What's new

Refugee Crisis Brews in Pakistan

Flintlock

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Oct 7, 2007
Messages
6,176
Reaction score
0
Refugee crisis brews in Pakistan
By Kamran Rehmat in Islamabad

Pakistani refugees, displaced by fighting in the tribal north, receive aid provided by the Afghan Red Crescent Society in Ali Sher district of Khost province, Afghanistan [AP]

News of clashes in Pakistan's tribal areas and the fate of thousands of refugees fleeing the fighting have been overshadowed by the country's focus on Islamabad's growing power struggle.


The concerted campaign by the coalition government to remove Pervez Musharraf, the Pakistani president, from power has shifted focus from a developing humanitarian crisis in the north.

According to government estimates, some 219,000 have been displaced as the military and tribal fighters battle for territorial control following a string of failed peace agreements in the once-scenic Swat Valley and Bajaur Agency, a district of the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA).

Rehman Malik, the advisor to the prime minister on interior affairs, told the media that 462 "militants" and 22 security personnel have lost their lives in the ongoing military operations.

However, these figures do not quite reveal the catastrophic situation that is rapidly gnawing at the integrity of this South Asian nation.


Ostensibly, the Taliban is fighting to enforce Sharia (Islamic law) in the region but have shown no remorse in using the local population as a collective human shield against Pakistani military operations.

Mass exodus


The residents have been advised by the security forces to leave their homes and seek sanctuary.

"It is not easy to leave your home. We expected the army to supervise the evacuation, which is the least they could have done to provide some sort of security but it has not happened," Sher Afzal, a resident who escaped the fighting in Bajaur Agency, said.

Further compounding the mass exodus is the steady stream of refugees fleeing from the adjoining Mohmand Agency. They have sought shelter in Peshawar, the capital of the Frontier province, and in nearby Dir and Malakand.

The Frontier government has asked for immediate financial assistance of Rs1.5 billion ($19.7 million) to cope with such massive displacement.

"There are hundreds of thousands of people waiting for help and we don't have the wherewithal to cope with the situation," an official of the provincial government said.

This has created a bind for the security forces who were caught between using force to flush out "militants" or doing nothing and thereby saving the innocent population caught in the crossfire.

They chose the first option even at the risk of collateral damage; this resulted in a high number of civilian casualties.

But not taking on the Taliban, experts have agreed, was not a viable option given the proclivity of their fighters to assimilate into local populations and use the breathing space to re-launch attacks.

"We have two options: either to keep mum and hand over the country to [the] Taliban or take action," the interior advisor said.

Tearing the script

At least six Pakistani troops were killed and 15 others injured in clashes with the Taliban [AFP]
In Swat, the situation is as tense as ever. The provincial government has come under pressure for trying to return to a now defunct peace agreement with the tribal fighters.

"The peace agreement signed in May is intact and the government is ready to hold negotiations to end unrest," Bashir Bilour, the senior minister and head of the government's peace committee, said.

But he also conceded the fighters had breached the pact.

The provincial government re-launched the military operation on July 29 after the Taliban-allied fighters threatened, but failed, to force the government to resign. They violated the peace accord by attacking security forces and torching girl schools.

More aid needed


But some tribesmen are now taking security affairs into their own hands, taking the fight to the Taliban-allied fighters and earning support from Islamabad.

The federal government announced an award of Rs500,000 (US$6,560) and a Kalashnikov rifle each for a few tribesman who had shot dead six fighters in Buner three days ago.

But Pakistanis are urging the government to at least apply the same anti-Taliban initiative to provide much needed shelter.

The provincial government has set up eight camps for the displaced, which the central government later upped statistically, by five more.

However, even these 13 camps are just not enough for the homeless.

A provincial government official, who did not want to be named, told Al Jazeera: "We are facing this situation because of the military action in the tribal region. It is therefore, the responsibility of the federal government to provide financial assistance."

Kamran Rehmat is a news editor with Dawn News, a Pakistani TV channel.

Al Jazeera English - Pakistan Power and politics - Refugee crisis brews in Pakistan
 
.
This is all the more reason to not back off this operation at this point until the areas are cleared out.

If the people return (after suffering all of this hardship and loss) and the militants reestablish themselves again because of 'peace deals', the GoP will lose all credibility and support from them.

1. Immediate relief in the form of camps, rations etc.

2. A sustained military operation, especially now that many of the people in the region have left.

3. Uplift programs and development in the affected areas once people are allowed to return.

There is unfortunately no alternative to this, because as the author points out:

"Ostensibly, the Taliban is fighting to enforce Sharia (Islamic law) in the region but have shown no remorse in using the local population as a collective human shield against Pakistani military operations."

and:

"But not taking on the Taliban, experts have agreed, was not a viable option given the proclivity of their fighters to assimilate into local populations and use the breathing space to re-launch attacks.

"We have two options: either to keep mum and hand over the country to [the] Taliban or take action," the interior advisor said."
 
Last edited:
.
Its not the so-called "militants" that are responsible for this refugee crisis, but, the Pakistani military. It is a disgrace and a shame . . . which other country would inflict so much collective punishment upon her own people for their own shortcomings !?

At the very least, the Pakistani government had a duty [to their own people] to ensure that there would be sufficient food, water and shelter available for people displaced by the military engagement . . . it should have been part of the planning and logistics. However, this is symptomatic of the general disregard for the affairs and interests of the Pakistani people that has been a hallmark of the failed political system in Islamabad.

The Pakistani people owe the military and political establishment in Islamabad nothing . . . they've been abused and killed for the dictates of an imperial power that wishes to see Pakistan dismantled and moulded to suit her hegemonic agenda . . . America will not pass.
 
.
MartialLaw this situation has Pakistani civilians killing Pakistani Civilians I fail to see how or why they need the US to do this.
 
.
Its not the so-called "militants" that are responsible for this refugee crisis, but, the Pakistani military. It is a disgrace and a shame . . . which other country would inflict so much collective punishment upon her own people for their own shortcomings !?

At the very least, the Pakistani government had a duty [to their own people] to ensure that there would be sufficient food, water and shelter available for people displaced by the military engagement . . . it should have been part of the planning and logistics. However, this is symptomatic of the general disregard for the affairs and interests of the Pakistani people that has been a hallmark of the failed political system in Islamabad.

The Pakistani people owe the military and political establishment in Islamabad nothing . . . they've been abused and killed for the dictates of an imperial power that wishes to see Pakistan dismantled and moulded to suit her hegemonic agenda . . . America will not pass.

Very nice speech. However it shows how clueless you are......

The guys fighting against the rule of law are using the civilians to hide behind and supply them with food and other supplies. The army has to target these areas in order to defeat the Militants. It's simple guerrilla warfare. the civilians don't want to be human shields for the Militants and are leaving (understandably).
Now if the Militants were not hiding behind the civilians there would not be a problem at all would there.........

I am sure there is a school you should be burning or women whose education you should be preventing. But occasionally do look up military tactics.
 
.
Its not the so-called "militants" that are responsible for this refugee crisis, but, the Pakistani military. It is a disgrace and a shame . . . which other country would inflict so much collective punishment upon her own people for their own shortcomings !?

At the very least, the Pakistani government had a duty [to their own people] to ensure that there would be sufficient food, water and shelter available for people displaced by the military engagement . . . it should have been part of the planning and logistics. However, this is symptomatic of the general disregard for the affairs and interests of the Pakistani people that has been a hallmark of the failed political system in Islamabad.

The Pakistani people owe the military and political establishment in Islamabad nothing . . . they've been abused and killed for the dictates of an imperial power that wishes to see Pakistan dismantled and moulded to suit her hegemonic agenda . . . America will not pass.



First of the headline is misleading they are Not Refugees. They are not moving to any other country rather they moved from one part of Pakistan to other part simple as that.


As debong said if Pakistan can host largest Refugees in the world we can also shelter our own people.

So trolls dont need to jump like monkeys in the first place.


Now coming to your point well your flag shows you are from UK right so you dont know a s.hit what is going on in my province so dont need to come up with an emotional statement without substance.


We fully support the current operation going on in Bajaur as this time Baitullah is holed up and Inshallah this mole of US/CIA/India going to be slaughterd like anything.


Your statement is nothing but a BS keeping view the killing of over 30 innoent partients in suicide blast in Tank DHQ hospital two days back.


Baitullah Mehsud TTP claimed the responsibility so stop supporting these terrorists.
 
.
Its unfortunate that senior members on this forum have to resort to abuse just because somebody else has taken a different view to them about the current military engagement in the tribal belt.

I am, also, a little amused that some posters allege that Baitullah is in the pay of the CIA/US government !?

Can you substantiate these allegations?!

Assuming you can substantiate your allegations [which I doubt] . . . shouldn't you, by the very same token and principle, object to the Pakistani military and the civilian government from receiving "US aid" - which, is just blood money for killing Pakistanis in the failed War On Terror. ??

The moral and intellectual veracity of the arguments being deployed in favour of Pakistani military engagement in the tribal belt is of a poor order and there is no popular support for it amongst Pakistanis . . . inside and outside of the country.

Stop perpetuating the American Raj and back Pakistan as an INDEPENDENT and credible nation on the international arena. No nation has ever achieved distinction and greatness by being the vassal of another !!
 
.
I think India and the US are responsible for this internal war in Pakistan. We should take actions rather sit and cry. Elimination of Indian sponsored terrorism is a must.
 
.
I think India and the US are responsible for this internal war in Pakistan. We should take actions rather sit and cry. Elimination of Indian sponsored terrorism is a must.


I agree that American+Indian elements need to be purged in Pakistan.

However, you seem to be ignoring the fact that Pakistans military top brass and the civilian political establishment regard Washington as the Holy Kaaba and they may daily tawaaf around it . . . to the extent that there is no aspect of Pakistani domestic and foreign policy that is immune from US influence!!

American influence is not amongst the militants, it doesn't need to be . . . Washington owns the Pakistani military top brass and the political system in Islamabad!!
 
.
First of the headline is misleading they are Not Refugees. They are not moving to any other country rather they moved from one part of Pakistan to other part simple as that.

As debong said if Pakistan can host largest Refugees in the world we can also shelter our own people.

So trolls dont need to jump like monkeys in the first place.

Now coming to your point well your flag shows you are from UK right so you dont know a s.hit what is going on in my province so dont need to come up with an emotional statement without substance.

We fully support the current operation going on in Bajaur as this time Baitullah is holed up and Inshallah this mole of US/CIA/India going to be slaughterd like anything.

Your statement is nothing but a BS keeping view the killing of over 30 innoent partients in suicide blast in Tank DHQ hospital two days back.

Baitullah Mehsud TTP claimed the responsibility so stop supporting these terrorists.

Jana Ji, please kill the message not the messenger. There's no need to fire personal shots. The rule applies to all of us.

Hope you understand.
 
.
The moral and intellectual veracity of the arguments being deployed in favour of Pakistani military engagement in the tribal belt is of a poor order and there is no popular support for it amongst Pakistanis . . . inside and outside of the country.

On the contrary, logical arguments have been advanced often in support of the action taken against militants - the only thing I have heard from you is 'stop bowing to American imperialism and killing your own people'. There is nothing to explain the failure of the militants to adhere to the peace deals that led to these operations, nor that the suicide bombings killing innocent people are being proudly proclaimed as their handiwork (60 dead in Wah Cantt as of now).

When it comes to 'popular opinion', let me also remind you that for the longest time the 'popular opinion' in the US was also in favor of slavery and segregation, despite the utter immorality of the position.

Support for these criminals amongst Pakistanis I chalk down to similar 'immoral' thinking, thinking that is akin to shoving ones head in the ground and hoping the threat miraculously vanishes.
 
.
On the contrary, logical arguments have been advanced often in support of the action taken against militants - the only thing I have heard from you is 'stop bowing to American imperialism and killing your own people'. There is nothing to explain the failure of the militants to adhere to the peace deals that led to these operations, nor that the suicide bombings killing innocent people are being proudly proclaimed as their handiwork (60 dead in Wah Cantt as of now).

When it comes to 'popular opinion', let me also remind you that for the longest time the 'popular opinion' in the US was also in favor of slavery and segregation, despite the utter immorality of the position.

Support for these criminals amongst Pakistanis I chalk down to similar 'immoral' thinking, thinking that is akin to shoving ones head in the ground and hoping the threat miraculously vanishes.


'Popular opinion' [in your view] amongst Pakistanis is 'immoral' !?

On what basis is it 'immoral' !?

Are the Pakistani people 'immoral' for resisting American imperialism that has killed over 100,000 muslims in Iraq and is looking to extend similar carnage into their country!?

Are they 'immoral' for supporting the implementation of the Sharia !?

Are they immoral because they do not share your secular view on Islam !?

Being agnostic, where do you get your 'morality' from !?

I think its incumbent upon people posting on these forums to not belittle the Pakistani people [who are PAKISTAN itself] for their devotion to Islam and its Sharia . . . its a source of strength and not of weakness.

I hope that your [future] posts carry some degree of respect for the Pakistani people and their religion . . . something that I notice has been, distinctly, absent of late.
 
.
'Popular opinion' [in your view] amongst Pakistanis is 'immoral' !?

On what basis is it 'immoral' !?

Are the Pakistani people 'immoral' for resisting American imperialism that has killed over 100,000 muslims in Iraq and is looking to extend similar carnage into their country!?

Are they 'immoral' for supporting the implementation of the Sharia !?

Are they immoral because they do not share your secular view on Islam !?

Being agnostic, where do you get your 'morality' from !?

I think its incumbent upon people posting on these forums to not belittle the Pakistani people [who are PAKISTAN itself] for their devotion to Islam and its Sharia . . . its a source of strength and not of weakness.

I hope that your [future] posts carry some degree of respect for the Pakistani people and their religion . . . something that I notice has been, distinctly, absent of late.

Popular opinion can be immoral, as it was in the case of support for slavery, as I pointed out. It should therefore not be a yardstick for determining what is 'right', though I understand that it constrains policy makers, especially in a democracy.

Pakistanis are being 'immoral' in supporting appeasement for a group of people who are carrying out suicide bombings, opposing education and equal rights for women, bombing and burning down schools, barber shops and other 'immoral businesses', and using force and fear to impose a perverted form of Islam upon those under their sway.

They are being immoral because the underlying cause for this appeasement is selfishness, that the rest of us in Pakistan will be left alone if we somehow let the militants do what they want in FATA and Swat. It is also driven by ignorance - the terrorists claim Shariah, and everyone simply imposes whatever their view of Shariah is (mostly a Utopian society, with justice and equality for all) on the Taliban demands, and thinks that such demands by the militants may not be all that bad.

However, the reality of the Talibans' 'Shariah', the reality of what we see happen everyday in FATA and Swat, and what happened in Afghanistan under the Taliban, is nothing short of returning to the dark ages. The Islamic world has suffered from such fossilization of thought and creativity for too long - this is the reason we have lagged behind the West in almost every parameter of civilization, and now these fans of the Neanderthals want to drag us back even further.
 
.
'Popular opinion' [in your view] amongst Pakistanis is 'immoral' !?
.

Popular opinion in Pakistan holds Musharraf responsible for the price of rice going up for example when in reality it is a result of global economics and is not the fault of one individual.

Because of "popular opinions" like this I for one am reluctant to accept them or to take them seriously.

P.S. There is no such thing as the American Raj.
 
.
Oh well. It seems like the new government is still doing exactly the same thing as what they were criticizing Musharraf for doing :cheesy: Democracy in Pakistan is not a solution.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom