Reference against Justice Isa was a ‘mistake’: Imran

[HAIDER]

Reference against Justice Faiz Isa:

It is not my fault, I did not even know Justice Faiz Isa, General Bajwa and General Faiz sent the reference, we forwarded it: Imran Khan

https://twitter.com/x/status/1684102501774286855

But Isa failed to provide money trail ............

 

[muhammadhafeezmalik]

But Isa failed to provide money trail ............

Isa was not supposed to provide money trail as these were not his properties.

 

[HAIDER]

Isa was not supposed to provide money trail as these were not his properties.

lolllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll .... yes all govt mulazim has wealth under other's name ... so stop defending.... you know very well...

 

[Thəorətic Muslim]

Isa was not supposed to provide money trail as these were not his properties.

As if his wife did.

What's that quote, a bad apple can spoil an entire bushel?

 

[Babaasif]

But Isa failed to provide money trail ............

But did Isa get convicted

 

[muhammadhafeezmalik]

As if his wife did.

What's that quote, a bad apple can spoil an entire bushel?

His wife provided all details, PTI Chairman the then PM Imran Khan changed half a dozen chairmen FBRs, finally he got one who was willing to reject that money trail.

lolllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll .... yes all govt mulazim has wealth under other's name ... so stop defending.... you know very well...

Would you like provide us detail of properties of Imran Khan's children and his wives?? Imran khan elected MNA on 2002 he gave divorce to Jamima Khan on 2004, did he provide wealth statement of his wife at that time??

 

[Mav3rick]

Reference against Justice Faiz Isa:

It is not my fault, I did not even know Justice Faiz Isa, General Bajwa and General Faiz sent the reference, we forwarded it: Imran Khan

https://twitter.com/x/status/1684102501774286855

And people still expect this ignorant, senseless, egoistical munafiq-e-aala to be their savior!

Whatever was bad, it was because of others where he simply played post-office; and whatever was good, it was all him. What a douche!

And the brainwashed, ignorant brigade which is so against Isa, need to do a little bit of research about him and why the reference was actually filed. Not just that, the fact that after he had defeated the reference against himself, he voluntarily released his financial details and tax returns to the public!

Perhaps he is the most honest and upright judge there is today in the Supreme Court and it is quite possible that all the misled, misguided PTI followers would be singing his praises very soon.

 

[muhammadhafeezmalik]

And people still expect this ignorant, senseless, egoistical munafiq-e-aala to be their savior!

Whatever was bad, it was because of others where he simply played post-office; and whatever was good, it was all him. What a douche!

And the brainwashed, ignorant brigade which is so against Isa, need to do a little bit of research about him and why the reference was actually filed. Not just that, the fact that after he had defeated the reference against himself, he voluntarily released his financial details and tax returns to the public!

Perhaps he is the most honest and upright judge there is today in the Supreme Court and it is quite possible that all the misled, misguided PTI followers would be singing his praises very soon.

He has not taken even one highly subsidised plot from government, while other hum-khiyal (like minded) judges got three three plots in very dubious manner. They are the best judges according to Insafis. They were so upright judges that were listening the cases against this housing colonies from where they benefited themselves.

 

[HAIDER]

His wife provided all details, PTI Chairman the then PM Imran Khan changed half a dozen chairmen FBRs, finally he got one who was willing to reject that money trail.


Would you like provide us detail of properties of Imran Khan's children and his wives?? Imran khan elected MNA on 2002 he gave divorce to Jamima Khan on 2004, did he provide wealth statement of his wife at that time??

PMLN govt is in power and digging for anything they found against Imran Khan, if your statement has any substance PMLN govt and establishment would have done that.

 

[Mav3rick]

He has not taken even one highly subsidised plot from government, while other hum-khiyal (like minded) judges got three three plots in very dubious manner. They are the best judges according to Insafis. They were so upright judges that were listening the cases against this housing colonies from where they benefited themselves.

A very vast majority of Pakistanis is led on through BS and propaganda. It is in our nature to latch on to the lie that suits our political acumen and desires. We are a group of incompetent, corrupt and evil people and so there are many who would rather believe in Youtube, Whatsapp and Facebook stories planted precisely to lure them into a paradise of their own choosing where their leader is the only righteous one and all others are spawns of the devil.

 

[Thəorətic Muslim]

His wife provided all details, PTI Chairman the then PM Imran Khan changed half a dozen chairmen FBRs, finally he got one who was willing to reject that money trail.

Only thing she provided was deflection of questions onto others.

Here let me show you jaahil patwaris.

Deflection of questions:
Q: Where did you get the money to buy all your current properties?
A: Wh@t abOut !MRan KhAn?

Actual answers to question:
Q: Where did you get the money to buy all your current properties?
A: Here is all the tax filings I've made in the pat 10 years as you can see my income supported my ability to save up money to buy properties.

Do you see the difference?

 

[muhammadhafeezmalik]

Only thing she provided was deflection of questions onto others.

Here let me show you jaahil patwaris.

Deflection of questions:
Q: Where did you get the money to buy all your current properties?
A: Wh@t abOut !MRan KhAn?

Actual answers to question:
Q: Where did you get the money to buy all your current properties?
A: Here is all the tax filings I've made in the pat 10 years as you can see my income supported my ability to save up money to buy properties.

Do you see the difference?

She said I paid more tax than Imran Khan and I own less properties than Imran Khan, so all my earnings were legal, she is a regular tax filer from early 90s.

Mrs Isa said she paid tax of Rs576,540 in 2018 from the taxable income of Rs4 million while for the year 2019 she paid Rs809,970 on the income of Rs5.3 million. It was said she was not receiving FBR notices on June 25, she said, adding that the very day she had lost her father. This false pretext of not receiving the notices was then used to paste notices on the gate of her residence to humiliate her in front of her household staff and everyone in the neighbourhood, she alleged.

She disclosed that when she was in Quetta with her husband, they had not only received threats but also terrorists carried out an attack. “I feared that the next terrorist attack may be successful and I wanted to secure my children’s future,” the statement said, adding she helped them buy two properties in a relatively cheap area on the outskirts of London.

Her net assets worth Rs124 million were declared with the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), Mrs Sarina Isa in her first detailed response submitted the money trail, source of income and other relevant record of the assets after the presidential reference against her husband was quashed, sources said. "Mrs Sarina Isa has had total assets worth Rs124 million. Her total assets worth Rs45.4 million in Pakistan and Rs78 million abroad [UK]. She submitted certificates issued by banks (UBL & Standard Chartered) in respect of foreign currency (pounds) account showing deposits for the years 2003 to 2013 amounting to 671, 490 British pounds and remittances abroad during the years 2003-2013 amounting to 698, 002 British pounds," a senior official engaged with FBR probe team told Geo News on Friday.

Her net assets worth Rs124 million were declared with the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), Mrs Sarina Isa in her first detailed response submitted the money trail, source of income and other relevant record of the assets after the presidential reference against her husband was quashed, sources said. "Mrs Sarina Isa has had total assets worth Rs124 million. Her total assets worth Rs45.4 million in Pakistan and Rs78 million abroad [UK]. She submitted certificates issued by banks (UBL & Standard Chartered) in respect of foreign currency (pounds) account showing deposits for the years 2003 to 2013 amounting to 671, 490 British pounds and remittances abroad during the years 2003-2013 amounting to 698, 002 British pounds," a senior official engaged with FBR probe team told Geo News on Friday.

She has submitted details of return of income, wealth statement and foreign income and assets statement for the tax years 2018 and 2019 in an effort to explain when, where and how she acquired her offshore, official further revealed seeking anonymity. She, however, did not give more details on this specific matter (London properties) as saying, "FBR is well aware of her source of income as she has been filer from early 90s."

In light of the Supreme Court verdict in the case, whereby the matter was forwarded to FBR, the office of Commissioner Inland Revenue and International Taxes Zone served notices on Sarina Isa (wife), Sehar Isa (daughter) and Arsalan Isa (son) last week.

Mrs Sarina Isa submitted a record of her salaries earned during her employment at the Karachi American School. She also provided details of the properties sold and bought in Karachi, including the taxes paid to the government on these assets.

Among her immovable properties worth Rs52,340,010, she disclosed her first immovable property worth Rs12, 020,660 with 50 percent share of children in 50-Coniston Court in London, according to her statement submitted with FBR officials. Second immovable property worth Rs19,181,050 with 50 percent share with her son in 40-Oakdale Road London was showed in returns while another moveable property worth Rs21,138,300 with 50 percent share with her daughter in 90-Adelaide Road London declared, read her financial statement for year 2019.

Sources further said that she mentioned the agricultural land gifted by her father. She also told the tax authorities that her husband does not have any link to her London properties, sources said, adding that she also stated that she declared the three London properties in tax returns filed last year.

Mrs Sarina Isa has had savings worth Rs21,650,000 in National Savings Center, DHA Karachi. She got receivables amounting Rs10,979,180 from her father in July 2018. The amount came through banking channel, informed officials said.

Mrs Sarina Isa also has had an investment worth Rs25,454,310, according to her financial statement. Her foreign income remained Rs4,731,076 in tax year 2019. Sarina Faez Isa also has had Rs25,454,310 in her foreign bank account in England, added the officials. Judge Isa's wife further revealed that she paid Rs1,386,510 in account of taxes in past two years, her FBR's record showed.

In her financial statement she submitted details of her national savings total amounting Rs21.7 million and its tax deduction certificates a well-informed officials continued to reveal. Mrs Sarina Isa also received Rs17,470,480 from her daughter who lived abroad in tax years 2018 and 2019, FBR's record showed.

In her agriculture property, she showed 24.7 acres land at Deh Korar, Tapa Zangipur Jacobabad. She also showed another piece of land of 148.21 acres in Jacobabad. Agriculture land was also showed in Dera Murad Jamali, commercial and industrial land in Shah Latif Town in Karachi and Clifton, according to financial statement. But she did not show her total agriculture income as it, according to her, was not taxable income.

“My son worked in an estate agency and also did some private contractual work,” the statement said, adding her son-in-law was working for the UK Ministry of Justice and her daughter-in-law worked as a financial analyst in London.

“If I wanted to conceal our ownership of properties we could have easily purchased them using a sham offshore company to hide the properties ‘real owners’. If you don’t believe me, please ask Prime Minister Khan and his well experienced coterie as to how they concealed their own ownership properties abroad,” she alleged.

“FBR also asked for the money trail for the properties,” she said, adding she didn’t know what the FBR meant by money trail. “Please explain and identify the provision in the Income Tax Ordinance (ITO) 2001 where money trail is mentioned so that she can understand and answer the question.”


She also enclosed along with her statement to FBR return of income, wealth statement and foreign income and assets statement for the year 2018, 2019, certificate issued by UBL, Standard Chartered Bank’s certificate in respect of the foreign currency account of December 2019 showing deposits for the year 2003 to 2013 amounting to pounds 671,490 and remittances abroad during the years 2003 to 2013 amounting to pounds 698,002.

Moreover, she also annexed investment position certificate of the National Saving Centre (NSC), different tax deduction certificates issued by NSC, the property registers maintained by the Land Registry showing the date and price of all the three properties, pictures of the envelopes attached to the gate and returning the open original envelopes with notices to her daughter and son.

Justice Isa’s wife makes public her reply to FBR

Seeks tax records and property details of PM, law minister, ARU chairman, ex-AG and their families.

www.dawn.com

 

[Thəorətic Muslim]

She said I paid more tax than Imran Khan and I own less properties than Imran Khan, so all my earnings were legal, she is a regular tax filer from early 90s.

July 2020 meanwhile the court was still asking questions in April 2021: https://www.dawn.com/news/1619456


According to sources, the FBR has submitted the report, seeking payment of Rs 35 million tax dues from Cerina Isa, to the Registrar of the apex court.

The report quoted the worth of the properties held by Cerina Isa to Rs 104.6 million and further claiming that only the money trail of properties worth Rs 23 million was found.

FBR submits report on Cerina Isa's properties to SC: sources

The report quoted the worth of the properties held by Cerina Isa to Rs 104.6 million.

arynews.tv

But she did not show her total agriculture income as it, according to her, was not taxable income.

Not taxable income was not shown. Yet:

FBR disputes money trail, Sarina Isa says her total income not considered

The Federal Bureau of Revenue (FBR) has declared the money trail provided by Sarina Isa – the wife of Supreme Court judge Justice Faez Isa – unsatisfactory and

www.24newshd.tv

On the other hand, the wife of the senior Supreme judge noted, the sources say, that the FBR neither included the income obtained from her 2,243 kanals of agriculture land nor the money received through the Clifton properties in Karachi. Even her income through employment wasn’t made part of the London properties, she said in her reply to the FBR.

 

[fitpOsitive]

Reference against Isa was a ‘mistake’: Imran​

PTI to file petition in IHC today challenging harassment of party’s social media activists

---

Hasnaat Malik April 14, 2022

Supreme Court Judge Justice Qazi Faez Isa. PHOTO: FILE

---

ISLAMABAD:
Former premier Imran Khan has admitted that the filing of a presidential reference for the removal of Supreme Court’s Justice Qazi Faez Isa was a mistake.

The former prime minister conceded his “mistake” during a meeting with the Insaf Lawyers Forum (ILF) members on Tuesday.

The purpose of the meeting was to activate the party’s legal wing in the present scenario wherein the PTI’s social media activists were being harassed by the law enforcement agencies.
Several participants of the meeting have confirmed to The Express Tribune that the ex-PM admitted that the filing of a presidential reference against Justice Isa was a mistake as the then relevant officials had misguided his government about the facts of the case.

Imran was not interested in pursuing the reference against the SC judge for the last couple of years. It has been learnt that former attorney general for Pakistan Khalid Jawed Khan had convinced him that Justice Isa was an honest judge and he was misled in this case.

Read More: Curative review: CJ’s role ‘crucial’ in Justice Isa case

A senior PTI lawyer said that Imran believed that one section within the superior judiciary was annoyed with the party because of the filing of the reference against Justice Isa. “Even though the architect of that reference was someone else,” the lawyer added.

However, senior lawyers say that Imran, being the chief executive of the country, could not be absolved as the reference was filed on his instructions.

Reference against Isa was a ‘mistake’: Imran | The Express Tribune

PTI to file petition in IHC today challenging harassment of party’s social media activists

tribune.com.pk

Pakistan is facing a locust outbreak of corruption. The people who are categorizing these locusts as good or bad are locusts themselves.
It's doesn't need any sorting, it needs sprays.

 

[muhammadhafeezmalik]

July 2020 meanwhile the court was still asking questions in April 2021: https://www.dawn.com/news/1619456


According to sources, the FBR has submitted the report, seeking payment of Rs 35 million tax dues from Cerina Isa, to the Registrar of the apex court.

The report quoted the worth of the properties held by Cerina Isa to Rs 104.6 million and further claiming that only the money trail of properties worth Rs 23 million was found.

FBR submits report on Cerina Isa's properties to SC: sources

The report quoted the worth of the properties held by Cerina Isa to Rs 104.6 million.

arynews.tv

Not taxable income was not shown. Yet:

FBR disputes money trail, Sarina Isa says her total income not considered

The Federal Bureau of Revenue (FBR) has declared the money trail provided by Sarina Isa – the wife of Supreme Court judge Justice Faez Isa – unsatisfactory and

www.24newshd.tv

On the other hand, the wife of the senior Supreme judge noted, the sources say, that the FBR neither included the income obtained from her 2,243 kanals of agriculture land nor the money received through the Clifton properties in Karachi. Even her income through employment wasn’t made part of the London properties, she said in her reply to the FBR.

Imran Khan had to change five chairmen FBR, finally he got one who was willing to reject the reply submitted by Serina Isa.

S.No.​	Name​	From​	To​
1)	Mr. Asim Ahmad (Current Chairman)	27.04.2022	.
2)	Dr. Muhammad Ashfaq Ahmed	24.08.2021	27.04.2022
3)	Mr. Asim Ahmad	09.04.2021	24.08.2021
4)	Mr. Muhammad Javed Ghani	07.07.2020	09.04.2021
5)	Ms. Nausheen Javaid Amjad	08.04.2020	06.07.2020
6)	Ms. Nausheen Javaid Amjad (Acting Chairperson)	06.01.2020	08.04.2020
7)	Syed Muhammmad Shabbar Zaidi	10.05.2019	06.01.2020

Even the biased judge Umer Ata Bandyal noted that the FBR had ignored questions regarding the rent Ms Isa was getting from a property in the Clifton area of Karachi, as well as the income she got from a school.

She was teaching in an American School and earning a taxable income since early 90s, yet PTI trolled her for that.