What's new

Qatar’s Race for Air Power

Zarvan

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 28, 2011
Messages
54,470
Reaction score
87
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
TYPHOON_MIRAGE_1021.jpg

MACRON_IN_QATAR_725.jpg

French president Emmanuel Macron, Eric Trappier, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Dassault Aviation and Cheik Tamim bin Hamad al-Thani Emir of Qatar attend the signature of order for 12 Rafale jet fighters for the Qatari Air Force. Photo Présidence de la république/P.Servent
In recent months Qatar defense officials were busy signing orders and deals for 96 new fighters, in a shopping spree aimed to scale the country’s minuscule air force eightfold. When (and if) those deliveries are completed, the Qatari Emiri Air Force (QEAF) will increase its order of battle from the current nine Mirage 2000-5 fighters to 96 modern, 4.5 Generation combat jets armed with the latest weapons the Western world can offer.

Yesterday Doha confirmed the acquisition of 24 Eurofighter Typhoon combat planes in an order worth US$8 billion (£6 billion), following the previous announcement on such purchase in September. Delivery is expected to commence in late 2022 with BAE Systemsacting as the prime contractor for both the provision of the aircraft and the agreed arrangements for the in-service support and initial training. Two years ago, Qatar signed a similar order for 24 Rafale fighter jets from Dassault, under a $7 billion (€6 billion) order, and last week exercised the option to buy 12 more, raising the total number to 36.

In June 2017 Qatar and the USA agreed on the sale of 36 Boeing F-15QA, an advanced version of the American strike fighters that has recently won increased interest in the Middle East. The deal with Qatar was estimated to cost $12 billion. Before that announcement, the US said it is ready to deliver Qatar up to 72 of the jets, for $21 billion. The unconfirmed news from Qatar came soon after the US criticized Doha for alleged ties with terrorist groups, taking side with the Saudi-led Arab coalition that confronted Qatar.

RAFALE_QATAR_1021.jpg

36 Rafale fighter jets are currently on order for the Qatar Emiri Air Force (QEAF). Photo: Dassault Aviation – M. Alleaume
72 was the number of planes Qatar has initially been planning to buy, and the F-15 was one of several options Doha evaluated, that also included the French Rafale and European Typhoon. Lockheed Martin F-35 and F-16, Boeing F-18E/F and SAAB Gripen were also assessed but not part of those shortlisted for the final pick. Since the French Rafale was already selected and firmed in order, Qatar could not pursue with full acquisition of the F-15QE. Nevertheless, as Qatar values those arms packages for their political value, it seems that splitting the border between the USA and the UK would earn Doha the expected political dividends. As London was the first to finalize a deal, a contract with Boeing for the F-15QA is now expected.

rafale_vertical_qatar_1021.jpg

Qatar will receive with its Rafales a full complement of METEOR, MICA, and SCALP missiles, and HAMMER air/ground guided bombs. Photo: Dassault Aviation.
Besides the aircraft producers, weapon manufacturers will also become major beneficiaries. Raytheon and Lockheed Martin are likely to win their share if the F-15QA acquisition matures. Meanwhile, MBDA is positioned to become a significant supplier to Qatar – the recent Typhoon order also covers acquisition of Meteor Air/Air missiles (AAM) and Brimstone air/ground missiles, both produced by MBDA. It also includes Paveway IV guided bombs built by Raytheon in the UK. MBDA also benefit from the Rafale deal, providing the Meteor AAM, along with two types of MICA AAMs (radar and IR guided), SCALP cruise missiles, Exocet anti-ship missiles and Safran (Sagem DS) produced Hammer air/surface guided munitions. Meteor and SCALP are two weapons expected to extend the reach of QEAF way beyond its borders, as the Meteor offers an operational range beyond 100 km, the most extended engagement range among Western air/air missiles and SCALP providing a precision strike capability at ranges more than 250 km away.

In its move to bolster its military power Qatar take an example from Singapore, that established its military power, particularly the air force, to scale with its economic weight, rather than the size of the population or geographic scale. But, while it took Singapore decades to bring its military to airpower to its current size, oil-rich Qatar wants to do it in few years, and it has the financial resources to do that. This rapid growth is not merely a whim; the QEAF prepares for a future where allied forces might reduce their presence in Al Udeid airbase, thus leave Qatar vulnerable. Qatar currently hosts tens of thousands of airmen and hundreds of combat planes from the USA, UK, and Australia. Those countries could withdraw their forces as operations against ISIL and Taliban are ceased. The friction with neighboring countries, which erupted this summer, only added urgency to Doha’s contingency plans.

How Qatar plans to operate and maintain those planes and diversified force? Each of the deals includes support and training services for air and ground crews, both in France, the UK and in Qatar. But these services often focus on the transition of skilled operators, not training cadets. But, can money solve this complex logistical puzzle?

The Emiri’s air force currently operates only 12 training and fighter jets and do not have pilots to man the growing combat fleet. Despite the establishment of significant training operations to train new pilots (with the acquisition of a fleet of Pilatus PC-9 turboprop trainers in 2012), Qatar’s small population will not likely support such growth in the next few years. The shortage brought Qatar to outsource the services of experienced pilots, a concept practiced by many of the oil-rich countries in the region. Reliance on contractor support for maintaining combat-ready forces of each type, using weapon and avionics configurations identical to the original version (Francs and Britain) would also make it simpler to rely on such resources, rather than establish local support.

TYPHOON_UDEID_725.jpg

During the week-long exercise, Qatari pilots tested their combat skills in their Mirage Jets against the British pilots flying the Typhoons. They also had the opportunity to get to learn about the Typhoon’s capabilities and weapons systems they are about to receive. Photo: Crown Copyright, UK MOD.
Last month Britain’s Royal Air Force (RAF) completed a training deployment to Al Udeid in Qatar, where four Typhoon fighters from No 29(R) Squadron joined the QEAF Mirage 2000-5 for a week-long exercise. Many of the QEAF pilots involved in this exercise will be amongst the first to be trained to fly them in Great Britain.

This cooperation will increase shortly, under the agreement signed between the two countries to establish a Joint Operation Squadron (JOS); this unique formation provides the nucleus of future joint operations between the Qatar Emiri Air Force and the RAF. Initially, the JOS will rely on RAF No. 12 Squadron. The squadron is currently operating Tornados and soon will transition to the future Typhoon force. The joint operation will bring Qatari air and support crews to train with their British colleagues at RAF Coningsby, Lincolnshire UK. As the JOS assumes combat readiness, with the goal to enhance the Qatari Air Force to provide aerial security over the peninsula during the FIFA 2022 World Cup events. “The Qataris will not be a permanent part of the squadron but will be integrated ahead of the delivery of the Typhoon aircraft. The move will provide the country with valuable joint frontline experience on an RAF Typhoon Squadron and speed up their preparation for when their own jets are delivered.” the UK MOD announced.

Such close cooperation with a major ally to seems to establish an ‘insurance policy’ to Qatar in its ongoing rift with its Arab neighbors. By spreading substantial acquisitions among the same arms suppliers that provide similar hardware to its (not so friendly) neighbors, Doha strengthens its weight by binding those countries to maintain their support to the small nation, regardless to regional and political pressures.

Qatari_typhoon_patch_725.jpg

A Qatar-2017 Typhoon patch prepared for Squadron 29(R) exercise in Qatar. Photo: Crown Copyright, UK MOD. exercise.

http://defense-update.com/20171211_qatar_air_power.html
 
. .
Qatar just announced the increase in the Rafales order from 24 to 36. They will get the first examples starting this year.
This has been discussed for a long time ago on PakDef back in the day, but I think Pakistan should do whatever is possible to keep the IAF from inducting the Mirage 2000-5s of the QAF, even if it means buying them for itself. Such a buy could down the road lead to acquiring the ones operated by UAE as well and in the face of not being able to get additional F-16s, would provide Pakistan with a complementary fighter that has been upgraded over the years and is on par, if not better than the PAF F-16s.
 
.
Qatari EF Typhoon Tranche 3+ beat Rafale and F-15


QEAF's F-15QAs & Rafales during 12 Squadron deployments to Qatar.
In short QEAF EF Typhoons in DACT beat the F15QA and Rafale

QEAF AlDhariat Squadron pilots also stated the new ECRS radar is already delivering significant tactical advantage, allowing Eurofighter pilots to track targets at greater range, launch their missiles & 'jump into the notch' whilst maintaining missile guidance.



EF Typhoon Tranche 3+ beat Rafale and F-15
1668085390364.png


Rafale beat F-15
1668085436182.png


1668085560700.png
 
.
Qatari EF Typhoon Tranche 3+ beat Rafale and F-15


QEAF's F-15QAs & Rafales during 12 Squadron deployments to Qatar.
In short QEAF EF Typhoons in DACT beat the F15QA and Rafale

QEAF AlDhariat Squadron pilots also stated the new ECRS radar is already delivering significant tactical advantage, allowing Eurofighter pilots to track targets at greater range, launch their missiles & 'jump into the notch' whilst maintaining missile guidance.



EF Typhoon Tranche 3+ beat Rafale and F-15
View attachment 895203

Rafale beat F-15
View attachment 895205

View attachment 895206
Hi is it possible for your to confirm who were the pilots operating EF & Rafale to beat F15 don’t get me wrong but possiblity is EF & Rafale might be flying by their own pilots & QAF pilots will be back seat something like
and if it’s not the case then what’s the lack in between mention two fighters against F15 which is believe is the latest version of im not wrong
if possible to answer
thank you
 
.
Hi is it possible for your to confirm who were the pilots operating EF & Rafale to beat F15 don’t get me wrong but possiblity is EF & Rafale might be flying by their own pilots & QAF pilots will be back seat something like
and if it’s not the case then what’s the lack in between mention two fighters against F15 which is believe is the latest version of im not wrong
if possible to answer
thank you


Qatari pilots were operating EF & Rafale to beat F15


Air to ground attack
F-15QA is better than Eurofighter for air to ground attack mission


BVR Combat
F-15QA can’t out-turn the Eurofighter. Its huge RCS can be targeted at over 220km even with CAPTOR-M radar .... the new ECRS MK-2 radar is already delivering significant tactical advantage, allowing Eurofighter pilots to track targets at greater range

and METEOR Air to Air Missile is very lethal weapon

BVR rating
Eurofighter : 91%
F-15QA : 88%


Dog Fight
Delta designs allow Eurofighter for good maneuverability at high speed

Dogfight Rating
Eurofighter : 75%
F-15QA : 64%

Maneuverability
Eurofighter : 9.5/10
F-15QA :8.2/10
 
Last edited:
. .
Qatar just announced the increase in the Rafales order from 24 to 36. They will get the first examples starting this year.
This has been discussed for a long time ago on PakDef back in the day, but I think Pakistan should do whatever is possible to keep the IAF from inducting the Mirage 2000-5s of the QAF, even if it means buying them for itself. Such a buy could down the road lead to acquiring the ones operated by UAE as well and in the face of not being able to get additional F-16s, would provide Pakistan with a complementary fighter that has been upgraded over the years and is on par, if not better than the PAF F-16s.

Couldn't agree more,

I won't maybe worry too much about the typhoons, but the Mirages are a MUST !
even if we have to sell some land ...
 
. .
Couldn't agree more,

I won't maybe worry too much about the typhoons, but the Mirages are a MUST !
even if we have to sell some land ...
I think the Mirage ship has sailed now with J-10 induction. But we should still ensure IAF does not get them down the road through whatever diplomatic channels.
 
.
Mirage 2000-5s of the QAF, even if it means buying them for itself.

For Qatar to sell Mirages to Pakistan would need approval from France which they won't give. Anyways we would soon start to phase out our mirage fleet starting next decade (hopefully) and as production line of mirages shut down long ago we are facing issues in maintaining our existing and hence had to purchase retired aircrafts of French air force to scavenge them for spare parts induction more mirages now makes no sense, had we wanted to we would have approached UAE to purchase them.
 
Last edited:
. .
For Qatar to sell Mirages to Pakistan would need approval from France which they won't give. Anyways we would soon start to phase out our mirage fleet starting next decade (hopefully) and as production line of mirages shut down long ago we are facing issues in maintaining our existing and hence had to purchase retired aircrafts of French air force to scavenge them for spare parts induction more mirages now makes no sense, had we wanted to we would have approached UAE to purchase them.
No you won't. After upgrading the fleet, they will be in Indian service for another 20 years at least.
 
.
An older relative (former PAF) helped set-up one of the Gulf Air Forces. Pilot candidates were difficult to select in a small population pool and in addition to physical/academic criteria they had to be filtered for family allegiance and that made the pool even smaller. Eventually it was set-up but pilots fly the jets like airliners. No low-level/all weather flying, and very limited night time combat capability.

And that was the country with 1 type of fighter jet. Given Qatar had to go outside for its police/security needs for the World Cup, I am keen to understand how a population pool of 1M can be tapped into to fly 100+ Gen 4 jets. No country flies more than one Gen 4 jets, and they have 3. I know the ground story (its all outsourced and contracted) but I am curious how many pilots are there for these aircraft.
 
.
An older relative (former PAF) helped set-up one of the Gulf Air Forces. Pilot candidates were difficult to select in a small population pool and in addition to physical/academic criteria they had to be filtered for family allegiance and that made the pool even smaller. Eventually it was set-up but pilots fly the jets like airliners. No low-level/all weather flying, and very limited night time combat capability.

And that was the country with 1 type of fighter jet. Given Qatar had to go outside for its police/security needs for the World Cup, I am keen to understand how a population pool of 1M can be tapped into to fly 100+ Gen 4 jets. No country flies more than one Gen 4 jets, and they have 3. I know the ground story (its all outsourced and contracted) but I am curious how many pilots are there for these aircraft.
They will have pilots from US and Europe flying them as contractors alongside Qataris
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom