RSS body seeks genetic tests to prove Indian Muslims are Hindus

[SQ8]

Somehow I am not sure what is the purpose of this attempt ? Yes, there are a lot of Hindu converts from the thousand year history of Islam in the subcontinent. There is Arab ancestry in many cases.. both from Arab settlers and local marriages. Just as there is Persian heritage as well.

I would think this may have to do with a future move to somehow start a campaign to forcefully convert Muslims later perhaps

 

[Jaanbaz]

even pakistani muslims have hindu ancestory, but pakistanis think their ancestors were turks, arabs etc.

Hello troll. Yes Most of Pakistanis were of Hindu and Buddhist ancestry. But many Pakistanis do have foreign origins. For example Baluchis have nothing to do with other Indians like you. They are a Iranic people, Pushtuns have nothing to do with say Gujarati or Bihari babu.

I would think this may have to do with a future move to somehow start a campaign to forcefully convert Muslims later perhaps

The Spanish inquisition successfully forced most of Muslims to convert to Christianity, the rest were expelled. Maybe our Hindutva trolls across the border are thinking along the same lines.

 

[SrNair]

Sorry I should have been clearer. What I meant was that early followers of Vedic religions were foreigners. I was wrong on one point though, Vedic religion definitely started from Northern India not from outside.



What??? Islam is also a way of life not just a religion. I don't understand when Hindus say Hinduism is a way of life.



And who were they?



Is it available online?

AFAIK Islam have firm rules .Noone can uncompromise it.
But you cant see such a method in Hinduism.
According to the Manusmriti Yavanas was the son of Anu son of an Indian king.He and his followers was expelled from our subcontinentbbecause of their barbaric method.Another one was Kambojas ,I forgot theirs king name.Both of them were kshatriyas .But that book was also mentioned about the gradual invasion of both tribes in to India.At that time India was stretched from Gandhara (present Afghanistan) to Vanga desh (Bengal).

Sanskrit the Vedic language got language and disciplned base because of Panini.A saint lived in Khyber Paktun area nearer to Swat river.
I dont know .But I read some parts when I visited an old library.But you will get more info about Yavanas and Kambojs in internet.

 

[Jaanbaz]

AFAIK Islam have firm rules .Noone can uncompromise it.
But you cant see such a method in Hinduism.
According to the Manusmriti Yavanas was the son of Anu son of an Indian king.He and his followers was expelled from our subcontinentbbecause of their barbaric method.Another one was Kambojas ,I forgot theirs king name.Both of them were kshatriyas .But that book was also mentioned about the gradual invasion of both tribes in to India.At that time India was stretched from Gandhara (present Afghanistan) to Vanga desh (Bengal).

Sanskrit the Vedic language got language and disciplned base because of Panini.A saint lived in Khyber Paktun area nearer to Swat river.
I dont know .But I read some parts when I visited an old library.But you will get more info about Yavanas and Kambojs in internet.

Thanks for the info. I'm going to find out if there are any books available to buy on ancient history of India that fully answers my curiosity.

 

[Lord ZeN]

Sorry, I all ready said I was wrong to say Vedic religion came from outside. I meant the people who were following that particular religion were foreigners who then spread the religion into rest of India.

Central Asian concept of religion had an influence on Earlier form of proto- Vedic religion .. BUT vedic texts were written inside India & most of the Vedic Philosophers were Indic people & Indo- Aryan.. So it's a Made in India kind of Sub religion ( inside Hinduism ).. But again most of Pakistanis were Hindus not Vedic philosophers .. And i have no problem in people converting to other religions.. Nothing to be Ashamed/ Proud of ...

 

[SamantK]

Somehow I am not sure what is the purpose of this attempt ? Yes, there are a lot of Hindu converts from the thousand year history of Islam in the subcontinent. There is Arab ancestry in many cases.. both from Arab settlers and local marriages. Just as there is Persian heritage as well.

I would think this may have to do with a future move to somehow start a campaign to forcefully convert Muslims later perhaps

Obviously, don't you see the sinister design to go scientifically in proving it?

 

[Jaanbaz]

Central Asian concept of religion had an influence on Earlier form of proto- Vedic religion

But some Indians say the opposite.

 

[Kloitra]

Interesting. But Islam is also influenced by different cultures as it spread to different parts of the world. The reason why Hinduism is influenced by local cultures is simply because it is older religion.

In Hinduism there is no particular way you have to follow. There are strict vegetarians, there are meat eaters, you can follow a particular god, you can be atheist, there are all kind of flexibilities. A good example is diet - coastal Hindus are non-vegetarians while inland ones tend towards vegetarianism. Your religious practices are defined by local culture. I believe it is opposite in Islam, where religion is paramount compared to customs?

I would think this may have to do with a future move to somehow start a campaign to forcefully convert Muslims later perhaps

As if. That would be end of India as we know it!

 

[halupridol]

it seems these ppl have a lot of monet
they cud have estblish a new IIT or PGI,,,,,but seems priorities r different

 

[Kompromat]

Congratulations, Bharat now has Eugenics.

 

[SrNair]

Somehow I am not sure what is the purpose of this attempt ? Yes, there are a lot of Hindu converts from the thousand year history of Islam in the subcontinent. There is Arab ancestry in many cases.. both from Arab settlers and local marriages. Just as there is Persian heritage as well.

I would think this may have to do with a future move to somehow start a campaign to forcefully convert Muslims later perhaps

No .We dont need conversion tactics for the sustainability of Hinduism.In India a Muslim or Christian can become Hindus. .But vested interests using these foreign ancestry theory for creating tensions among communities.
That trends will bust once we prove that we have same bonds and blood.

 

[Jaanbaz]

Baluchis have nothing to do with pakistan also

A lot more then you think my little friend. Have you ever even talked to real life Baluchi before? There hundreds of thousands who live in Sindh and Punjab and like all Pakistanis they intermarry with other Pakistanis.

 

[RKO]

Another troll thread!!!

 

[Kompromat]

even pakistani muslims have hindu ancestory, but pakistanis think their ancestors were turks, arabs etc.

Our ancesstors were misguided who practiced a structure which made them slaves of fellow men and of dogmatic superstition, myths and folklore. Once we gave it up we created equity among men and treated our fellow mankind like equals.

 

[Kaniska]

What is to prove here?...Arab people did not come here to settle in India...So of course...Muslims in subcontient are converted Hindus....But if really RSS would like to go for this route, i would suggest rather than simply trying to prove that Muslims are converted...It should find why they are converted...If RSS is really serious about Hindu culture, rather than going behind the Muslims and their conversion, they should focous on how can caste system and the untouchability and inequality that is prevalent in Hindu religion to be eliminated...That will fetch them lot of respect rather than going behind why Muslims are converted....It is not a roclet science to understand than if you do not allow people to go inside the temple just because they are of lower caste, why will not they convert to any other religion they want?....So RSS should prioritize its goal.