Banglar Bir
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2006
- Messages
- 7,805
- Reaction score
- -3
- Country
- Location
UN steps up pressure on Myanmar
Larry Jagan, November 9, 2017
UN Headquarters
The United Nations is stepping up pressure on Myanmar to rapidly resolve the violence in its strife-torn western province of Rakhine.
In a Presidential Statement, released after the UN Security Council discussed the situation in Myanmar at length, the UN condemned the communal violence, demanded that Myanmar end the excessive of military force, and urged the authorities to allow the thousands of refugees who have fled to neighbouring Bangladesh to return as quickly as possible.
Adopted unanimously by the 15-member UN body, the statement avoided the threat sanctions if the situation did not improve, it left Myanmar in no doubt that more is to come if serious measures are not taken soon to resolve the inter-communal violence, reign in the military, respect human rights “without discrimination and regardless of ethnicity or religion, including by allowing freedom of movement, equal access to basic services and equal access to full citizenship for all individuals.”
Also Read: Myanmar warns U.N. pressure could harm talks with Bangladesh
Although the UN Security Council stopped short of adopting a strongly worded resolution sponsored by Britain and France and strongly supported by the Muslim countries of the OIC, in deference to Beijing and Moscow’s threat to veto it, the UN is definitely turning up the heat on Myanmar.
In their statement they suggested that the UN Secretary General consider appointing a Special Adviser on Myanmar – something which the UN had previously, but ended last year at the Myanmar government’s request. The UN Security Council gave formal notice that it would be on the agenda in a month’s time, at which the UN chief Antonio Guterresis to report back on developments.
Myanmar protested that the statement did not sufficiently acknowledge the complexity of the problems in Myanmar and was tantamount to interference. It was based on accusations and false claims of evidence, complained Myanmar’s ambassador to the UN, Hau Do Suan. “It exerts undue political pressure on Myanmar,” he said. “And it fails to give sufficient recognition to the government of Myanmar for its efforts to address the challenges in Rakhine State.”
Nonetheless, the statement still represents the strongest council pronouncement on Myanmar in nearly ten years, and reflects widespread international concern at the plight of the Muslim Rohingya, who face official and social discrimination in this Buddhist-majority country. The sponsors of the resolution see this a first step, and believe the ball is now firmly in Naypyidaw’s court.
Also Read: Tillerson’s Myanmar visit shows Trump’s renewed interest in South-East Asia
The UN also condemned the attacks by the insurgent Arakan Rohingya Solidarity Army (ARSA) some nine weeks ago, which sparked the latest violence in Rakhine, which led to the exodus of nearly 700,000 Muslims across the border, alleging the systematic killing, sexual violence and the deliberate destruction of homes by the Myanmar military. For its part, the army denies these allegations and blames the Muslim militants for the carnage.
However, the UN – after a series of investigations since the first ARSA attacks last October – accused Myanmar’s military of ethnic cleansing.
The Rohingya have faced decades of discrimination in Buddhist-majority Myanmar. They are not recognized by Myanmar’s government as an ethnic group, which insists they are Bengali migrants from Bangladesh living illegally in the country. They have been denied citizenship since 1982, which has effectively rendered them stateless.
The statement also stressed the importance of transparent investigations into allegations of human rights abuses and “in this regard, the Security Council calls upon the Government of Myanmar to cooperate with all relevant United Nations bodies, mechanisms and instruments.” Myanmar has refused to allow a UN fact-finding mission, set up the UN human rights council in March to investigate all allegations of abuses after a smaller military counteroffensive launched in October 2016, and is likely to also investigate the current outbreak of violence.
Also Read: US lawmakers seek to slap new sanctions on Myanmar military
Myanmar’s de facto leader, Aung San Suu Kyi, has pledged accountability for rights abuses and insists all refugees who can prove they were residents of Myanmar will be accepted back. The military have also set up their own inquiry into the army’s conduct in Rakhine since the latest violence erupted in late August which far from convincing, and failed to bring any soldiers to book for the allegations of human rights abuses at the time.
Aung San Suu Kyi has insisted that Myanmar did not need further UN enquiries as they were investigating these allegations of abuse internally. More importantly she pointed to the Kofi Annan advisory commission on Rakhine State – appointed more than a year ago – to suggest solutions to the problems of Rakhine. They submitted their recommendations in August, a day before the ARSA launched their attacks on more than twenty border guard posts, leaving more than a hundred dead.
Since then the recommendations have become the blueprint for reconciliation in Rakhine. Foreign leaders in the region and international diplomats often cite the Commission’s report and recommendations as providing an important way forward. It led to the establishment of the Union enterprise for humanitarian assistance, resettlement and development in Rakhine, with Aung San Suu Kyi’ at the helm to oversee their implementation.
The UN referred to both matters in the presidential statement. But they warned that all UN agencies that are providing humanitarian assistance to the refugees, and those involved in their repatriation and resettlement should be given full access.
It “urged the Governments and all humanitarian partners to pay special attention to the needs of women, particularly survivors of sexual violence.” Similarly, while welcoming Myanmar’s public commitment to implement the recommendations of the Advisory Commission, it urged “all parts of the Government of Myanmar to work together to implement these recommendations swiftly and in full.”
Also Read: Myanmar’s Suu Kyi ‘urges people not to quarrel’ on visit to Rakhine
So, the UN has certainly stepped up its involvement in seeing Myanmar resolve the problems in Rakhine state. While UN sanctions are not on the table, it does not preclude individual countries from taking further action. Several Western countries have adopted travel bans on Myanmar’s military leaders, with further measures being considered.
Myanmar’s problems will also feature prominently on other international arenas in the coming days. Once again ASEAN – with its annual meeting about to start in Manila — will also focus on the violence in Myanmar’s Rakhine state and the mass exodus of Muslim refugees. The plight of the Rohingya refugees is also expected to top the discussions when the US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson visits Myanmar later this month.
RELATED ARTICLES MORE FROM AUTHOR
MYANMAR
Lack of UN pressure on Myanmar encourages further attacks on Rohingyas
MYANMAR
Myanmar warns U.N. pressure could harm talks with Bangladesh
ISSUES
Tillerson’s Myanmar visit shows Trump’s renewed interest in South-East Asia
https://southasianmonitor.com/2017/11/09/un-steps-pressure-myanmar/
Larry Jagan, November 9, 2017
UN Headquarters
The United Nations is stepping up pressure on Myanmar to rapidly resolve the violence in its strife-torn western province of Rakhine.
In a Presidential Statement, released after the UN Security Council discussed the situation in Myanmar at length, the UN condemned the communal violence, demanded that Myanmar end the excessive of military force, and urged the authorities to allow the thousands of refugees who have fled to neighbouring Bangladesh to return as quickly as possible.
Adopted unanimously by the 15-member UN body, the statement avoided the threat sanctions if the situation did not improve, it left Myanmar in no doubt that more is to come if serious measures are not taken soon to resolve the inter-communal violence, reign in the military, respect human rights “without discrimination and regardless of ethnicity or religion, including by allowing freedom of movement, equal access to basic services and equal access to full citizenship for all individuals.”
Also Read: Myanmar warns U.N. pressure could harm talks with Bangladesh
Although the UN Security Council stopped short of adopting a strongly worded resolution sponsored by Britain and France and strongly supported by the Muslim countries of the OIC, in deference to Beijing and Moscow’s threat to veto it, the UN is definitely turning up the heat on Myanmar.
In their statement they suggested that the UN Secretary General consider appointing a Special Adviser on Myanmar – something which the UN had previously, but ended last year at the Myanmar government’s request. The UN Security Council gave formal notice that it would be on the agenda in a month’s time, at which the UN chief Antonio Guterresis to report back on developments.
Myanmar protested that the statement did not sufficiently acknowledge the complexity of the problems in Myanmar and was tantamount to interference. It was based on accusations and false claims of evidence, complained Myanmar’s ambassador to the UN, Hau Do Suan. “It exerts undue political pressure on Myanmar,” he said. “And it fails to give sufficient recognition to the government of Myanmar for its efforts to address the challenges in Rakhine State.”
Nonetheless, the statement still represents the strongest council pronouncement on Myanmar in nearly ten years, and reflects widespread international concern at the plight of the Muslim Rohingya, who face official and social discrimination in this Buddhist-majority country. The sponsors of the resolution see this a first step, and believe the ball is now firmly in Naypyidaw’s court.
Also Read: Tillerson’s Myanmar visit shows Trump’s renewed interest in South-East Asia
The UN also condemned the attacks by the insurgent Arakan Rohingya Solidarity Army (ARSA) some nine weeks ago, which sparked the latest violence in Rakhine, which led to the exodus of nearly 700,000 Muslims across the border, alleging the systematic killing, sexual violence and the deliberate destruction of homes by the Myanmar military. For its part, the army denies these allegations and blames the Muslim militants for the carnage.
However, the UN – after a series of investigations since the first ARSA attacks last October – accused Myanmar’s military of ethnic cleansing.
The Rohingya have faced decades of discrimination in Buddhist-majority Myanmar. They are not recognized by Myanmar’s government as an ethnic group, which insists they are Bengali migrants from Bangladesh living illegally in the country. They have been denied citizenship since 1982, which has effectively rendered them stateless.
The statement also stressed the importance of transparent investigations into allegations of human rights abuses and “in this regard, the Security Council calls upon the Government of Myanmar to cooperate with all relevant United Nations bodies, mechanisms and instruments.” Myanmar has refused to allow a UN fact-finding mission, set up the UN human rights council in March to investigate all allegations of abuses after a smaller military counteroffensive launched in October 2016, and is likely to also investigate the current outbreak of violence.
Also Read: US lawmakers seek to slap new sanctions on Myanmar military
Myanmar’s de facto leader, Aung San Suu Kyi, has pledged accountability for rights abuses and insists all refugees who can prove they were residents of Myanmar will be accepted back. The military have also set up their own inquiry into the army’s conduct in Rakhine since the latest violence erupted in late August which far from convincing, and failed to bring any soldiers to book for the allegations of human rights abuses at the time.
Aung San Suu Kyi has insisted that Myanmar did not need further UN enquiries as they were investigating these allegations of abuse internally. More importantly she pointed to the Kofi Annan advisory commission on Rakhine State – appointed more than a year ago – to suggest solutions to the problems of Rakhine. They submitted their recommendations in August, a day before the ARSA launched their attacks on more than twenty border guard posts, leaving more than a hundred dead.
Since then the recommendations have become the blueprint for reconciliation in Rakhine. Foreign leaders in the region and international diplomats often cite the Commission’s report and recommendations as providing an important way forward. It led to the establishment of the Union enterprise for humanitarian assistance, resettlement and development in Rakhine, with Aung San Suu Kyi’ at the helm to oversee their implementation.
The UN referred to both matters in the presidential statement. But they warned that all UN agencies that are providing humanitarian assistance to the refugees, and those involved in their repatriation and resettlement should be given full access.
It “urged the Governments and all humanitarian partners to pay special attention to the needs of women, particularly survivors of sexual violence.” Similarly, while welcoming Myanmar’s public commitment to implement the recommendations of the Advisory Commission, it urged “all parts of the Government of Myanmar to work together to implement these recommendations swiftly and in full.”
Also Read: Myanmar’s Suu Kyi ‘urges people not to quarrel’ on visit to Rakhine
So, the UN has certainly stepped up its involvement in seeing Myanmar resolve the problems in Rakhine state. While UN sanctions are not on the table, it does not preclude individual countries from taking further action. Several Western countries have adopted travel bans on Myanmar’s military leaders, with further measures being considered.
Myanmar’s problems will also feature prominently on other international arenas in the coming days. Once again ASEAN – with its annual meeting about to start in Manila — will also focus on the violence in Myanmar’s Rakhine state and the mass exodus of Muslim refugees. The plight of the Rohingya refugees is also expected to top the discussions when the US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson visits Myanmar later this month.
RELATED ARTICLES MORE FROM AUTHOR
MYANMAR
Lack of UN pressure on Myanmar encourages further attacks on Rohingyas
MYANMAR
Myanmar warns U.N. pressure could harm talks with Bangladesh
ISSUES
Tillerson’s Myanmar visit shows Trump’s renewed interest in South-East Asia
https://southasianmonitor.com/2017/11/09/un-steps-pressure-myanmar/