in March 2017 that Thai Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha confirmed the purchase of three submarines from China—but that the country only paid for two, since the third one would be a “free gift.”

In September 2018, South China Morning Post reported that Thailand dropped the number of submarines purchased to one, after local politicians opposed the deal for its high financial burden.

TASS stated that China’s state-run China Shipbuilding Industry Corp. (CSIC) recently announced that at least eight countries were interested in buying its submarines, including Algeria, Cuba, and Venezuela—news that “is unlikely to be joyful for Russian shipbuilders.”
 
.
pakistani-jets-700x420.jpg

Pakistani fighter jets perform during the Pakistan Day parade in Islamabad on March 23, 2019. (Farooq Naeem/AFP/Getty Images)
Russia Competes With China for Arms Sales to Pakistan
BY FRANK FANG, EPOCH TIMES
April 18, 2019 Updated: April 18, 2019
Share
reported on April 15 that Pakistan has expressed interest in making a huge purchase of Russian military hardware, citing comments from Konstantin Makienko, deputy director of the Moscow-based defense think tank Center for Analysis of Strategies and Technologies.

The total invoice could top $9 billion, according to Makienko, who added that Pakistan would likely purchase Russian heavy and medium fighter jets, medium and short-range air defense systems, combat helicopters, tanks, and warships.

Makienko named two types of Russian military hardware that would likely be on Islamabad’s shopping list: the new Russian fighter jet MiG-35 and the heavy transport helicopter Mi-26T2.

Pakistani authorities haven’t confirmed this planned purchase, nor have Pakistani media reported on it thus far.


But Makienko noted that given the low-competitive nature of the military market in Pakistan, which is dominated by China, Russia would likely receive extremely favorable terms on the purchase contracts.

He added that Pakistan has not made requests such as technology transfer or localization of production as terms for any purchases.

China supplied weapons worth over $6.4 billion to Pakistan from 2008 to 2018, making it Pakistan’s biggest supplier, according to data from the independent arms research institute SIPRI (Stockholm International Peace Research Institute), followed by the United States with $2.5 billion, and Italy with $471 million worth of weapons.

Currently, Chinese-made jets make up the bulk of Pakistan’s fleet of fighter jets: the Chengdu J-7, and JF-17 Thunder. The former was modeled after the Russian jet MiG-21, while the latter was developed jointly by the Pakistani state-owned aerospace company Pakistan Aeronautical Complex (PAC) and China’s state-owned Chengdu Aircraft Corp.

In 2016, one of the biggest arms deals between China and Pakistan was signed, with the sale of eight Chinese diesel-electric attack submarines manufactured by state-run China Shipbuilding Trading Corporation, to be delivered to the Pakistan Navy by 2028, according to Pakistan’s English-language newspaper The Express Tribune.

Aside from arms sales, there have been other recent signs that Russia and Pakistan plan to enhance their military ties.

On March 24, Russia’s Federal News Agency (FAN) reported comments by Pakistani Major General Asif Ghafoor about expanding defense cooperation between Moscow and Islamabad. Ghafoor said that there could be more military contracts between the two countries, as Pakistan had just received its orders of Russian attack helicopters Mi-35, a purchase made in 2015.

A week later, on March 30, unnamed senior officials at Pakistan’s foreign ministry told local English-language daily newspaper The Nation that Islamabad and Moscow had agreed to exchange high-level visits more frequently, with defense being the main component of growing ties between the two countries.

Russia and China are competing for customers for their military equipment worldwide. Russian news agency TASS, in an editorial published on March 29, noted that China was a market competitor in the sale of submarines, citing the case of Thailand’s navy choosing to buy submarines from China over shipbuilders in Russia, South Korea, and Germany.

Thailand’s English-language daily The Nation, reported in March 2017 that Thai Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha confirmed the purchase of three submarines from China—but that the country only paid for two, since the third one would be a “free gift.”

In September 2018, South China Morning Post reported that Thailand dropped the number of submarines purchased to one, after local politicians opposed the deal for its high financial burden.

TASS stated that China’s state-run China Shipbuilding Industry Corp. (CSIC) recently announced that at least eight countries were interested in buying its submarines, including Algeria, Cuba, and Venezuela—news that “is unlikely to be joyful for Russian shipbuilders.”

https://www.theepochtimes.com/russia-competes-with-china-for-arms-sales-to-pakistan_2885710.html
 
. .
The total invoice could top $9 billion, according to Makienko, who added that Pakistan would likely purchase Russian heavy and medium fighter jets, medium and short-range air defense systems, combat helicopters, tanks, and warships.

What the heck Pakistan Army?? He added that Pakistan has not made requests such as technology transfer or localization of production as terms for any purchases.


China supplied weapons worth over $6.4 billion to Pakistan from 2008 to 2018, making it Pakistan’s biggest supplier, according to data from the independent arms research institute SIPRI (Stockholm International Peace Research Institute), followed by the United States with $2.5 billion, and Italy with $471 million worth of weapons.
 
.
The total invoice could top $9 billion, according to Makienko, who added that Pakistan would likely purchase Russian heavy and medium fighter jets, medium and short-range air defense systems, combat helicopters, tanks, and warships.

What the heck Pakistan Army?? He added that Pakistan has not made requests such as technology transfer or localization of production as terms for any purchases.


China supplied weapons worth over $6.4 billion to Pakistan from 2008 to 2018, making it Pakistan’s biggest supplier, according to data from the independent arms research institute SIPRI (Stockholm International Peace Research Institute), followed by the United States with $2.5 billion, and Italy with $471 million worth of weapons.
What the heck on what ???
 
.
the new Russian fighter jet MiG-35 and the heavy transport helicopter Mi-26T2
both systems mention in the article seems highly improbable for Pakistan specially Mi-26T
 
. . .
Major B.S, why would Pakistan want Mig-35? Same engine as JF-17? Didn’t Russia offered mig-29 ten years ago?

If we are going for any deal, I would say No less than SU-35 and S-400
 
.
The timing of this report is suspicious... I don't it is true or the motivation behind revealing this info..
both systems mention in the article seems highly improbable for Pakistan specially Mi-26T
bhai reason? may be we will get Augusta westland 139?
I personally think MiG 35 may be a better option than Su35 because of the AESA radar and relatively smaller size but I'm not sure about its performance. It uses RD33MK engine which is similar to RD93. I guess Egypt bought 24 of them ...
 
Last edited:
.
That is almost out total foreign reserves with state bank. That part makes the article dubious.
this is indicating the long term program for next 10+ years for defence expenditures/acquisition and Russians would probably asked to participate in competitive tenders against Chinese offers as indicated by the following
Pakistani authorities haven’t confirmed this planned purchase, nor have Pakistani media reported on it thus far.

But Makienko noted that given the low-competitive nature of the military market in Pakistan, which is dominated by China, Russia would likely receive extremely favorable terms on the purchase contracts.
 
.
some how I believe Pakistan is not going to buy high price stuff from Russia any time soon. simple reason is Pakistan is broke and -ve political influence on russia is big from india. lastly, Pakistan do not buy for the sake of buying, there history dictates that Pakistan go for items that give them edge today and tomorrow.
 
.
bhai reason? may be we will get Augusta westland 139?
no its a heavy lift helicopter which very expensive to operate and maintain and might not be an efficient operable helicopter to many of our high mountainous region like northern area and tribal belt due to service ceiling limitations
 
.
no its a heavy lift helicopter which very expensive to operate and maintain and might not be an efficient operable helicopter to many of our high mountainous region like northern area and tribal belt due to service ceiling limitations
I see.

Personally I want to see an indigenous facility to produce rotary and fixed wing transport and passenger airplanes either through TOT or JV. Russia has pretty good products in this class especially the rotary ones like Mi35, Mi28, Mi17 etc... We should think about long term and sustainable acquisitions. Buying off the shelf as a knee jerk reaction to the situation shows our lack of vision.
 
Last edited:
.
Healthy competition is good

Unlike US regime
 
.
Back
Top Bottom