R u knucklehead or something??
Cant u get this in to ur head that when Hindu families were sending their elder son to join Khalsa army as a long tradition as ,they never saw Sikhism as some alien religion ,but an offset their own Hindu religion ???
And why This tradition continued into 20th century,where Hindu families of Punjab ,get their elder son baptized as a Sikh sardar ??
If those Hindus had seen Khalsa army as some alien religious forces nothing to do with hindus why would they their sons to become a sardar himself when u said there was no compulsion to do so.
And if it was only for the lure of principle of sikhism,they why not the whole family adopted Sikh religion and choose to donate their elder sons only??
Why no Muslim Punjabi family did have same tradition when u keep harping hard how Sufi saints popular among Sikh gurus and heavily influenced them??
The fact of the matter is that the Hindu Punjabi families didn't see Sikhism unique or separate from their own religion ,but only an offset of Hinduism with puritanical view void of unnecessary ritualistic compulsion that had sipped Hinduism over the centuries of its past history.
..
sorry buddy,Its only the khalistais who getting arrested and have beengot killed like stray dogs till now .
Dont u thinks its RSS affiliated Punjab police(majority Sikhs themselves) who is blame for this blatant injustice??
Yaar Biplob,,,
If hindus had sent their elder child to fight with khalsa,, they could have fought even being hindus,, no one would have asked them to become sikhs but for the only reason "that by becoming KHALSA something changed in them that is why they would become khalsa and not remain hindu" even muslims fought with sikhs so hindus were no different.. mate one more reason that comes to my mind- i might be wrong that sikhs never tried to forcefully convert anyone or i would say were not that good in propogating their religion,, even today its the same thing...that most of the complete families did not become sikhs as your saying and just the eldest child...
Mate no means on arguing.. just tell me that how would u like if u lived in lets say pakistan with islam dominated country and hell bent on making you muslim even if you wanted to be a hindu or you are hindu...
U would not like certainly... that is what the RSS is all about...
then why u are behind that sikhs came from hindus... then where did hindus came from... where did muslims came from...
Avval allah noor upay kudrat ke sab bandeh....
So just chill ur a hindu and be happy and loyal hindu..
we are sikhs and let us be happy with it...
sorry buddy,Its only the khalistais who getting arrested and have beengot killed like stray dogs till now .
Dont u thinks its RSS affiliated Punjab police(majority Sikhs themselves) who is blame for this blatant injustice??
There was nice line probably in starting of this thread which justifies what you are sayin..."Jeh sikh nu sikh na mare ta kaum kade na haare"