What's new

Punjab refuses to hand over Gurdaspur terror probe to NIA.

Juggernautjatt

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
1,426
Reaction score
-4
Country
India
Location
India
Ruchika M Khanna
Tribune News Service
Chandigarh, August 19


The Punjab Government has refused to hand over the investigation of the first-ever suspected Fidayeen attack in the state at Dinanagar on July 27 to the National Investigation Agency (NIA) saying it can handle the probe on its own.

Sources in the state government said Director General of Police Sumedh Singh Saini met with officials of the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) and conveyed the state’s decision to continue with their probe claiming the investigation had reached a “crucial stage” and handing it over now could hinder its pace.

The NIA has been asking the MHA to allow it to take over the investigation of the Dinanagar attack so that a watertight case could be made to bring out the complicity of Pakistan in the attacks.

The Punjab Government is under fire from Central security agencies over the evidence collected and shared with them, especially the GPS coordinates. Both Intelligence Bureau and Border Security Force (BSF) have expressed their reservations over the “handling” of evidence by the Punjab Police — a charge strongly denied by Punjab Government.

While the sources refused to divulge anything on the status of the Punjab Police’s investigation citing international ramifications, they insisted the probe was continuing in the right direction.

“It was a conscious decision not to allow the Army take over the operation on the day of the attack. It was an attack on the police force and the police had to deal with it on its own,” said the source.

A decision had been taken at the highest level that the investigation, too, should be handled by the Punjab Police, considering its experience in dealing with cross-border terror and its intelligence on the fringe elements that could have supported the three terrorists killed in Dinanagar, the source added.

A senior official in the NIA said under the NIA Act, 2008, any state government which witnesses an attack, where the complicity of another country is suspected, should approach the Ministry of Home Affairs seeking its transfer to the NIA.

“In case of the Gurdaspur attack, the Punjab Government did not approach the MHA. But the NIA asked the Home Ministry that the case be transferred to them since it was a fit case to be dealt by the agency.

It is up to the ministry to decide. During the recent attack in Jammu and Kashmir’s Udhampur, the Home Ministry directly asked the NIA to take over the investigation,” the official said.

The NIA had the best resources to decipher the crucial forensic and scientific evidence collected from the crime scene, the official said.“We can take up the Dinanagar case probe, but we may face hurdles while conducting the investigation on the ground,” said another NIA official.

Under the NIA Act, a “scheduled offence” includes the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act and offences relating to waging war against India. The Dinanagar incident falls in this category.

“Though we cannot say anything in this regard, considering its international ramifications, the Punjab Police are doing a good job,” said Sukhbir Singh Badal, Punjab Deputy Chief Minister, who holds the charge of Home department. Badal said the state government had beefed up security in the border areas by providing more jeeps and motorcycles for patrolling.

(With input from Shaurya K Gurung in Delhi)
Punjab refuses to hand over Gurdaspur terror probe to NIA
 
. .
Ruchika M Khanna
Tribune News Service
Chandigarh, August 19


The Punjab Government has refused to hand over the investigation of the first-ever suspected Fidayeen attack in the state at Dinanagar on July 27 to the National Investigation Agency (NIA) saying it can handle the probe on its own.

Sources in the state government said Director General of Police Sumedh Singh Saini met with officials of the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) and conveyed the state’s decision to continue with their probe claiming the investigation had reached a “crucial stage” and handing it over now could hinder its pace.

The NIA has been asking the MHA to allow it to take over the investigation of the Dinanagar attack so that a watertight case could be made to bring out the complicity of Pakistan in the attacks.

The Punjab Government is under fire from Central security agencies over the evidence collected and shared with them, especially the GPS coordinates. Both Intelligence Bureau and Border Security Force (BSF) have expressed their reservations over the “handling” of evidence by the Punjab Police — a charge strongly denied by Punjab Government.

While the sources refused to divulge anything on the status of the Punjab Police’s investigation citing international ramifications, they insisted the probe was continuing in the right direction.

“It was a conscious decision not to allow the Army take over the operation on the day of the attack. It was an attack on the police force and the police had to deal with it on its own,” said the source.

A decision had been taken at the highest level that the investigation, too, should be handled by the Punjab Police, considering its experience in dealing with cross-border terror and its intelligence on the fringe elements that could have supported the three terrorists killed in Dinanagar, the source added.

A senior official in the NIA said under the NIA Act, 2008, any state government which witnesses an attack, where the complicity of another country is suspected, should approach the Ministry of Home Affairs seeking its transfer to the NIA.

“In case of the Gurdaspur attack, the Punjab Government did not approach the MHA. But the NIA asked the Home Ministry that the case be transferred to them since it was a fit case to be dealt by the agency.

It is up to the ministry to decide. During the recent attack in Jammu and Kashmir’s Udhampur, the Home Ministry directly asked the NIA to take over the investigation,” the official said.

The NIA had the best resources to decipher the crucial forensic and scientific evidence collected from the crime scene, the official said.“We can take up the Dinanagar case probe, but we may face hurdles while conducting the investigation on the ground,” said another NIA official.

Under the NIA Act, a “scheduled offence” includes the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act and offences relating to waging war against India. The Dinanagar incident falls in this category.

“Though we cannot say anything in this regard, considering its international ramifications, the Punjab Police are doing a good job,” said Sukhbir Singh Badal, Punjab Deputy Chief Minister, who holds the charge of Home department. Badal said the state government had beefed up security in the border areas by providing more jeeps and motorcycles for patrolling.

(With input from Shaurya K Gurung in Delhi)
Punjab refuses to hand over Gurdaspur terror probe to NIA
F*cking clowns- they bungled their response to the attack and now they are hampering the best counter terror investigative agency in India from doing their job.


The NIA should have the authority to supersede any local agency when it comes to investigating terror attacks in India no matter where they occur, the NIA act should be amended accordingly. Hopefully the MHA makes the right call and tells the Punjab police to get lost and orders the NIA in.
 
.
F*cking clowns- they bungled their response to the attack and now they are hampering the best counter terror investigative agency in India from doing their job.


The NIA should have the authority to supersede any local agency when it comes to investigating terror attacks in India no matter where they occur, the NIA act should be amended accordingly. Hopefully the MHA makes the right call and tells the Punjab police to get lost and orders the NIA in.
Due to this obstinacy of Punjab government several type of conspiracy theories are emerging in social media like attack was staged to gain some sort of political benefit or something.
NIA probe is essential in this matter to curb rumours because since militancy people of state have very little faith in Punjab Police investigations.
 
.
Now some people will say that it is a ploy by Punjab Government to hide the fact that terrorists were actually Sikhs!

We must allow NIA to get to the root of the matter.
 
.
Akalies needs arm twisting by BJP. Recently their Food Processing Minister too was giving divergent statement .

Anyway I concur with @Abingdonboy NIA act needs to be tweaked to overrule the jurisdiction in investigation.

Now some people will say that it is a ploy by Punjab Government to hide the fact that terrorists were actually Sikhs!

We must allow NIA to get to the root of the matter.

What rubbish , it' not as if it has happened for the first time . Many state governments have done it earlier too. Once Tamil government had rebuffed center to hanbdover the case of one the train blast.
 
.
Due to this obstinacy of Punjab government several type of conspiracy theories are emerging in social media like attack was staged to gain some sort of political benefit or something.
NIA probe is essential in this matter to curb rumours because since militancy people of state have very little faith in Punjab Police investigations.
Typical social media response, there is no such conspiracy of course- this is simply pure arrogance on display by the Punjab police (the same arrogance that was on display during the attack and that could have got many killed).
 
. .
Typical social media response, there is no such conspiracy of course- this is simply pure arrogance on display by the Punjab police (the same arrogance that was on display during the attack and that could have got many killed).
May be there is no such conspiracy but first Punjab Government refused to give charge to Army then refuse to publicise facts of post mortem report of terrorists & now refusal to NIA. All these things are pointing to something suspicious.
 
.
May be there is no such conspiracy but first Punjab Government refused to give charge to Army then refuse to publicise facts of post mortem report of terrorists & now refusal to NIA. All these things are pointing to something suspicious.
Not really suspicious- just BS bravado from Punjab's police, they think they are the best and can handle it without federal help. Similar jurisdiction nonsense happens all the time in federal nations. The NIA should have the authority to step in as they see fit in thee cases- screw the local authorities.
 
.
Akalies needs arm twisting by BJP. Recently their Food Processing Minister too was giving divergent statement .

Anyway I concur with @Abingdonboy NIA act needs to be tweaked to overrule the jurisdiction in investigation.



What rubbish , it' not as if it has happened for the first time . Many state governments have done it earlier too. Once Tamil government had rebuffed center to hanbdover the case of one the train blast.

This is rubbish really. The TN govt didnt "rebuff" NIA. The TN Police had already nearly cracked the case by the time NIA got here, which even NIA praised them. Then they let the TN police handle on its own, after sharing of details of NIA.

Get your facts right.
 
.
This is rubbish really. The TN govt didnt "rebuff" NIA. The TN Police had already nearly cracked the case by the time NIA got here, which even NIA praised them. Then they let the TN police handle on its own, after sharing of details of NIA.

Get your facts right.


Don't get hyper, read slowly and carefully.

Chennai bomb blasts: Centre puts on hold sending NIA, NSG, forensic experts to Tamil Nadu - timesofindia-economictimes

It required interference from High Court to get the case transfered to NIA.

PIL seeks transfer of Central station bomb blast case to NIA
 
. . .

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom