Roots of the identity crisis in Pakistan

[ThunderCat]

Ancient India

That's like saying ancient Africa

Our land and people has very little to do with people in ganga land

Before the European colonization, India means land of the Indus.

 

[Kuru]

Yeah but their was NO ancient India,, it's was just our people in Pakistan

You can literally see the map where the earliest human civilizations formed

If you had to describe them as todays countries it's China, Pakistan, Iraq and Egypt

Ofcourse, that's the modern term and will be described as such.

I'm talking about Ancient India though. Anything that happened in Ancient India belongs to Ancient Indians. That includes your ancestors too. No one can take that away from you.

 

[hussain0216]

Ofcourse, that's the modern term and will be described as such.

I'm talking about Ancient India though. Anything that happened in Ancient India belongs to Ancient Indians. That includes your ancestors too. No one can take that away from you.

What ancient India???????

If by ancient India you mean Pakistan, then that is ONLY for our people in Pakistan

What does it have to do with indians today?

Your no different to a African claiming Egypt because its in Africa

 

[Kuru]

What ancient India???????

If by ancient India you mean Pakistan, then that is ONLY for our people in Pakistan

What does it have to do with indians today?

Your no different to a African claiming Egypt because its in Africa

Philippines is in Asia, we don’t claim that. Japan is also in Asia, we don’t claim that either. It’s only Ancient India we claim, and rightly so.

 

[Menace2Society]

Yes it does mean that.
Different parts of this country had different things. Point is, all was done by ancient Indians.

There is no such thing as Ancient India.

During the time of that map you were australoid monkeys living in jungles. There is only ancient Pakistan.

 

[AA_]

Modern, contemporary Indians have agenda to lump us together as one so they can leech off our history and claim part ownership.

The ultra-liberal Pakistani writes these articles as a passive aggressive way to hate on Islam and Muslims.

Not a single Pakistani I know claims this.

The Indian here uses reverse psychology as a coping mechanism to justify why the average Pakistani distances himself from the average Indian. The Indian being inferiority complex creature has to save face and create non stop posts across various social media that Pakistanis consider themselves “Arabs” as a way to justify their repeated attempts to capture our history.

 

[Kuru]

There is no such thing as Ancient India.

During the time of that map you were australoid monkeys living in jungles. There is only ancient Pakistan.

Sure. Seems Dawn doesn’t know it yet.

The Republic of India, which emerged after the Partition of British India, embraced its ancient Indian heritage, becoming the visible successor of Ancient India.

 

[Maula Jatt]

@Kuru tu Kitna faarigh hai re?

 

[BamsiBey]

Root cause of identity crisis in Pakistan: Political instability, social injustice, lack of law and order.

Because of political instability, Pakistanis never got to rally around and celebrate its national hero's. Be it Qaid, Fatima Jinnah, Bhutto, AQ khan, and even IK now.

Talented, educated, hardworking people never make it to the top because of social Injustice.

 

[hussain0216]

Philippines is in Asia, we don’t claim that. Japan is also in Asia, we don’t claim that either. It’s only Ancient India we claim, and rightly so.

Someone said it above your trying to leech off Pakistani history, the history of our land and our people

 

[Kuru]

Someone said it above your trying to leech off Pakistani history, the history of our land and our people

Nothing to leech here. People call it Ancient India. Also provided a link from your own newspapers.

Denying the history could also be a cause of identity crisis. Just saying.

 

[ThunderCat]

There is no such thing as Ancient India.

During the time of that map you were australoid monkeys living in jungles. There is only ancient Pakistan.

Ancient India was in Pakistan and not the country that appropriated the name.

The ultra-liberal Pakistani writes these articles as a passive aggressive way to hate on Islam and Muslims.

Those are elite class Muhajirs with their typical pro-Indian agenda. The identity crisis can be seen as theirs.

 

[surmabhopali]

which pakistanis are these ?

They are Hashmi, Siddiki , khwaza, mirrza , irani , arabi ,saiyyad, fatmi, barni, and many more names imply they are from outside of pakistan .

 

[SaadH]

May be it is. But then again, I find people here claiming to have ruled India, so this is for them. Someone needs to show them the reality.

Whaaat? So Muslims starting from Dehli Sultanate and then Mughal empire and countless other smaller fiedoms didn't rule India. And people living in Pakistan don't any connection to people who at one point ruled India?

This is some next level super gobar powered hindutva revisionist history...

 

[Kuru]

And people living in Pakistan don't any connection to people who at one point ruled India?

You tell me.